Spain makes P2P filesharing illegal and kills legit Internet usage?

, posted: 29-JUN-2006 19:23

The MPAA is probably dancing a jig over Spain making peer-to-peer filesharing illegal last Thursday, but did the Spanish parliament really stop to think about how the ban will be enforced?

Instead of directly going after the filesharers themselves the Spanish have decided to make it a criminal offence for Internet providers to facilitate filesharing. It's not clear how "facilitate filesharing" is defined, but if it simply means "allowing it to happen", ISPs in Spain are in for some massive headaches. Blocking P2P is far from easy because it's possible to "hide" the traffic by using standard Internet protocol ports (like http and ftp) and encryption.

Spain seemed to be on the right track when it decided to levy a tax on recordable digital media. The tax would be paid back to copyright holders, and is probably a far more sensible way to compensate them than introducing Draconian laws that will see ISPs in the dock for failing to hold back the P2P tide.





Other related posts:
US to pressure NZ into copyright compliance?
Hyperlinking to copyrighted material is illegal: Australia
More on NZ FACT's 'Anti P2P program'


 





Comment by freitasm, on 29-JUN-2006 20:29

This just show how legislators can be insensible to modern technology. P2P has nothing to do with illegal content copy. If this is the case they should make Windows Media Player, the Apple iPod, and even the CD Recorder illegal.

Clueless people.


Comment by RaF, on 30-JUN-2006 02:01

"Spain seemed to be on the right track when it decided to levy a tax on recordable digital media"

It's wonderfull that I have to pay if I save my personal photos into Cds because someone think that ALL cd and DVD media are used to burn copyrighted media.

Only a silly person could think something like that, but all our Spanish politics are proud to be silly.


Author's note by juha, on 30-JUN-2006 06:50

By being on the right track, I meant of course that it's preferable to pay a small "copyright tax" on recordable media than facing police raids etc by the police. Valid point though, that the tax hits personal usage of non-copyrighted material.


Add a comment

Please note: comments that are inappropriate or promotional in nature will be deleted. E-mail addresses are not displayed, but you must enter a valid e-mail address to confirm your comments.

Are you a registered Geekzone user? Login to have the fields below automatically filled in for you and to enable links in comments. If you have (or qualify to have) a Geekzone Blog then your comment will be automatically confirmed and shown in this blog post.

Your name:

Your e-mail:

Your webpage:





Links to stories I've written:

Google News search for me
PC World New Zealand
Computerworld NZ
PC World and Computerworld Australia
PC World US
Computerworld US
Infoworld
NZ Herald
Virus Bulletin
PC World NZ Blog

Content copyright © Juha Saarinen. If you wish to use the content of my blog on your site, please contact me for details. I'm usually happy to share my stuff, as long as it's not for spamblogs and what have you. Attribution with a link back to the blog is always appreciated. If you wish to advertise on my blog, please drop me an email to discuss the details.

Comments policy
All comments posted on this blog are the copyright and responsibility of the submitters in question. Comments commercial and promotional in nature are not allowed. Please ensure that your comments are on topic and refrain from making personal remarks.




    follow me on Twitter





    Add to Netvibes



    Latest comments

    Bill Bennett on Trade Me, the behemoth on NZ’s Internet: Which begs the question, does TradeMe make more money from advertising than it m...

    juha on Trade Me, the behemoth on NZ’s Internet: @Edmund Yeah, page impressions are but one measure :)...

    Edmund Good on Trade Me, the behemoth on NZ’s Internet: All well and good to serve up that many pages - is anyone actually buying??...

    freitasm on Trade Me, the behemoth on NZ’s Internet: And with that they suck dry all the online advertising budget and no one else ge...

    lotech on Losers in the Apple iPad launch: Microsims are just smaller shaped SIMs - other than the size of the plastic it i...

    juha on Losers in the Apple iPad launch: @dacraka Vodafone NZ says it has MicroSIMs - I'd imagine Telecom has them too. C...

    dacraka on Losers in the Apple iPad launch: If NZ wants the 3G functionality, our mobile operators will need to come out wit...

    Foo on Losers in the Apple iPad launch: Great article Juha.@Jason - 60 days until release? Won't it be longer for NZ (Ju...

    Bnsofts on Losers in the Apple iPad launch: Ohh this is great thanks for sharing....

    freitasm on Losers in the Apple iPad launch: Phreek... Vodafone 3G network is 2100MHz only in the main centres. Everywhere th...



    Top Ten Techsplodings

    Telecom New Zealand's local lo...
    (28-APR-2006 17:32, 179240 views)
    Join New Zealand Internet blac...
    (16-FEB-2009 09:26, 132557 views)
    iTunes 7 bugs: doesn't Apple t...
    (14-SEP-2006 12:34, 91967 views)
    Working BIOS driver crack for ...
    (13-MAR-2007 16:14, 50967 views)
    The spoofed Telecom commercial...
    (19-MAY-2006 15:59, 45223 views)
    What did Materazzi say to Zida...
    (11-JUL-2006 08:20, 38972 views)
    Windows Vista problem solving ...
    (24-FEB-2007 18:16, 37380 views)
    Firefox 2.0 and Windows Vista ...
    (3-DEC-2006 12:23, 33809 views)
    Gutmann Reloaded and My Vista ...
    (26-JAN-2007 15:35, 32543 views)
    The Saddam Snuff Movie...
    (31-DEC-2006 11:25, 31235 views)




    Subscribe to RSS headline updates from: http://feeds.feedburner.com/Technozone
    Powered by FeedBurner



    Add to Google Subscribe in NewsGator Online Click here to add this RSS feed to Feedster Click here to add this RSS feed to My MSN Click here to add this RSS feed to AvantGo Click here to add this RSS feed to My Yahoo!

    Linkorama

    Modern Drunkard Magazine
    Centre for Citizen Media
    The Assimilated Negro
    The Raw Feed
    Object Dart
    Copyblogger
    Neil Sanderson's blog
    The Opinionated Diner
    Griffin's Gadgets
    Dion Hinchcliffe
    InternetNZ blog (Colin Jackson)
    Spareroom
    Off the record
    Rawiri Blundell
    KhooSuyinKhoo
    ReadWriteWeb
    Frankarr
    Tim Haines
    Darren Rowse - Problogger
    Daniel McKenzie
    The Hivelogic Narrative
    Fraser Talk
    Leaf Salon
    Bad Science
    Wanda Harland
    Kiwi Herald
    Mauricio Freitas
    Hard News
    The Geekzoner
    Mr Cokemaster
    Commercial Archive
    Kiwiblog
    Jama
    Chiefie's blog
    Generation X Y
    Not the South China Morning Post
    Nic often Wise
    Loosewire (Jeremy Wagstaff of WSJ)
    SunnyO
    BlackMagic NZ Film Blog
    Nigel Parker's MSDN blog