Geekzone: technology news, blogs, forums
Guest
Welcome Guest.
Username: Password: Auto login:
Did you know you can browse Geekzone without ads by Subscribing?
You haven't logged in yet. If you don't have an account you can register now.
  Spectec SDW-822 miniSD WLAN-11b review

Posted on 24-SEP-2007 10:45 by M Freitas. | Tags Filed under: Reviews.





Many Windows Mobile devices still come to the market lacking wireless LAN (Wi-Fi) capabilities. The reasons are many, and vary from power consumption through simple bill of materials cost.

Like myself, many users probably found perfect wireless LAN coverage at home, office or even hotels and cafes, but still have to go through their cellular data plans to connect to the Internet. While this is not a big deal as in it works, it can be costly while roaming or simply not as fast as Wi-Fi.

Spectec has released a series of miniSD Wi-Fi cards that will work on a range of Windows Mobile devices - and even on some devices not in the list as I found out.


The miniSD Wireless LAN card, with an adapter

The SDW-822 mini SD WLAN-11b is only only of the many models available. You can plug this device to Windows Mobile devices running Windows Mobile 2003 Second Edition, Windows Mobile 5.0 Pocket PC and Windows Mobile 5.0 Smartphone.

It supports the IEEE 802.11b standard providing 11 Mbps (megabits per second) maximum throughput.

For comparison, there is the SDW-825 model with support for IEEE 802.11b/g with up to 54 Mbps - probably an overkill on mobile devices.

The miniSD card requires a small driver to be loaded on your Pocket PC before its use. The driver also adds a Wireless Manager program that helps you control the miniSD WiFi card, including option to turn the radio on or off.

Spectec lists a range of devices compatible with the SDW-822 mini SD WLAN-11b and I just happen to have the Palm Treo 750v here. So we arranged for a review unit to be sent.

My first test was on the Palm Treo 750v, but I was curious about using the miniSD card with other devices and for this I tried it on the Palm Treo 700wx. The difference is that the Treo 700wx uses SD cards, while this is a miniSD card. Using a miniSD-to-SD adapter like the ones you get when buying miniSD cards, I tried the card on the Treo 700wx and it was actually recognised and worked well. I actually liked it better on the Palm Treo 700wx because the SD card slot is on the top of the unit, while on the Palm Treo 750v the slot is on the side, making it a bit hard to hold the device.


The card on a Palm Treo 750v miniSD slot


The card on a Palm Treo 700wx SD slot (with adapter)

When using with the Palm Treo 750v on a native miniSD slot you will see just a couple of milimeters pointing outside the device's body. On the Palm Treo 700wx this is a bit more noticeable, but just because I used the SD-to-miniSD adapter.

I had no problems connecting those devices to my wireless LAN Access Point, which requires WPA encryption. The SDW-822 mini SD WLAN-11b supports WEP, WPA and WPA_TKIP. I also used it with some commercial hotspots around town including those found in cafes and malls.





In terms of coverage it does well, and even inside my house, it worked through multiple walls. The driver software sometimes fails to load though, requiring a soft reset, after which the card functions ok. This happened even after I made sure there was plenty of memory available.But a couple of seconds for the soft reset didn't spoil the whole experience.

In terms of speed you will really see a difference between using Wi-Fi or cellular data, even if comparing to UMTS or CDMA. Websites load promptly and e-mail synchronisation is much faster.

I did not notice any reduction in battery life, certainly nothing different from the normal battery life on these devices I have around here - they don't usually last a full day, with all that push e-mail and checking RSS feeds around. Just in case, the driver provides a Power Saving feature that you can enable or disable.



Certainly an interesting little accessory to add to your gadget bag and to have handy when out and about with your Windows Mobile device.

Pros
  • It's Wi-Fi!
  • Easy to use
  • Really small
  • Integrates with the Windows Mobile LAN manager well

    Cons
  • Sometimes the driver fails to load (but a soft reset solves it)








    Other articles related to Reviews



    Comments

    mule
      send private message user's profile
    Comment posted by mule on 24-SEP-2007 13:08
    Any idea where can you purchase these in NZ?  I am really keen to get one for my 700wx
    freitasm
     open user's web page send private message user's profile
    Comment posted by freitasm on 24-SEP-2007 13:28
    There's one going your way...
    paradoxsm
      send private message user's profile
    Comment posted by paradoxsm on 24-SEP-2007 17:25
    Same here, This is the only feature lacking for my old faithful i-mate PocketPC
    Pakuman
      send private message user's profile
    Comment posted by Pakuman on 25-SEP-2007 10:00
    Sure would like one for my Harrier - Is there an agent in NZ?
    stanleychung
      send private message user's profile
    Comment posted by stanleychung on 25-SEP-2007 10:23
    That is absolutely unbelievable how technology has progressed. I still think WiFi USB adapters are really flash. Any ideas where i can go get one in christchurch? Keen for one for my Treo 700wx
    freitasm
     open user's web page send private message user's profile
    Comment posted by freitasm on 25-SEP-2007 10:26
    It looks like you can find some on Trademe. I am not posting the direct link to prevent spamming - search and you will find.

    Aaron1100us
      send private message user's profile
    Comment posted by Aaron1100us on 5-OCT-2007 22:51
    Can this new card be used with the Moto Q?
    freitasm
     open user's web page send private message user's profile
    Comment posted by freitasm on 6-OCT-2007 07:18
    There is a special version for Motorola Q Smartphones. Visit the Spectec page linked from the review to find more.
    Aaron1100us
      send private message user's profile
    Comment posted by Aaron1100us on 6-OCT-2007 08:34
    Yeah, it says Q 9M and Q9 GSM.  Both of those run Mobile 6.0 and the regular Q like mine runs the Mobile 5.0.  I'm wanting to know if this will work on a regular Q with the Mobile 5.0 OS?
    freitasm
     open user's web page send private message user's profile
    Comment posted by freitasm on 6-OCT-2007 08:49
    The product page says it supports both Windows Mobile 5.0 and Windows Mobile 6. In this case it makes no difference if you are using GSM or CDMA.
    marcopa87
      send private message user's profile
    Comment posted by marcopa87 on 30-MAR-2008 00:15
    good morning...
    but the cardwifi sdw-822(standard type) works im motoQ?
    what do you have to make for this?
    I have a MotoQ, and I want to use a card, but my card is a sdw-822(standard type)!
    what I make?
    Thanks

    Sorry but my english is zero, I speak only Portuguese...
    freitasm
     open user's web page send private message user's profile
    Comment posted by freitasm on 30-MAR-2008 07:12

    Spectec also supplies a card specifically designed for the Moto Q... Just visit their website.

    marcopa87
      send private message user's profile
    Comment posted by marcopa87 on 1-APR-2008 01:07
    But, the standard type card wifi work in MotoQ?
    how make a test?
    Thanks...
    freitasm
     open user's web page send private message user's profile
    Comment posted by freitasm on 1-APR-2008 13:28
    Spectec products special cards for Moto Q. You should contact Spectec directly for more information on any model that we have not tested.
    TANK
    send private message user's profile
    Comment posted by TANK on 18-AUG-2008 23:29
    I HAVE THE 700WX WITH THE SAME 822 AND ADAPTER BUT WHEN I INSERT IT INTO MY 700WX IT FREEZES IT UNTILL I EJECT IT ANY IDEA WHAT IT COULD BE AND WHAT DRIVERS SHOULD I INSTALL BCUZ IVE TRIED THE THE ONES THAT CAME ON THE DISK WITH THE WIFI 
    Post a commentPlease login or register to post a comment on this article.