Want to help us test an ads-free Geekzone? Register for webpass now

Geekzone: technology news, blogs, forums
Guest
Welcome Guest.
You haven't logged in yet. If you don't have an account you can register now.
Chorus after Ernst & Young report
Posted on 16-Dec-2013 09:28 by billbennettnz. | Tags Filed under: News.



One interpretation of the Ernst & Young report is that Chorus was correct when it claimed the drop in copper access price would mean a $1 billion funding shortfall.

The report surfaced Saturday lunchtime. Later that afternoon Chorus CEO Mark Ratcliffe issued a statement: “The report aligns with our market disclosure of 5 November and the information provided to shareholders in the letter from the chairman earlier this week”.

Another interpretation is that Chorus hasn’t tried hard enough to find alternative routes around the copper price issue.

Ernst & Young’s report outlines areas where Chorus could make savings to address the shortfall.

It’s hard to believe Chorus hadn’t already been through a similar exercise internally.

Chorus’ media statement says the company “would be unlikely to be able to meet all of its forward commitments without external support”.

This sounds like Chorus still isn’t trying hard enough.

If the company were to work through Erst & Young’s plans it could reduce the funding shortfall to as little as $200 million.

Some perspective is needed on these numbers. The project has seven years to go. The funding shortfall doesn’t all have to be found in one year.

Even a $1 billion shortfall only means less than $150 million a year. A $200 million shortfall means finding less than $30 million a year. When Chorus was part of Telecom NZ, the firm’s financial team had little trouble squeezing savings of those size from the business’ costs.

There’s a sting in the tail, the company says Erst & Young’s proposed initiatives: “Have the potential to negatively impact service levels and broadband services for consumers across New Zealand on the current network”.

Telecom NZ isn’t impressed by this warning. It responded on Sunday saying Chorus needs to come up with a proposal that doesn’t undermine its monopoly copper network.

It’s possible Chorus sees its warning as negotiating leverage. It should resist the temptation.

The obvious way out of what could become an impasse is for the government to step in and take full or partial control of Chorus.

That’s ideologically out of step with a National Party government keen on selling off state assets. Yet the government also has a strong pragmatic streak which could override ideology.

There’s an election next year. Stepping in to deal with an unpopular, possibly abusive, monopoly makes political sense. If that doesn’t happen, an alternative incoming government might deal more harshly with Chorus.




comments powered by Disqus


Trending now »

Hot discussions in our forums right now:

Sex toys and Waitangi Day - Whats your take on the flip flopping day.
Created by Mspec, last reply by networkn on 10-Feb-2016 10:01 (111 replies)
Pages... 6 7 8


Netflix Crackdown - have you been affected?
Created by Paul1977, last reply by kharris on 10-Feb-2016 13:23 (341 replies)
Pages... 21 22 23


Whats something small that really annoys you?
Created by Finch, last reply by Rikkitic on 9-Feb-2016 10:05 (473 replies)
Pages... 30 31 32


2.4ghz Wifi - You just can't win
Created by Yabanize, last reply by tdgeek on 10-Feb-2016 16:07 (31 replies)
Pages... 2 3


What is H/P Out?
Created by simon14, last reply by gbwelly on 8-Feb-2016 21:02 (14 replies)

Vodafone X - age discrimination?
Created by sxz, last reply by quickymart on 10-Feb-2016 17:31 (26 replies)
Pages... 2


Dirty water - how to flush out a hot water cylinder?
Created by jonathan18, last reply by Rikkitic on 10-Feb-2016 17:01 (13 replies)

0800 number used for scams
Created by Ford, last reply by Ford on 9-Feb-2016 18:25 (36 replies)
Pages... 2 3