Windows and Outlook search annoying you? Be in to win one of ten Lookeen Desktop Search licenses now

Geekzone: technology news, blogs, forums
Guest
Welcome Guest.
You haven't logged in yet. If you don't have an account you can register now.
Apple, Microsoft, Google technology stacks conclusions
Posted on 17-Dec-2013 08:28 by billbennettnz. | Tags Filed under: News.


computer chipContinually jumping between technology stacks feels inefficient. Would it make sense to just pick one and stick with it?

To answer the question I spent a week working exclusively with each of the three main technology stacks: Apple, Microsoft and Google. I wanted to see if this approach improves productivity and whether it is practical or limiting.

Efficient, but

Each technology stack has its advantages. Ill write more about that in another post.

The stacks also have common advantages.

Sticking exclusively with one stack means you learn all of its commands, tricks and nuances. Familiarity breeds productivity. As your knowledge of the stack deepens your work becomes faster. Quickly performing complex tasks involving more than one app can be automatic.

While none of the technology stacks are flawlessly integrated, in most cases the quirks and road bumps are easily dealt with.

Its hard to walk past the efficiency benefits of mastering your tools. You will work better if you stick to just one stack.

So pick and stick with just one stack?

If your technology needs are relatively straightforward and narrow, you should be able to pick one stack, learn it intimately and reap huge productivity gains.

I certainly recommend employers and managers standardise on a single stack in a workplace.

More complex cases

This simple approach will work for most people most of the time.

However, many people have complex needs that may not be fully serviced by a single technology stack. In my testing I found minor limitations with the Apple and Microsoft stacks while the Google stack is much more limiting.

None of this matters for many tasks, but youd certainly struggle to do creative work like web design if you stayed strictly inside the Google camp. In fact, most creative work means moving across the stack boundaries at times.

Cross stack integration

As I mentioned earlier, none of the stacks are flawless integrated. They all do a good job most of the time.

If I were to put a number on it, Id give Apple and Google nine out of ten. Microsoft loses an extra point because of the cognitive dissonance of switching between the Windows 8 Metro interface and the older, desktop interface.

Moving between stacks isnt that much harder. Most apps will copy data from other stacks, although there are still a few glitches.

There are minor problems and inefficiencies moving between stacks. If we stick with the same scale, then on the whole cross stack integration would weigh-in at seven out of ten.

The real benefits of staying in one stack are more to do with learning how everything works than with integration.

Recommended approach

Based on my, admittedly unscientific, experiment, the smartest strategy is to pick a master stack, not an exclusive stack.

Choose one: Apple, Microsoft or Google. Plan a stack strategy. Buy your devices within the same stack. Stay with it when you upgrade. Dont be tempted to deviate unless you plan to eventually move everything to the new standard.

Use the mainstream apps within the stack, such as iWorks, Office or Google Docs. Master the tools, learn all the tricks. Make working in the stack second nature.

Stick with it as far as is practical, but dont be frightened of moving outside the stack when you need a different tool to perform a specific task. View your chosen stack as a neighbourhood, not a prison.

[digitl 2013]

digitl on Google+

The post Apple, Microsoft, Google technology stacks conclusions appeared first on digitl.




comments powered by Disqus


Trending now »

Hot discussions in our forums right now:

Gravitational waves observed for the first time, proving Albert Einstein right 100 years on.
Created by tehgerbil, last reply by joker97 on 13-Feb-2016 20:00 (48 replies)
Pages... 2 3 4


Speed camera ticket 55km in 50km zone?
Created by johnr, last reply by richms on 13-Feb-2016 20:52 (22 replies)
Pages... 2


Plug Adapter Plug Query.
Created by steve181, last reply by steve181 on 13-Feb-2016 19:22 (15 replies)

Whats something small that really annoys you?
Created by Finch, last reply by Ouranos on 13-Feb-2016 16:11 (479 replies)
Pages... 30 31 32


Netflix Crackdown - have you been affected?
Created by Paul1977, last reply by LazyDr on 13-Feb-2016 11:09 (367 replies)
Pages... 23 24 25


Pretty serious security flaw with online bills
Created by dclegg, last reply by BarTender on 12-Feb-2016 20:08 (31 replies)
Pages... 2 3


Replacement genuine Laptop batts becoming unavailable in NZ ?
Created by 1101, last reply by 1101 on 12-Feb-2016 16:29 (15 replies)

Sex toys and Waitangi Day - Whats your take on the flip flopping day.
Created by Mspec, last reply by pctek on 12-Feb-2016 16:47 (114 replies)
Pages... 6 7 8