Geekzone: technology news, blogs, forums
Guest
Welcome Guest.
You haven't logged in yet. If you don't have an account you can register now.

Chorus: A tempting proposal, some merit, some flaws
Posted on 18-Feb-2014 08:54 by Bill Bennett. | Tags Filed under: News.



How much would it cost to build and run a copper telecommunications network if you were starting from scratch today?

Thatís the question at the heart of the Commerce Commissionís mission to regulate the price service providers pay Chorus to provide customers with copper-based broadband.

Indirectly itís also at the root of the recent financial troubles plaguing Chorus.

Working out the cost of building and running a new network is far from simple. Apart from anything else, no-one would build a fresh copper-based network today, it isnít the smartest or the most efficient option. Newly rich countries that donít already have copper networks arenít building them. Instead †they move direct to wireless networks.

Rather than plough through hypothetical alternatives, Chorus has suggested the Commerce Commission cuts to the chase and uses††the actual cost of the companyís existing copper network as a starting point.

It makes sense. After all, the existing Chorus copper network is the nearest thing we have to a modern equivalent copper network.

And itís tempting. By opening the books, Chorus would let Commerce Commission analysts see first hand what a network costs. Presumably the information will not all be made public, but there will be insights in to how these things work.

If nothing else, it will speed up the investigation.

But there are downsides, as Tuanz CEO Paul Brislen points out in his organisationís blog:

Chorus hasnít always made the†smartest decisions when it comes to its costs†and that modelling these inefficiencies and ruling them out would have to go by the by. Chorus suggests the expense and time taken to model for these would be hopeless and so itís an all or nothing approach Ė you can have the data, but you canít remove the warts.

Brislen goes on to point out rival telco CallPlus sells a similar product on the market today for less than the previously announced draft access price that caused all the fuss.

In other words, Chorus is effectively asking the Commerce Commission to factor in the companyís inefficiencies.

If Brislen is luke-warm about the Chorus proposal, opposition communications spokesperson Clare Curran is downright icy. She says:

The company does not have a great track record for efficiency or competence when it comes to rolling out the ultrafast broadband network.

Any recommendations Chorus makes which involve Ďtrust us to come up with the right answersí should be regarded with healthy scepticism. The company wants the best price possible.

She has a point. Chorus wouldnít have come up with a proposal that wasnít in line with getting the result it wants from the Commerce Commission.

The post Chorus: A tempting proposal, some merit, some flaws appeared first on digitl.



comments powered by Disqus


Trending now »

Hot discussions in our forums right now:

What time does windows 10 go live?
Created by gogokr431, last reply by Detruire on 2-Aug-2015 00:23 (526 replies)
Pages... 34 35 36


Just installed Windows 10 on release and have questions... Post here
Created by Behodar, last reply by Sideface on 1-Aug-2015 22:14 (113 replies)
Pages... 6 7 8


Do I need to have 7 installed to get 10 ?
Created by xpd, last reply by Regs on 30-Jul-2015 21:04 (117 replies)
Pages... 6 7 8


GST refund on imports returned due to size issues
Created by Geektastic, last reply by raytaylor on 29-Jul-2015 22:57 (29 replies)
Pages... 2


New site and UFB plans
Created by cws82us, last reply by raydenl on 1-Aug-2015 22:33 (131 replies)
Pages... 7 8 9


How do Tosh Computers manage to avoid GST being charged?
Created by Geektastic, last reply by mattwnz on 31-Jul-2015 19:27 (25 replies)
Pages... 2


Time to update yet?
Created by Dreal, last reply by Dreal on 1-Aug-2015 23:54 (21 replies)
Pages... 2


Laptop purchase review
Created by sep11guy, last reply by nathan on 31-Jul-2015 13:20 (15 replies)