Geekzone: technology news, blogs, forums
Welcome Guest.
You haven't logged in yet. If you don't have an account you can register now.
Android: Third among equals
Posted on 1-Oct-2014 11:50 by Bill Bennett. | Tags Filed under: News.

Google, Apple and Microsoft all have decent mobile operating systems.

Last year I spent a week working exclusively with each. My conclusion is you wonít go far wrong with any of them. All three cover the basics adequately. None of them is perfect and none has a fatal flaw. Each has pluses and minuses.

You many find yourself in one camp almost by accident, if, say, someone gives you an iPhone. It may be a deliberate choice: after researching the market you chose a Surface Pro 3. It could be you work for an organisation that standardises on the Galaxy Tab S.

Once in a camp, your relationship with that world generally deepens. As an iPhone user you may learn to make the most of iOS. You may spend money on apps, store everything in iCloud and generally take on a commitment to Appleís way of doing things. This works the same with all three operating systems.

While the three operating systems are equal in many senses, there are ways in which they are anything but equal. Android has by far the largest market share, Windows Phone has a tiny market share. There are roughly 25 Android users for every Windows Phone user.

Market share is often overstated. Itís implications are misunderstood More customers doesnít mean more profit. Android device makers struggle to break even while Apple, on a smaller market share, is highly profitable.

Many developers focus on iOS ahead of Android despite there being fewer users because thatís where there are app sales.

Which brings me to why do I say Android is ďthird among equalsĒ?

In my work I make a point of working with all three mobile operating systems. I also use Windows 8 and OS X.

While the three mobile operating systems are, to a point, largely functionally equal, Android doesnít have things nailed down as neatly as Windows or Apple. This is a blessing for some, for most people itís a problem.

For a start you always know where you are on any Windows or Apple device. Thatís just not true on Android. Samsungís Android user interface is different to LGís Android and so on. Not all apps run on all variations.

This means that from a usability point of view Android isnít one thing, itís many. Where I mentioned earlier about staying in one camp, for Android owners getting all the productivity benefits might mean sticking with Samsung, LG or HTC. Working with one makerís Android phone and another makerís Android tablet can be almost as jarring as moving to another operating system entirely.

My second gripe about Android is that users are lucky to see one OS upgrade on any single device. When iOS or Windows Phone moves from one version to another, everyone gets to move so long as their existing hardware can support the new software. This rarely happens with Android. Itís not uncommon to get left behind.

For me, this is important. Itís why I see Android as the least best choice of the three operating systems. Itís harder work for everyday users who want to get business or other tasks done efficiently.

I understand how Android appeals to more technical types who like to go beneath the surface. Itís a great OS for those who want the freedom to tinker. If thatís you, then fine, I donít think youíve made a silly or dumb choice opting for Android.

However, I worry that Android is often the lowest cost option and because of that it is often the OS used by the least technical users. I see that as a problem. Some will struggle to do simple things because of this. Many will not enjoy the full functionality of their tools.

Filed under: mobile Tagged: Android, IOS, Windows Phone

comments powered by Disqus

Trending now »

Hot discussions in our forums right now:

Xtra email no longer receives on Outlook 2003 / Outlook 2011 for MAC
Created by lNomNoml, last reply by Spong on 20-Jan-2017 23:51 (29 replies)
Pages... 2

The President Of The USA: Donald Trump
Created by TimA, last reply by ajobbins on 21-Jan-2017 02:45 (1782 replies)
Pages... 117 118 119

New Ford Mustang or Holden Commodore or alternatives
Created by MikeB4, last reply by blakamin on 20-Jan-2017 23:51 (61 replies)
Pages... 3 4 5

Lost Mp3 collection, how to rebuild on the cheap (legally)?
Created by TeaLeaf, last reply by kickintheeye on 18-Jan-2017 23:05 (18 replies)
Pages... 2

$1160 for a car battery??!!
Created by jonathan18, last reply by Aredwood on 21-Jan-2017 01:46 (53 replies)
Pages... 2 3 4

Upsize my American houses to McMansion value deal.
Created by kingdragonfly, last reply by richms on 18-Jan-2017 15:48 (14 replies)

Spec check on laptop for GoPro editing please
Created by martyyn, last reply by richms on 20-Jan-2017 17:23 (13 replies)

New Unlimited Fixed Broadband
Created by LivingSkinny, last reply by noroad on 19-Jan-2017 11:14 (55 replies)
Pages... 2 3 4