Geekzone: technology news, blogs, forums
Welcome Guest.
You haven't logged in yet. If you don't have an account you can register now.
Why ratepayers should worry about Auckland Council ERP
Posted on 27-May-2015 15:09 by Bill Bennett. | Tags Filed under: News.

At ZDNet Rob O’Neill says SAP is the big winner from Auckland Council’s IT spending.

He writes:

“The report reveals the so-called Auckland ”Supercity“, an amalgamation of eight former local councils into one, spent NZ$21.6 million with SAP in the nine months from 1 July 2014 through 31 March 2015”

O’Neill says the council’s SAP NewCore project aims to replace eight earlier ERP systems with one that simplifies and standardises processes.

ERP blow-out

The cost of the project has already blown out from $71 million to $157 million.

Taken at face value, that’s a poor return on investment given the expected benefits from this spending are around $10 million a year.

Cost blow outs for big ERP projects are not unusual. Few projects are finished on time, on budget and deliver the promised benefits.

The bigger the project, the lower the chance of hitting those targets.

ERP failure rate

The 2015 ERP Report from Panorama finds 21 percent of companies think their ERP implementation failed. More than half (52 percent) of projects fail to come in on deadline and 60 percent of customers say ERP hasn’t delivered the expected benefits.

This isn’t about SAP. It just happens to be the largest, most visible ERP vendor. And it is the one doing business with Auckland Council[1].

To be fair to SAP and other ERP vendors, these numbers are in line with other large scale software implementations. CRM systems don’t fair much better.

It also needs to be said the ERP failures and missed targets are rarely about the software.

Management failure

In almost every case the problem boils down to poor project management and badly defined, even misunderstood, business processes[2]. Muddled change management is also often behind a failed or disappointing ERP project.

All of these areas are the responsibility of the executives overseeing the ERP project. Ownership of the project has to go right to the top.

You need exceptional management and first class leadership to get big ERP projects humming.

None of this is comforting for Auckland ratepayers.

  1. This project has been controversial for some time. The NZ Herald rang alarm bells three years ago.  ?
  2. An opinion piece from Don Christie at the NBR suggests battle-hardened CIOs from the previous Auckland councils were deliberately kept away from the project planning phase.  ?

Filed under: News Tagged: Auckland, Enterprise resource planning, SAP

comments powered by Disqus

Trending now »

Hot discussions in our forums right now:

RNZAF Boeing 757 breaks down when carrying PM. RNZAF must have an atrocious dispatch reliability figure.
Created by amiga500, last reply by amiga500 on 27-Oct-2016 15:58 (85 replies)
Pages... 4 5 6

WiFi and 3G/4G controlled Wall Switches
Created by maxeon, last reply by wbx0838 on 26-Oct-2016 17:46 (21 replies)
Pages... 2

Gigabit cable now available
Created by sub, last reply by Pumpedd on 27-Oct-2016 15:35 (159 replies)
Pages... 9 10 11

Is it me, or have Trade Me prices increased?!
Created by Geektastic, last reply by mattwnz on 27-Oct-2016 14:58 (32 replies)
Pages... 2 3

Microsoft Surface Studio
Created by dafman, last reply by dafman on 27-Oct-2016 16:03 (14 replies)

Sugar In Food
Created by Geektastic, last reply by jarledb on 27-Oct-2016 15:56 (28 replies)
Pages... 2

Galaxy Note 7 Announcement and Owners' Thread
Created by eracode, last reply by JeremyNzl on 26-Oct-2016 19:35 (1201 replies)
Pages... 79 80 81

Working for Spark - Customer support / Contact Centre
Created by goodfox, last reply by GregF on 27-Oct-2016 15:56 (22 replies)
Pages... 2