Geekzone: technology news, blogs, forums
Welcome Guest.
You haven't logged in yet. If you don't have an account you can register now.
Notes on Sky-Vodafone merger
Posted on 9-Jun-2016 14:51 by Bill Bennett. | Tags Filed under: News.

Earlier today Sky and Vodafone New Zealand confirmed they are to merge.

Itís a big dealÖ

The deal is worth about $3.5 billion. Thatís huge by New Zealand standards.

Last month I interviewed Simpson Grierson partner Michael Pollard for the Capital Markets report in the New Zealand Herald. I wrote:

ďDeals nudged the $9 billion mark in New Zealand in 2015, and mergers and acquisitions around the world, with global volumes up 37 per cent, had a flow-through effect into the New Zealand market.Ē

At the time I wrote the feature, most observers thought 2016 would be a solid year for New Zealand mergers and acquisitions after an outstanding 2015. Although they all told me the action doesnít tend to warm up until mid-year.

Thanks to the Sky-Vodafone deal 2016 will†be even bigger than 2015 for mergers and acquisitions.

Öbut not as big as you might think

Together the new business has a forecast revenue of a shade under $3 billion for the next financial year and expects to see an EBITDA (earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation) of almost $800 million.

It will be one of the largest businesses on the NZX. Yet, it still wonít be as big as Spark NZ.

Sparkís latest half-year report showed the company had revenues of around $1.7 billion for first six months of the 2016 financial year. EBITDA for the same period was a shade over $450 million.

Telecommunications isnít growing. Sparkís guidance says to expect growth between 0 and 3 percent in the second half of the year. Letís take the lower figure.

That would give Spark revenues of around $3.5 billion and an annual EBITDA of a little over $900 million.

On that basis, Spark NZ would still be about 10 to 15 percent larger than the merged Vodafone-Sky business.

Triple play

Somewhere in the thinking behind the Sky-Vodafone merger is the knowledge some US companies combine media and telecommunications. They may even be profitable.

In most case these are cable TV companies who also offer phone services. Or phone companies who deliver cable TV through their pipes.

You may hear this described as a triple play. That is a service provider selling TV, phone calling and internet connections with only one bill.

On the surface this is where a merged Sky-Vodafone business is going.

Yet there is one important difference between the US style triple play strategy and what happens in New Zealand.

Americaís triple play operations are vertically integrated. The service provider owns the cable connection to a house. It controls everything all the way back to the telephone switch, internet server and TV broadcast suite.

That canít happen in most of New Zealand. It may work in those parts of Wellington and Christchurch where Vodafone inherited the HFC network.

It is†possible for the new business to run something along these lines using fixed wireless broadband ó although data capacity could be an issue here. [1]

For the most part, the Sky-Vodafone business will need, at some point, to use the Chorus copper network or the various local fibre companies, including Chorus. These are open access, which means no vertical integration.

How this will play out and whether the new business hits regulatory hurdles is not yet clear. One thing is clear, if Sky-Vodafoneís competitors can appeal to the Commerce Commission, they will. Expect to see courtroom dramas as this plays out.

Content strategy

In Australia, Optus, a telecommunications company has the rights to English Premier League. If you want to watch English football in that country, you need to be an Optus customer.

Football is popular, but it is a minority sporting code. Australiaís big codes are subject to anti-siphoning laws. This means pay-to-view media companies canít wall off the most popular sports fixtures from broadcast television.

Thereís no anti-siphoning law in New Zealand. If you want to watch Rugby Union, Rugby League or Cricket, you have to buy a package from Sky. While thereís no indication the merged business intends to stop selling these packages to customers on other broadband networks, any hint this could happen would be, letís say, controversial.

Dumb dumb pipes

Paul Brislen touches on this last point in an opinion piece at The Spinoff. He says this deal might be great for shareholders, but isnít so good for consumers.

Moreover, Brislen explains why telecommunications companies are worried about being little more than a dumb pipe. The short version is that it is hard to make money when your rivals sell an identical product.

By merging with Sky, Vodafone skirts around the dumb pipe problem. It means it can add value to the dumb pipe by making it the conduit for content. The problem here is that Skyís content selling model is every bit as much of a problem as the question of dumb pipes.

Putting two companies faced with tough technology challenges in one basket could solve all their problems. Or it could mean executives have to face a war on two fronts instead of one.

  1. Letís face it. Data capacity is an issue here. Vodafoneís 4G network can only support a limited number of fixed wireless broadband users. While thereís scope for bigger data caps, itís never going to be the best delivery mechanism for voracious TV consumers. †?
Notes on Sky-Vodafone merger was first posted at

Filed under: Telecommunications Tagged: Sky, Spark, Vodafone

comments powered by Disqus

Trending now »

Hot discussions in our forums right now:

Sony XZ Owners discussion
Created by networkn, last reply by Geektastic on 23-Oct-2016 22:48 (104 replies)
Pages... 5 6 7

Gigabit cable now available
Created by sub, last reply by Pumpedd on 23-Oct-2016 10:48 (59 replies)
Pages... 2 3 4

Who is this women? She is possibly the most famous women on the internet and nobody knows who she is.
Created by jimbob79, last reply by cynnicallemon on 20-Oct-2016 13:28 (14 replies)

Labour weekend plans?
Created by DarthKermit, last reply by joker97 on 22-Oct-2016 09:51 (27 replies)
Pages... 2

Is windows 10 anniversary update causing you problems
Created by robjg63, last reply by mdav056 on 20-Oct-2016 14:01 (27 replies)
Pages... 2

Rise of the machines
Created by Rikkitic, last reply by cynnicallemon on 24-Oct-2016 08:51 (25 replies)
Pages... 2

Windows 10: HDMI or DP to connect to 4K monitor?
Created by joker97, last reply by joker97 on 23-Oct-2016 19:04 (12 replies)

Does anyone use Ebay?
Created by TeaLeaf, last reply by tchart on 23-Oct-2016 19:36 (23 replies)
Pages... 2