Geekzone: technology news, blogs, forums
Guest
Welcome Guest.
You haven't logged in yet. If you don't have an account you can register now.

View this topic in a long page with up to 500 replies per page Create new topic
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | ... | 40
2186 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 543


  Reply # 571644 21-Jan-2012 15:10 Send private message

old3eyes:
KiwiNZ: Even if the pirated material was offered by the rights holders for $1 the downloaders would still want it for nothing. Quite disgusting really.


 

How do you know that??  Haven't you read on this board the endless threads about no legal way to get content especially TV stuff here in NZ  or do you work for a media company that like to tie everything up here so that the likes of Netflix  won't operate here??


Just because there is no legal way , (by the way there is its called going to JBHIFI and buying the DVD), does not make it ok to illegally download it.




KiwiNZ

 Interesting. You're afraid of insects and women. Ladybugs must render you catatonic.

6087 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 208


  Reply # 571645 21-Jan-2012 15:14 Send private message

jpollock: Yes, the reddit piece explains the indictment. What it doesn't explain is why they were arrested in New Zealand, where copyright infringement isn't a criminal offense. It is a federal offense in the US, which is why it collected the racketeering and money laundering charges as well.

So, why were they arrested here?


Is format shift illegal in NZ, where you rip a CD to listen on your media payer. Or upload a ripped CD to the apple icloud server to listen to it streaming, so you don't need to store the file locally on the media player?

1599 posts

Uber Geek
Inactive user


  Reply # 571646 21-Jan-2012 15:15 Send private message

mattwnz:
jpollock: Yes, the reddit piece explains the indictment. What it doesn't explain is why they were arrested in New Zealand, where copyright infringement isn't a criminal offense. It is a federal offense in the US, which is why it collected the racketeering and money laundering charges as well.

So, why were they arrested here?


Is format shift illegal in NZ, where you rip a CD to listen on your media payer. Or upload a ripped CD to the apple icloud server to listen to it streaming, so you don't need to store the file locally on the media player?

To my understanding, yes.

2186 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 543


  Reply # 571648 21-Jan-2012 15:18 Send private message

jpollock:
freitasm: 
If they didn't know there were pirated files being hosted on their servers that would be the ideal situation for Safe Harbour. But I will bet it is pretty easy to find some communication that will show they knew too well what was being hosted.

IANAL, but to me this is the same as saying a bar owner, warned multiple times that drug dealers were selling their "merchandise" in the bar property decide to profit of it by offering "special rooms" to bar "sponsors" (subscribers). When the prosecution comes down they might not get the bar owner for drug dealing, but sure will get him for something like gang affiliation, or facilitating crime, or whatever.

 


I've read the indictment.  It's good reading.  The criminal copyright violation is pretty damning.  The money laundering part doesn't make any sense to me.

However, copyright infringement isn't punishable by incarceration here in NZ, and it isn't mentioned anywhere in the existing extradition agreement.  Prostitution is (being a John can result in extradition), copyright not so much.

The money laundering charge, as far as I can see, is "they took money, they exported the money".  Under that definition of money laundering any international firm that commits a crime is also guilty of money laundering.

Finally, under RICO, any criminal copyright infringement by a company automatically collects a RICO charge.

So, it really sounds like it is criminal copyright infringement.  Without that, the rest doesn't exist.  I would hope that it makes extradition interesting. 

It also makes it interesting for operators of web gambling who manage to sell to Americans...  Don't travel to anywhere with an extradition agreement with the US!

 If they _are_ extradited for criminal copyright infringement, why do we have our own legislative system?  We might as well say, "We're going to follow American law". 


If their company is incorporated or has offices etc in the US then US  laws apply and under the Bilateral treaties New Zealand and the US have the US can apply for Interpol assistance and extradition.




KiwiNZ

 Interesting. You're afraid of insects and women. Ladybugs must render you catatonic.

2186 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 543


  Reply # 571650 21-Jan-2012 15:20 Send private message

mattwnz:
jpollock: Yes, the reddit piece explains the indictment. What it doesn't explain is why they were arrested in New Zealand, where copyright infringement isn't a criminal offense. It is a federal offense in the US, which is why it collected the racketeering and money laundering charges as well.

So, why were they arrested here?


Is format shift illegal in NZ, where you rip a CD to listen on your media payer. Or upload a ripped CD to the apple icloud server to listen to it streaming, so you don't need to store the file locally on the media player?


You may make a digital copy of a CD 'you own' for private use on 'your' other media if the rights holder has allowed same under their T&C.

This does not however extend to DVD's.




KiwiNZ

 Interesting. You're afraid of insects and women. Ladybugs must render you catatonic.

10125 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 266

Trusted
Subscriber

  Reply # 571693 21-Jan-2012 17:18 Send private message

Problem I have with buying DVD's in NZ is that they are generally bastardized into PAL, and are available here ___WAY___ after anywhere else. Shippnig pieces of polycarbonate across the world when there is an internet that can move the data faster and with less polution is just so retarded it is not funny.

Also there is the previously mentioned issue of the content being hard to use when on DVD form with unskippable parts etc, and ease of damage of the data.




Richard rich.ms

71 posts

Master Geek


  Reply # 571694 21-Jan-2012 17:19 Send private message

jpollock: Yes, the reddit piece explains the indictment. What it doesn't explain is why they were arrested in New Zealand, where copyright infringement isn't a criminal offense. It is a federal offense in the US, which is why it collected the racketeering and money laundering charges as well.

So, why were they arrested here?


They were arrested here because they were living here. They were arrested by the NZ Police at the request and under a warrant from the US FBI because that's the way extradition works.  PS NZ does have provisions covering criminal copyright infringement and has for a while. From memory, it was the basis for the case against the fellow who stole a copy of "Sione's Wedding" from a post production company and was selling dupes from his car at the markets. See s131 of the Copyright Act

Dotcom, Batato, Ortmann and van der Kolk were arrested today in Auckland, New Zealand, by New Zealand authorities, who executed provisional arrest warrants requested by the United States. Bencko, Echternach and Nomm remain at large. Today, law enforcement also executed more than 20 search warrants in the United States and eight countries, seized approximately $50 million in assets and targeted sites where Megaupload has servers in Ashburn, Va., Washington, D.C., the Netherlands and Canada. In addition, the U.S. District Court in Alexandria, Va., ordered the seizure of 18 domain names associated with the alleged Mega conspiracy


according to the DoJ. The DoJ regard the alleged crimes as being under their jurisdiction because MU had leased servers in Virginia (Carpathia) and Washington (Cogent) which they used to serve downloads and make financial transactions. If the activity that caused the transactions is found to be criminal, as the DoJ charges say, then the revenue is tainted and sending it to another country (Hong Kong, I believe but I'm not sure - might have been direct to Auckland) counts as money laundering. 

This the same, in reverse, as the apprehension in the US of Nai Yin Xue for killing his wife in Auckland. 

I think I saw a police statement that they weren't considering charges in NZ over copyright, but I note that they have charged a 55 year old NZ man for illegal possession of a firearm.

71 posts

Master Geek


  Reply # 571696 21-Jan-2012 17:23 Send private message

I put some links in there, but they didn't work because I haven't been registered long enough.

http://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/1994/0143/45.0/whole.html#DLM346602 - Copyright Act

http://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/2012/January/12-crm-074.html - DoJ press release

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xue_family_murder_and_abandonment - Nai Yin Xue


6087 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 208


  Reply # 571703 21-Jan-2012 17:48 Send private message

richms: Problem I have with buying DVD's in NZ is that they are generally bastardized into PAL, and are available here ___WAY___ after anywhere else. Shippnig pieces of polycarbonate across the world when there is an internet that can move the data faster and with less polution is just so retarded it is not funny.

Also there is the previously mentioned issue of the content being hard to use when on DVD form with unskippable parts etc, and ease of damage of the data.


Laws haven't kept up with the changes in technology, even from just a few years ago. Also these big media companies have people in high up places, so have a lot of influence on the laws. I don't think they are loosing that much money at all, as their profits have risen year on year, and they have the chance to adapt and create a different experiences. Similar things happened when the motor vehicle came in. In 1865, any self propelled carriage on a British highway had to have a crew of three men. One had to walk in front of the carriage with a red flag to warn horse drawn vehicles of it's approach. That was done to protect an dying industry, but thankfully that didn't last.


BDFL
47914 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 3537

Administrator
Trusted
Geekzone
Subscriber

  Reply # 571707 21-Jan-2012 18:18 Send private message

mattwnz:
jpollock: Yes, the reddit piece explains the indictment. What it doesn't explain is why they were arrested in New Zealand, where copyright infringement isn't a criminal offense. It is a federal offense in the US, which is why it collected the racketeering and money laundering charges as well.

So, why were they arrested here?


Is format shift illegal in NZ, where you rip a CD to listen on your media payer. Or upload a ripped CD to the apple icloud server to listen to it streaming, so you don't need to store the file locally on the media player?


AUDIO format shift is not illegal. VIDEO format shift is.
 




601 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 5

Trusted

  Reply # 571710 21-Jan-2012 18:22 Send private message

nzlemming: 
They were arrested here because they were living here. They were arrested by the NZ Police at the request and under a warrant from the US FBI because that's the way extradition works.  PS NZ does have provisions covering criminal copyright infringement and has for a while. From memory, it was the basis for the case against the fellow who stole a copy of "Sione's Wedding" from a post production company and was selling dupes from his car at the markets. See s131 of the Copyright Act


Ah, there it is, didn't see it when I went looking for it.  Dude's toast.

nzlemming: 

This the same, in reverse, as the apprehension in the US of Nai Yin Xue for killing his wife in Auckland. 

I think I saw a police statement that they weren't considering charges in NZ over copyright, but I note that they have charged a 55 year old NZ man for illegal possession of a firearm.


Except, that extradition agreements typically require symmetry in punishment for it to be allowed.  If it didn't attract criminal liability here, they shouldn't extradite him.  But, it seems it is, so he's on his own.

When reading the indictment, I was reminded of this:


 




450 posts

Ultimate Geek


  Reply # 571712 21-Jan-2012 18:27 Send private message

freitasm: 

IANAL, but to me this is the same as saying a bar owner, warned multiple times that drug dealers were selling their "merchandise" in the bar property decide to profit of it by offering "special rooms" to bar "sponsors" (subscribers). When the prosecution comes down they might not get the bar owner for drug dealing, but sure will get him for something like gang affiliation, or facilitating crime, or whatever.

 


You mean like SkyCity?

Who are getting punished with looser gambling laws & probably over a 100%  increase in pokie machines, in exchange for a building a new casino/convention centre..


BDFL
47914 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 3537

Administrator
Trusted
Geekzone
Subscriber

  Reply # 571713 21-Jan-2012 18:29 Send private message

MikeyPI:
freitasm: 

IANAL, but to me this is the same as saying a bar owner, warned multiple times that drug dealers were selling their "merchandise" in the bar property decide to profit of it by offering "special rooms" to bar "sponsors" (subscribers). When the prosecution comes down they might not get the bar owner for drug dealing, but sure will get him for something like gang affiliation, or facilitating crime, or whatever.

 


You mean like SkyCity?

Who are getting punished with looser gambling laws & probably over a 100%  increase in pokie machines, in exchange for a building a new casino/convention centre..



Completely unrelated. Read my example again. I don't see SkyCity helping drug dealers.

 




1687 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 105

Trusted
Subscriber

  Reply # 571727 21-Jan-2012 19:22 Send private message

jpollock: Except, that extradition agreements typically require symmetry in punishment for it to be allowed.  If it didn't attract criminal liability here, they shouldn't extradite him. 

It does attract criminal liability here, it's just that police have decided not to prosecute through our justice system. Something that hasn't been mentioned (not sure why) is that, given the charges alleged, these people also fall quite clearly within s98A of the Crimes Act 1961. 




Chuck Norris has abolished the periodic table of elements. The only element he recognises is the element of surprise!

2724 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 179

Trusted
Subscriber

  Reply # 571735 21-Jan-2012 20:20 Send private message

will they return our personal files on megaupload??? goodness sake this is not fair for law-abiding users





1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | ... | 40
View this topic in a long page with up to 500 replies per page Create new topic








Twitter »
Follow us to receive Twitter updates when new discussions are posted in our forums:



Follow us to receive Twitter updates when news items and blogs are posted in our frontpage:



Follow us to receive Twitter updates when new jobs are posted to our jobs board:



Follow us to receive Twitter updates when tech item prices are listed in our price comparison site:




News »

Trending now »
Hot discussions in our forums right now:

galaxy s4 now on 4.4.2
Created by nzrock, last reply by blakamin on 17-Apr-2014 22:08 (39 replies)
Pages... 2 3


Forms of government for New Zealand
Created by charsleysa, last reply by MrMistofeles on 17-Apr-2014 22:22 (85 replies)
Pages... 4 5 6


Business vs Residential UFB, why the huge difference in cost??
Created by dman, last reply by dman on 16-Apr-2014 23:45 (22 replies)
Pages... 2


Problem with NDSCam
Created by haydenmarsh, last reply by Benoire on 14-Apr-2014 21:28 (21 replies)
Pages... 2


MH370 - Call for Search & Rescue Help
Created by DS248, last reply by Sideface on 17-Apr-2014 17:28 (735 replies)
Pages... 47 48 49


Weather - Auckland
Created by networkn, last reply by Sidestep on 17-Apr-2014 13:47 (18 replies)
Pages... 2


Is it legal to rip your own DVD in New Zealand?
Created by PSlover14, last reply by KiwiNZ on 17-Apr-2014 20:10 (17 replies)
Pages... 2


True cost of driving ..
Created by rayonline, last reply by alasta on 14-Apr-2014 20:43 (52 replies)
Pages... 2 3 4



Geekzone Live »
Try automatic live updates from Geekzone directly in your browser, without refreshing the page, with Geekzone Live now.

Are you subscribed to our RSS feed? You can download the latest headlines and summaries from our stories directly to your computer or smartphone by using a feed reader.

Alternatively, you can receive a daily email with Geekzone updates.