Fisk on Wikipedia and Web hate campaigns

, posted: 22-APR-2007 10:01

Robert Fisk"There is no end to the Internet's circle of hate," writes Robert Fisk in his article, Caught in the Deadly Web of the Internet, published in the Independent. Fisk, in case you've missed it, is a well-known British journalist whose critical pieces on Western policies the Middle East especially are seen, to put mildly, as controversial.

Even if you don't agree with Fisk, read that Independent story. In it, Fisk recounts the experience of Taner Akçam, a Turkish historian and writer. Akçam faces prosecution in Turkey for writing about the Armenian Genocide at the beginning of the century in that country - yes, the Turks are that sensitive about it still.

However, due to vandalising of Akçam's Wikipedia entry, which accused him of being a member of a terrorist group, he was detained by Canadian border police on February 17 this year. This is acknowledged in the Wikipedia entry, which can now only be edited by registered users.

Based on the detention and what US Homeland Security officials told him, Akçam now believes he can't travel overseas anymore because of the Internet hate campaign against him.

If you think about it, would you take your chances with border police after YouTube videos labelling you a "former terrorist"?



That's serious enough, but the Fisk also mentions Wikipedia's the Internet's role in the the case of Hrant Dink, an Armenian-Turkish journalist who was murdered in January this year. Apparently a false quote attributed to Dink spurred his murder.

Fisk's own Wikipedia entry carries this notice on top:

Editing of this article by unregistered or newly registered users is currently disabled to prevent sock puppets of currently blocked or banned users from editing it. If you are prevented from editing this article, and you wish to make a change, please discuss changes on the talk page, request unprotection, log in, or create an account.

While it's easy to say "don't trust anything you see or hear on the Internet", reading Fisk's story, it appears that the Canadian and US authorities did just that. And why shouldn't they? Wikipedia styles itself as an encyclopaedia, not a libel and defamation publisher.

In the past, attacks on people tended to be contained to Usenet postings and later on, websites. Now however we have "the wisdom of the crowds" on sites like Wikipedia and the ability to easily assemble images, audio and video that appear very believable - and, Google finds it all.

Countries, corporations and individuals alike can be targeted on the Internet, and it doesn't take much effort either. Just pander to people's prejudices, and they'll believe you.

It's the Internet Samizdat cutting both ways. You will find the truth but also falsehoods, sometimes very damaging ones. That's the core of the issue Fisk's article points to: how do you know which is which any more?


Update The day after I posted this, I read that Wayne Crookes, the Canadian Green Party's former campaign manager is suing Google, Wikipedia and openpolitics.ca. Hmm.





Other related posts:
Microsoft being a Onecare
Brothers in spam – the Atkinsons
Why would anyone buy the Wolfram Alpha iPhone app?


 





Comment by artyom, on 22-APR-2007 11:45

i actually posted the news on my blog as it became available, but was long ignored, but thank goodness for Fisk, as he seemed to care enough about it to write about it two months after the event.

here is my original entry from february.


Comment by taniwha, on 22-APR-2007 21:11

Reminiscent of the Kathy Sierra blog post only a few weeks ago. It may or may not be hatred, but it results in awful criminal behaviour published publicly on the internet.


Comment by Peter Mills, on 24-APR-2007 07:07

Do not trust Fisk, he wants to censor the internet (they all do). This is all about the First Amendment. Let's not follow the gov't down the path of censorship. After all, censorship is becoming America's favorite past-time. The US gov't (and their corporate friends), already detain protesters, ban books like "America Deceived" from Amazon and Wikipedia, shut down Imus and fire 21-year tenured, BYU physics professor Steven Jones because he proved explosives, thermite in particular, took down the WTC buildings. Free Speech forever (especially for the internet).

Last link (before Google Books caves to pressure and drops the title).


Comment by che tibby, on 26-APR-2007 11:58

just to remind us that "free speech" often equals "paranoid delusions", there is peter.


Add a comment

Please note: comments that are inappropriate or promotional in nature will be deleted. E-mail addresses are not displayed, but you must enter a valid e-mail address to confirm your comments.

Are you a registered Geekzone user? Login to have the fields below automatically filled in for you and to enable links in comments. If you have (or qualify to have) a Geekzone Blog then your comment will be automatically confirmed and shown in this blog post.

Your name:

Your e-mail:

Your webpage:





Links to stories I've written:

Google News search for me
PC World New Zealand
Computerworld NZ
PC World and Computerworld Australia
PC World US
Computerworld US
Infoworld
NZ Herald
Virus Bulletin
PC World NZ Blog

Content copyright © Juha Saarinen. If you wish to use the content of my blog on your site, please contact me for details. I'm usually happy to share my stuff, as long as it's not for spamblogs and what have you. Attribution with a link back to the blog is always appreciated. If you wish to advertise on my blog, please drop me an email to discuss the details.

Comments policy
All comments posted on this blog are the copyright and responsibility of the submitters in question. Comments commercial and promotional in nature are not allowed. Please ensure that your comments are on topic and refrain from making personal remarks.




    follow me on Twitter





    Add to Netvibes



    Latest comments

    andre on Should Fairfax sell Trade Me to Ebay?: Well, if Trademe do or not decided to sell to E-bay. Lets check out this wonderf...

    juha on Microsoft being a Onecare: Hi Marius,This isn't an "article", just a blog entry that came about after a Mic...

    Marius on Microsoft being a Onecare: It's amazing how an article like this could have been posted on Geekzone. Onecas...

    juha on Microsoft being a Onecare: Thanks Dave - that's useful to know. Mind you, Microsoft could've spelled that o...

    Dave on Microsoft being a Onecare: 0x0C600C03=disable your installed AV while running ANY online AV scanner....

    Simplify Solutions on List of ReadyBoost compatible FLASH devices: Yes... Indeed an excellent resource for designing... I will surely add this info...

    Ragnor on Microsoft being a Onecare: OneCare was pretty sub par, I'm surprised anyone is using it still since it's pr...

    steve on Microsoft being a Onecare: You have to seriously wonder about the depth of thought they gave to this.....es...

    Bill Bennett on Microsoft being a Onecare: You've got to ask yourself "why bother" with the safety scanner when there's Sec...

    Nic Wise on First test on Vodafone NZ HSPA+: wow, thats a full 5x faster than my DSL here in London. Want. :) ...



    Top Ten Techsplodings

    Telecom New Zealand's local lo...
    (28-APR-2006 17:32, 178644 views)
    Join New Zealand Internet blac...
    (16-FEB-2009 09:26, 130380 views)
    iTunes 7 bugs: doesn't Apple t...
    (14-SEP-2006 12:34, 89035 views)
    Working BIOS driver crack for ...
    (13-MAR-2007 16:14, 48953 views)
    The spoofed Telecom commercial...
    (19-MAY-2006 15:59, 44402 views)
    What did Materazzi say to Zida...
    (11-JUL-2006 08:20, 37536 views)
    Windows Vista problem solving ...
    (24-FEB-2007 18:16, 35834 views)
    Firefox 2.0 and Windows Vista ...
    (3-DEC-2006 12:23, 32869 views)
    Gutmann Reloaded and My Vista ...
    (26-JAN-2007 15:35, 31698 views)
    The Saddam Snuff Movie...
    (31-DEC-2006 11:25, 30476 views)




    Subscribe to RSS headline updates from: http://feeds.feedburner.com/Technozone
    Powered by FeedBurner



    Add to Google Subscribe in NewsGator Online Click here to add this RSS feed to Feedster Click here to add this RSS feed to My MSN Click here to add this RSS feed to AvantGo Click here to add this RSS feed to My Yahoo!

    Linkorama

    Modern Drunkard Magazine
    Centre for Citizen Media
    The Assimilated Negro
    The Raw Feed
    Object Dart
    Copyblogger
    Neil Sanderson's blog
    The Opinionated Diner
    Griffin's Gadgets
    Dion Hinchcliffe
    InternetNZ blog (Colin Jackson)
    Spareroom
    Off the record
    Rawiri Blundell
    KhooSuyinKhoo
    ReadWriteWeb
    Frankarr
    Tim Haines
    Darren Rowse - Problogger
    Daniel McKenzie
    The Hivelogic Narrative
    Fraser Talk
    Leaf Salon
    Bad Science
    Wanda Harland
    Kiwi Herald
    Mauricio Freitas
    Hard News
    The Geekzoner
    Mr Cokemaster
    Commercial Archive
    Kiwiblog
    Jama
    Chiefie's blog
    Generation X Y
    Not the South China Morning Post
    Nic often Wise
    Loosewire (Jeremy Wagstaff of WSJ)
    SunnyO
    BlackMagic NZ Film Blog
    Nigel Parker's MSDN blog