Technology. Dissected, discredited.

Youtube - it's broke, but I don't expect them to fix it.

, posted: 21-Jun-2010 22:58

Youtube is hard to avoid. Since its inception (and subsequent absorption Google) it's very much become the default online video site. Even with competitors that offer a much better experience it seems to be nigh impossible to to get any sort of traction against Youtubes dominance.

I've edited and published more than my fair share of video to both Youtube and it's next biggest rival - Vimeo. There have been some good features added to Youtube, something like automatic closed captioning is one, but in my mind most of the new features Google add seem to be more focused at monetising Youtube and keeping it out of legal troubles and rarely improve it for us - the users. Of course anyone who has used Vimeo knows it offers a more complete experience and more tailored to the end user be them uploader or viewer.

But even with posting a clip on Vimeo its pretty much impossible not to have to stick the same one on youtube to guarantee complete exposure.

And to that end (and the motivation for this post) why does Youtube still not offer the ability to replace a clip without deleting the old one and reposting it fresh. If you do 'reupload' its considered a whole new clip - which of course resets views, deletes comments and forces a new link to be made - and making for a huge pain in the ass if you spot an issue in the clip after posting it.

There are of course other issues, such as Youtubes constant desire to re-compress even perfectly encoded MP4 files and the time limit of 10 mins for any single clip but that can wait until I get annoyed by them (again) in the future.

I suppose in some ways it confirms what I think most monopolies general rule - "If it's broke, and the users still come, then why fix anything. We win either way."


More information

Other related posts:
Vodamoan - new connection pains
Fine Tuning Mac Mini, Logitech Harmony, Plex Nine & EyeTV
Using a MacMini with a Logitech Harmony remote control

Comment by muppet, on 27-Jun-2010 22:23

Of course.

People still use Hotmail and Yahoo.

Add a comment

Please note: comments that are inappropriate or promotional in nature will be deleted. E-mail addresses are not displayed, but you must enter a valid e-mail address to confirm your comments.

Are you a registered Geekzone user? Login to have the fields below automatically filled in for you and to enable links in comments. If you have (or qualify to have) a Geekzone Blog then your comment will be automatically confirmed and placed in the moderation queue for the blog owner's approval.

Your name:

Your e-mail:

Your webpage:

lotech's profile

New Zealand

I run a post production company specialising mainly in TV & Commercials. I also do graphic and motion design when it's there to be done. I've used Windows my whole life, but am now run Macs exclusively in our office and at home. Few issues. It just works.

My current setup is a Early 2008 17" Macbook Pro (C2D 2.5Ghz, 4gb, 320Gb, UWXGA Screen).