Geekzone: technology news, blogs, forums
Welcome Guest.
You haven't logged in yet. If you don't have an account you can register now.
Taxing times at Netflix New Zealand
Posted on 6-Apr-2015 14:29 by Bill Bennett | Tags Filed under: Articles

Netflix didnít take long to disrupt New Zealandís media sector.

The disruption started before the worldís largest streaming TV and film service opened in New Zealand last month.

Netflix is based overseas. That means it doesnít have to charge GST. New Zealand companies do.

Not charging GST gives Netflix a built-in 15 percent price advantage over local TV and services like Sparkís Lightbox or Sky TV.

Reverse protectionism

Until a generation ago governments used tariff barriers to protect local businesses from foreign competition. Tariffs could also protect local jobs.

Now New Zealandís GST tax regime is crippling local firms. It threatens jobs ó good jobs.

In this sense GST acts as a brake on innovation and does nothing to help local content producers .

We all pay the price

Thereís more to this than just damaging New Zealand businesses, jobs and innovation.

Tax revenue lost to overseas companies means either we go without public services or pay higher taxes. Thatís all of us, Netflix customers or not.

Unless the government acts Netflix will squeeze local content providers†out of business. And that means more lost taxes.

More than just GST

Spark pays New Zealand company tax. Employees pay income tax. Spark buys services from other New Zealand businesses. That money circulates. Spark contributes to the economy in many ways.

None of the money paid to Netflix circulates in the New Zealand economy. In that sense it is parasitic.

Not everyone agrees:

We’ll come back to the value NZ subscribers get from Netflix in a moment. First, some more context.

Just like online shopping?

New Zealand retailers watching from the sidelines will point out theyíve put up with similar unfair competition for years.

There are fewer bookshops on our high streets and almost no music stores any more thanks to global outlets like Amazon. Like Netflix they donít charge GST on New Zealand transactions. [1]

The difference between the price of books, DVDs, CDs and other goods purchased overseas is greater than 15 percent. Thatís because global retailers reap huge economies of scale from running vast centralised warehouses.

Not worth taxing

Inland Revenue says it isnít worth collecting the GST on imported goods worth less than NZ$400. Parcels of books, CDS, DVDs and clothes rarely bust that limit. In effect, fly in under the IRDís radar.

High street retailers would like that stop, but it isnít going to happen.

Netflix doesnít deal with physical goods. Thereís no obvious customs border to police. Movie and TV subscriptions cost around†NZ$10 a month, well below the NZ$400 threshold.

There is a practical difference between selling physical goods and selling a subscription TV service. At some point the cost of collecting GST when goods reach the NZ border is lower than the amount of tax collected.

Easily fixed

Collecting New Zealand taxes from overseas retailers is technically easy, but politically hard.

There’s nothing technical stopping US-based global retailers from charging New Zealand GST, or any other country’s equivalent tax, at the point of sale.

After all, they already have to do something similar with state-based sales taxes when selling to customers in other US states. At most it would need a few lines of code in their existing software.

Competitive edge

They don’t want to do this as it will affect their competitive edge. In reality such an effect would be small. Books from Amazon are less than half the price in NZ shops, adding 15 percent to that is unlikely to lose many sales.

On the other hand Netflix New Zealand subscription fees range from NZ$10 to NZ$16 a month. Adding 15 percent GST to those prices changes the competitive landscape for streaming video services in New Zealand. The closest rival, Spark’s Lightbox service, is NZ$13.

Time for government intervention?

New Zealand’s government isn’t shy of industry intervention. That’s especially true in the telecommunications sector where it forced an industry restructure to get its UFB fibre broadband project underway and†taxes telecommunications companies to deliver rural services.

Getting involved to level the playing field for local content companies doesn’t mean†changing ideology or established principles. It isn’t about protecting an out-of-date business model.†Securing†the tax base isn’t controversial ó and is likely to play well with voters too.

However, New Zealand is too small a nation to tackle some of the world’s largest and most power companies on its own. There are moves underway elsewhere to deal with these problems. The UK and Australia are already moving towards imposing taxes on multinationals.

In December the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development released a paper suggesting foreign suppliers would pay local sales taxes.

1. Unless a customer is daft enough to order more than NZ$400 worth in a single transaction.

Filed under: Media Tagged: fibre, government, Spark

comments powered by Disqus

Trending now »

Hot discussions in our forums right now:

New Vodafone Broadband Plans
Created by Naithin, last reply by antoniosk on 21-Oct-2017 17:15 (55 replies)
Pages... 2 3 4

Macrium Reflect backup software - anyone using it?
Created by geekIT, last reply by Dynamic on 23-Oct-2017 21:01 (16 replies)
Pages... 2

Vodafone TV - Is this sky?
Created by wingbat45, last reply by richms on 20-Oct-2017 18:00 (84 replies)
Pages... 4 5 6

KRACK - WPA2 essentially cracked.
Created by michaelmurfy, last reply by Paul1977 on 20-Oct-2017 09:28 (76 replies)
Pages... 4 5 6

Amazing that some speciality shops in malls survive at all
Created by amiga500, last reply by richms on 20-Oct-2017 23:07 (14 replies)

Streaming of some All Blacks games on for only $24.99!
Created by dazhann, last reply by vexxxboy on 22-Oct-2017 07:45 (30 replies)
Pages... 2

Load bearing wall? Looking for builders opinions
Created by Louis1985, last reply by Bung on 24-Oct-2017 05:40 (19 replies)
Pages... 2

macbook macbook pro for school kid options?
Created by floydie, last reply by Yabanize on 23-Oct-2017 22:18 (9 replies)