Geekzone: technology news, blogs, forums
Guest
Welcome Guest.
You haven't logged in yet. If you don't have an account you can register now.


View this topic in a long page with up to 500 replies per page Create new topic
1 | 2 
BlakJak
1167 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

  #2506098 16-Jun-2020 20:35
Send private message

Interesting video talking about shingling...

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8IRjFZ9xEj8





No signature to see here, move along...

 
 
 

You will find anything you want at MightyApe (affiliate link).
kiwifidget
"Cookie"
2907 posts

Uber Geek

Lifetime subscriber

  #2506118 16-Jun-2020 21:34
Send private message

allan:

 

For Seagate drives, there are a number of statements online indicating that the Ironwolf and Ironwolf Pro ranges are not shingled.

 

 

I hope that's right, I have 5 8TB Ironwolfs in my NAS.





Delete cookies?! Are you insane?!


jpoc

1043 posts

Uber Geek


  #2506176 17-Jun-2020 08:12
Send private message

Mark:

 

A reasonable rule of thumb for if a drive is shingled or not, is the amount of cache on the drive ... 256MB+ is a good sign it's a shingled drive.

 

 

allan:

 

For Seagate drives, there are a number of statements online indicating that the Ironwolf and Ironwolf Pro ranges are not shingled.

 

 

From Amazon:

 

Seagate IronWolf 6TB NAS Internal Hard Drive HDD – CMR 3.5 Inch SATA 6Gb/s 5600 RPM 256MB Cache

 

Alan's link to the synology site indicates that that drive is approved by them so it is unlikely to be shingled.

 

I am not setting out to criticise Mark here I am just illustrating that it is difficult to be sure.

 

I may buy one of those drives and use dd to try to copy a shingled WD Red drive that is in my zfs array.

 

 




Mark
1623 posts

Uber Geek


  #2506267 17-Jun-2020 09:51
Send private message

 

I am not setting out to criticise Mark here I am just illustrating that it is difficult to be sure.

 

 

I don't mind criticism at all :-)   Was just pointing out that shingled drives tend to have more cache on them (since they need it to give the illusion of performance), drives usually came with 64 or 128MB of cache, then shingled drives started being swapped into the same product families (naughty WD!) but they came with extra cache.

 

Also to be honest if you drop a drive into a NAS the write back cache should probably be off unless you have external UPS and the NAS shutdown nicely during a power outage.


concordnz
424 posts

Ultimate Geek

Trusted
EMT (R)

  #2506328 17-Jun-2020 10:38
Send private message

Mark:


I am not setting out to criticise Mark here I am just illustrating that it is difficult to be sure.



I don't mind criticism at all :-)   Was just pointing out that shingled drives tend to have more cache on them (since they need it to give the illusion of performance), drives usually came with 64 or 128MB of cache, then shingled drives started being swapped into the same product families (naughty WD!) but they came with extra cache.


Also to be honest if you drop a drive into a NAS the write back cache should probably be off unless you have external UPS and the NAS shutdown nicely during a power outage.



Nope - Increased cache is NOT a guideline/warning.
Please don't use this as a rule of thumb.- you will confuse yourself.
- all manufacturers are increasing their caches on both SMR & CMR as ram costs have dropped.
WD Red 8Tb & 10Tb have increased to 256mb cache & these are definitely CMR (good)

concordnz
424 posts

Ultimate Geek

Trusted
EMT (R)

  #2506332 17-Jun-2020 10:53
Send private message

Western Digital CMR/SMR info is easy to find.
( This stuff is not a secret).

8Tb+ WD is always CMR (Good) - so anyone buying drives for new RAID has nothing to worry about.

Only those replacing an old drive & size matching need to check.(if in doubt/lazy - just use WD Red Pro's......)
& you are running Raid - you should be checking detailed spec of the drives you are buying to put in anyway





Seagate & Toshiba(Toshiba is also doing it), are harder to find info on what models are/are not SMR (Shingled)


Mark
1623 posts

Uber Geek


  #2506385 17-Jun-2020 11:16
Send private message

concordnz:

Nope - Increased cache is NOT a guideline/warning.
Please don't use this as a rule of thumb.- you will confuse yourself.
- all manufacturers are increasing their caches on both SMR & CMR as ram costs have dropped.
WD Red 8Tb & 10Tb have increased to 256mb cache & these are definitely CMR (good)

 

 

 

Fair enough .. I've not progressed beyond 2TB drives at home anyway, and the last purchase was to find a non-SMR replacement in that size and spindle speed for the RAID set, I found cache size helped narrow it down which of the models superseding it were actually SMR in a period when WD weren't making it easy info to find.

 

 

 

 




jpoc

1043 posts

Uber Geek


  #2506420 17-Jun-2020 11:37
Send private message

concordnz: Western Digital CMR/SMR info is easy to find.
( This stuff is not a secret).

 

It appears though that as recently as April this year, it was a secret. WD only admitted it when the information was released by others.

 

As recently as March this year WD wrote:

 

“Just a quick note. The only SMR drive that Western Digital will have in production is our 20TB hard enterprise hard drives and even these will not be rolled out into the channel. All of our current range of hard drives are based on CMR Conventional Magnetic Recording. [Blocks & Files emboldening.] With SMR Western Digital would make it very clear as that format of hard drive requires a lot of technological tweaks in customer systems.”

 

It is hard to read that and avoid the conclusion that WD have not been honest and straight with their customers.

 

The blocks and files blog reported it a couple of months ago and their report was highlighted in theregister.

 

It was only after that revelation that WD admitted what they had been doing.

 

That was when they updated their data sheets.

 

So, how much do you believe their current claims?

 

Refs:

 

https://blocksandfiles.com/2020/04/14/wd-red-nas-drives-shingled-magnetic-recording/

 

https://blocksandfiles.com/2020/04/24/western-digital-smr-drives-policy-change/

 

 


jpoc

1043 posts

Uber Geek


  #2506492 17-Jun-2020 12:09
Send private message

Mark:

 

A reasonable rule of thumb for if a drive is shingled or not, is the amount of cache on the drive ... 256MB+ is a good sign it's a shingled drive.

 

 

I found another update for this:

 

The Toshiba P300 range has recently been disclosed as being shingled and that comes with a 64MB cache.

 

 


Mark
1623 posts

Uber Geek


  #2506589 17-Jun-2020 13:30
Send private message

jpoc:

 

Mark:

 

A reasonable rule of thumb for if a drive is shingled or not, is the amount of cache on the drive ... 256MB+ is a good sign it's a shingled drive.

 

 

I found another update for this:

 

The Toshiba P300 range has recently been disclosed as being shingled and that comes with a 64MB cache.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Are we playing "I can prove you wrong" ? πŸ˜€

 

 

 

P300 500GB to 3TB is non-shingled with 64MB

 

P300 4TB and 6TB is shingled with 128MB

 

 

 

So nyyaaaaaaaahhhhhhhh  πŸ˜‹


tchart
2314 posts

Uber Geek

ID Verified
Trusted

  #2506595 17-Jun-2020 13:33
Send private message

Lolz I thought this was some conspiracy about people using shingles on their driveway!


jpoc

1043 posts

Uber Geek


  #2506686 17-Jun-2020 14:38
Send private message

Mark:

 

Are we playing "I can prove you wrong" ? πŸ˜€

 

 

 

P300 500GB to 3TB is non-shingled with 64MB

 

P300 4TB and 6TB is shingled with 128MB

 

 

Not at all, it all just goes to show how weird this whole situation is.

 

I have a Toshiba X300 6TB drive and there is a little matrix in the documentation that shows the available drives.

 

The N300 and X300 ranges are listed as having 128MB cache and the P300 range is shown as 64MB.

 

It almost looks as though the people talking or writing about their own company's products do not actually know this information.

 

What are their customers supposed to do?


Mark
1623 posts

Uber Geek


  #2506698 17-Jun-2020 14:53
Send private message

jpoc:

 

What are their customers supposed to do?

 

 

Most of these big companies could not care less about any customer not buying drives by the tens of thousands!  Mere home users basically just have to accept what they are given and like it! 😬

 

Or file class action lawsuits so the lawyers can stay fat. 


1 | 2 
View this topic in a long page with up to 500 replies per page Create new topic





News and reviews »

One New Zealand Extends 3G Switch-off Date
Posted 11-Apr-2024 08:56


Amazon Echo Hub Review
Posted 10-Apr-2024 18:57


Epson Launches New Versatile A4 Desktop Scanners
Posted 10-Apr-2024 15:31


Motorola Mobility Launches New Android Phones in New Zealand
Posted 10-Apr-2024 14:59


Logitech G Unveils the PRO X 60 Gaming Keyboard
Posted 9-Apr-2024 19:01


Logitech Unveils Signature Slim Keyboard and Combo
Posted 9-Apr-2024 13:33


ExpressVPN Launches Aircove Go Portable Router With Built-in VPN
Posted 26-Mar-2024 21:25


Shure MoveMic Review
Posted 25-Mar-2024 12:47


reMarkable 2 Launches at JB Hi-Fi New Zealand
Posted 20-Mar-2024 08:36


Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra review
Posted 19-Mar-2024 11:37


Google Nest Wifi Pro Review
Posted 16-Mar-2024 11:28


Samsung Galaxy A55 5G and Galaxy A35 5G
Posted 12-Mar-2024 12:41


Cricut EasyPress Mini Zen Blue launches at Spotlight New Zealand
Posted 12-Mar-2024 12:32


Logitech Introduces MX Brio Webcam
Posted 12-Mar-2024 12:24


HP Unveils Broadest Consumer Portfolio of AI-Enhanced Laptops
Posted 3-Mar-2024 18:09









Geekzone Live »

Try automatic live updates from Geekzone directly in your browser, without refreshing the page, with Geekzone Live now.



Are you subscribed to our RSS feed? You can download the latest headlines and summaries from our stories directly to your computer or smartphone by using a feed reader.







Backblaze unlimited backup