billgates: Here is some of my Whisky collection. I got the JW XR in 2012. Still have not opened it yet. My absolute favourite IMO most under rated Whisky in the world in Johnnie Walker Black Label. I love my Whisky's and only drink them straight. The Bunnahabhain is 31 hears old. Its rubbish.
Late to the party here, but is that the Bunnahabhain 97 heavily peated (signatory bottling) (matured in hogsheads?)
I don't usually like Bunnahabhain, but quite like that. I'm a fan of the heavy islay, with Talisker, Laphroig, and Ardberg some of favs.
edit: If you are looking for a good value whisky, keep an eye out for the Glenfarclas 105 10 yo. (cask strength, 60%)
about $100 for the 700ml goes nicely with a few drops of water to get a fuller flavour, or even a cube or 2.