Geekzone: technology news, blogs, forums
Guest
Welcome Guest.
You haven't logged in yet. If you don't have an account you can register now.




282 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 3

Trusted

Topic # 129417 15-Sep-2013 02:32
Send private message

I had a phone call from Telecom call centre last week asking if I want to upgrade my ADSL to VDSL2 and sign a 12 month contract for a phone+broadband package. This made me look at what is available in the market and at my recent usage to see what is the best package for our family. I been with Telecom for twenty odd years - mainly because I have been happy with them overall (plus I have had an Xtra account - and did not want the hassle of changing it) So I checked out about a dozen or so web sites and it looks like only six companies are providing BOTH VoIP and VDSL2 - and I came up with a short list of  two (Snap vs WorldExchange] - they are different - and they all sounds good and I cant make my mind up. Any advise / recommendations ?  I read many of the posts here - but very few of them were written in the last few months with the newer VDSL offerings were in place. This is what I found on the web site:

1. SNAP VDSL BROADBAND & SNAP PLUS

 

  • 100GB data per month
  • Need VDSL modem (FRITZ!Box 7390) - I think this is extra.
  • Snap Plus phone line 
  • FREE Voicemail
  • FREE Caller ID
  • FREE Call Waiting
  • Free Number Port
  • FREE connection and Wiring
  • $100 / month @ 12 mnth contract
  • NZ-based Help Desk
Snap seem pretty on to it, had a good writeup about it in Stuff yesterday and have a FB page full of happy customers. However, they are based in Christchurch - and I cant find out about what sort of DR / Bus. continuity they have if their data centre goes down with an earthquake.

2.WORLD EXCHANGE FUSION 100

 

  • 100GB data per month
  • Need a WXC MP264 Residential Gateway @ $295 extra
  • FREE Voicemail
  • FREE Caller ID
  • FREE Call Waiting
  • FREE connection and Wiring
  • $125 / month @ 12 mnth contract [Plus $30 switching fee]
  • Emergency Services Compliant Primary Voice Line
  • Call Waiting
  • Call Forwarding
  • Fax to Email
  • Free Local Calls
  • 5 Cent NZ Calling
  • Free installation
  • Free Number Port
  • 12 month contrac
  • NZ-based Help Desk
WorldExchange seems to have the most 'features' per unit dollar - but not sure I have use for many of the telephony features.

3. 2TALK VDSL BASIC PLAN + GO FREE VOICE PLAN

 

2Talk looks cheap - but the cost of ownership seems more than SNAP when you add all the bits (extra monthly or extra toll charges).


4. TELECOM ULTRA VDSL AND  EVERYDAY LOCAL CALLING

 

  • 80GB data per month
  • FREE Ultra VDSL Modem (TG589vn)  +Wifi
  • $95 / month @ 12 mnth contract [Plus $99 connection fee]
  • Edit:  includes landline + everyday local calling
  • VoIP is not something Telecom offers - so need extra fees for for a PBX on cloud + SIP phones from another provider.
Any suggestions from existing users / experts are gratefully accepted. Here are my detailed requirements:

- We have six in the family (Three teenagers)
- our average bandwidth usage is 80GB / m. Hardly use the land-line 
- Not bothered if the router does not have Wifi - as I have a separate high end Wi-Fi router.
- Have not considered the phones we need - but I guess a phone like a phone like the FRITZ!Fon MT-F) would be fine for the main phone, and each person in the house (who have either an iPAD or iPHONE) can download Zoiper SIP Phone - so everyone in the house will have a phone each.  
- Edit: I dont need analogue line for FAX / alarm / Sky etc. Manage everything fine over broadband. 
- My current ADSL connection has down bandwidth of  15kbps and 14dB line attenuation




Tim M, Auckland
Blog: http://paddler.co.nz





Filter this topic showing only the reply marked as answer View this topic in a long page with up to 500 replies per page Create new topic
 1 | 2 | 3
3225 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 924

Trusted

  Reply # 895745 15-Sep-2013 07:38
Send private message

Snap Naked VDSL (a 24 month contract gets you the fritzbox free) + 2 Talk VOIP works well for our house. You can easily configure the Fritxbox for 2talk voip and it has a built in ATA which means you can just plug any phone you already have into one of the FON ports on it. 

IMO snap are the best VDSL provider and 2 talk have been outstanding (and well priced) for our VOIP.

(I hope your current ADSL has 15 Mbps not kbps down otherwise there's no way you'll get VDSL)

PS: I'm surprised at that usage per month with 3 teenagers! You might find it goes up a fair bit once on VDSL ;-)

PPS: It looks like you were looking at Fibre pricing with Telecom.  Their base VDSL plan is 80GB @ 95$ and includes landline + everyday local calling.

2731 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 706


  Reply # 895748 15-Sep-2013 08:12
Send private message

im With Snap and have the 1st package on your list and it's great, the Fritzbox is a great modem, solid and reliable and your question on continuity in a earthquake, i cant answer that, but during the last earthquakes i never had any down time with Snap.




Common sense is not as common as you think.


 
 
 
 


5190 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 1682


  Reply # 895753 15-Sep-2013 08:57
Send private message

From personal experience, WxC have been very good with service continuity, and on the occasions tech support has been required, it has been of a very high standard.

Double check the Fusion 100 price though - I thought it was $125.00



282 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 3

Trusted

  Reply # 895754 15-Sep-2013 09:08
Send private message

RunningMan: Double check the Fusion 100 price though - I thought it was $125.00


Sorry - Typo at my end - updated the original post with the correct price.




Tim M, Auckland
Blog: http://paddler.co.nz





27270 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 6699

Moderator
Trusted
Biddle Corp
Lifetime subscriber

  Reply # 895784 15-Sep-2013 10:33
Send private message

First thing is to establish whether you're in a VDSL2 coverage zone. You'd think Telecom would only target those customers who are. Does the Chorus coverage map show VDSL2 (20Mbps+) at your address?



282 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 3

Trusted

  Reply # 895790 15-Sep-2013 10:45
Send private message

vexxxboy: im With Snap and have the 1st package on your list and it's great, ... the Fritzbox is a great modem, solid and reliable .

Oh OK. I read in another post that their Wi-fi range on n  sucks - are you OK with their Wi-Fi performance?

sidefx: Snap Naked VDSL (a 24 month contract gets you the fritzbox free)

Which Fritbox did they give you? Was it the FritzBox 7340 or the 7390? They dont have any pricing on the Fritzbox - I am assuming it is part of the monthly fee even on 'BROADBAND & SNAP PLUS' the regardless of which Fritbox I get? 

sidefx: You can easily configure the Fritxbox for 2talk voip and it has a built in ATA which means you can just plug any phone you already have into one of the FON ports on it. 

Just curious - why did you not sign up for their 'BROADBAND AND PHONE' with SNAP and have just one provider?

sidefx: IMO snap are the best VDSL provider and 2 talk have been outstanding (and well priced) for our VOIP. 

I will call Vodafone and Telecom on Monday who are my current providers and see if they will help me save $1400/year - which is how much I will be saving if I do switch based on my current usage [plus any one off fees]. I owe that to them after they looked after me for so many years.


sidefx: PS: I'm surprised at that usage per month with 3 teenagers! You might find it goes up a fair bit once on VDSL ;-) 
 
I turn on Parental control (which block Youtube and Steampowered) when I get the 80% usage alert from Telecom broadband everymonth.

sidefx: PPS: It looks like you were looking at Fibre pricing with Telecom.  Their base VDSL plan is 80GB @ 95$ and includes landline + everyday local calling.

Thanks updated the original post regarding the Telecom price and what is included.

sidefx:  (I hope your current ADSL has 15 Mbps not kbps down otherwise there's no way you'll get VDSL)
.

I get 12 Mbps download when I do a speed test However, this was a copy and paste from the modem statistics:

 

 

 

 

Bandwidth (Up/Down) [kbps/kbps]:

 

1.113 / 14.869

 

 

 

 

 

 

 








Tim M, Auckland
Blog: http://paddler.co.nz





3681 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 1390

Subscriber

  Reply # 895797 15-Sep-2013 10:49
Send private message

For just VDSL they are all much the same. But you require voice services so that is where they are all VERY different:
Telecom - you will retain an analogue line. Sky will still be able to dial out, so will your alarm or anything else. You dont get 'smart' features though.
Snap - they are an awesome ISP (I use them) but their voice service had (and probably still does) some pretty major issues. I wouldnt use Snap voip.
2Talk - excellent voice service. We use 2talk for pretty much all our business customers with their phone systems. 2talk broadband is mainly built towards getting the best access available for their voice product. I find throughput on 2talk VDSL to be a bit lower than others. It doesnt worry me though as the main point is that we can provide end-to-end QoS for the voice traffic. Also, if you arent confident with setting up VoIP equipment 2talk is not for you. They have no real support available. So to summarise, 2talk has an awesome voice platform as long as you know what you are doing.
WxC - they have a true PSTN replacement. They auto-provision and then manage your VoIP device to make sure you have an excellent experience with VoIP. I have never heard anyone say a bad thing about their voice service. They dont make as many features available as 2talk do but you probably dont require too much anyway. I see caller id, voicemail and call forwards being the most useful feature in the home situation. The rest are more business orientated. Seeing as you dont seem too clued up on the VoIP side of things I would suggest WxC is your best bet.

Thats my 2c anyway.



282 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 3

Trusted

  Reply # 895800 15-Sep-2013 10:55
Send private message

sbiddle: First thing is to establish whether you're in a VDSL2 coverage zone. You'd think Telecom would only target those customers who are. Does the Chorus coverage map show VDSL2 (20Mbps+) at your address?


Yeah...my area is clearly in the middle of the 20Mbs zone with UFB planned by Jun 2016. I think I am connected to the Whenuapai exchange.
My high attenuation might be down to dodgy wiring of the in-line ADSL splitter inside the wall - but if I get VDSL I was going to discard all the old wiring.




Tim M, Auckland
Blog: http://paddler.co.nz





2731 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 706


  Reply # 895803 15-Sep-2013 11:02
Send private message

I have never had a problem with the WiFi on the fritz box , some people have, but i run 2 laptops and 4 other devices often at the same time and have had no problems and Snap Voip is the only Voip i have used and have used it since they started it, and any problems they have fixed pretty much straight away. The Fritzbox is a lot more than a modem, i use mine as a answering machine and have it set up as my NAS device. And also remember for an extra $5 a month you get unlimited Youtube, i watch everything in HD and go through 40- 50 Gb a month .










Common sense is not as common as you think.




282 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 3

Trusted

  Reply # 895812 15-Sep-2013 11:21
Send private message

vexxxboy: And also remember for an extra $5 a month you get unlimited Youtube


I did not find anything about that on Snap Web. But this is what I read about here in Geekzone posts:

- Steam gaming traffic are un-metered 
- Traffic between 1AM-7AM are unmetered
- $5 a month get you unlimited Youtube

Anyone confirm if these are still on offer?




Tim M, Auckland
Blog: http://paddler.co.nz







282 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 3

Trusted

  Reply # 895829 15-Sep-2013 12:38
Send private message

chevrolux: 
WxC .... dont make as many features available as 2talk do but ....


Thanks - just trying to do a compare WxC features  vs 2Talk Features - what are the features you are  alking about? I found the main ones of differentiation are things like being able to record phone conversation, Group Talk that 2Talk have (as opposed to only 3-Way Talk that WxC have). On the other hand, WxC have  / Outlook integration (probably for presence info based on your calender / status?) and 2Talk seems to have just a manually updated stand alone calender. I guess Snap does not offer any of these voice features? Am I right?






Tim M, Auckland
Blog: http://paddler.co.nz





2731 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 706


  Reply # 895877 15-Sep-2013 14:20
Send private message

BlueToothKiwi:
vexxxboy: And also remember for an extra $5 a month you get unlimited Youtube


I did not find anything about that on Snap Web. But this is what I read about here in Geekzone posts:

- Steam gaming traffic are un-metered 
- Traffic between 1AM-7AM are unmetered
- $5 a month get you unlimited Youtube

Anyone confirm if these are still on offer?


yes they are still on offer but the Steam one they cant guarantee but everytime i have used it the data has been free. 




Common sense is not as common as you think.


3681 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 1390

Subscriber

  Reply # 895884 15-Sep-2013 14:28
Send private message

2Talk sell their platform as a Cloud-based PABX system. Meaning it has most of the flexibility of a true PABX built right in to the platform. Whereas WxC's residential offering is built towards offering a replacement for the analogue network. WxC also make geographic information available when you dial 111 and, as previously mentioned, run an entirely managed service meaning you will simply have to plug in the router and not worry about.
2Talk's website doesn't really tell you what is actually available. You need to log in to an account and you will see there are many many features built in to the platform but like I say, they are more business orientated so don't really concern the residential user. The biggest downside to you will be having to set up your VoIP devices yourself.

1234 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 154


  Reply # 895917 15-Sep-2013 15:52
Send private message

You could take a look at www.fullflavourmedia.co.nz at @114 no limit as such but fair use policy then add a 2talk line. they give you the modem to use ( with 2 ATA ports ) which you need to send back at the end of the contract and from memory it's around 250 install fee but no minimum contract length.


5290 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 2318

Trusted
Lifetime subscriber

  Reply # 895948 15-Sep-2013 16:50
One person supports this post
Send private message

WorldxChange! They are the only ones I'd trust to be a true PSTN replacement option, and have been doing it to a high standard for longer than any others. Where were the likes of Snap, Orcon or even Telecom when fibre to home subdivisions were being built? Last I check (very recently), Snap didn't even have their dial plan sorted, you have to wait several seconds before the call can begin to connect.




Chorus has spent $1.4 billion on making their xDSL broadband network faster. If your still stuck on ADSL or VDSL, why not spend from $150 on a master filter install to make sure you are getting the most out of your connection?
I install - Naked DSL, DSL Master Splitters, VoIP, data cabling and general computer support for home and small business.
Rural Broadband RBI installer for Ultimate Broadband and Full Flavour

 

Need help in Auckland, Waikato or BoP? Click my email button, or email me direct: [my user name] at geekzonemail dot com


 1 | 2 | 3
Filter this topic showing only the reply marked as answer View this topic in a long page with up to 500 replies per page Create new topic



Twitter »

Follow us to receive Twitter updates when new discussions are posted in our forums:



Follow us to receive Twitter updates when news items and blogs are posted in our frontpage:



Follow us to receive Twitter updates when tech item prices are listed in our price comparison site:



Geekzone Live »

Try automatic live updates from Geekzone directly in your browser, without refreshing the page, with Geekzone Live now.


Geekzone Live »

Our community of supporters help make Geekzone possible. Click the button below to join them.

Support Geezone on PressPatron



Are you subscribed to our RSS feed? You can download the latest headlines and summaries from our stories directly to your computer or smartphone by using a feed reader.

Alternatively, you can receive a daily email with Geekzone updates.