!!! ALLERT - DON'T BUY A TIVO !!! ;)

Forums › TiVo › !!! ALLERT - DON'T BUY A TIVO !!! ;)

1 | 2 | 3

zaptor

745 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 39

#649462 2-Jul-2012 11:44

Behodar:
crackrdbycracku: Who is still selling them?

Noel Leeming isn't.

The local NL (Whakatane) had several when I was in there on Saturday.

Yeah, got mine from NL for $234. Not as cheap as others, but, it's not a refurbished unit. I think if you just phone around you might find one (depending on where you are of course). Neither NL or BB have them showing on their website, but, they are in stock (albeit limited/dwindling).

Jaxson

8172 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 1332

Trusted

#649470 2-Jul-2012 11:59

Sorry I'm not having a good Monday morning, so this won't be as 'shaped' a comment the other great comments on here....

I personally don't think TIVO is the amazing be all and end all of PVR's. I think it's good at what it does, but in a way that is expected of any PVR. I think the menus are decided non HD looking and I'd personally prefer some lingo to be more PVR standard, like 'Now Playing' sounds conceptually like what's on live TV right now compared to what's been previously recorded etc. I find some of the menu's clunky and little things like that.

What sets it apart though is the cheap as price due to the run out. For the price it really is that good. In a world where you can still buy a stand alone single tuner set top box that connects to an external USB drive for $300, picking up a TIVO at even that price is simply amazing. Add in a free wifi dongle, a web interface and apparently simple steps to upgrade to a larger hard drive etc and it's all pretty impressive.

Examples would be things like I have a universal remote, so I don't care about the peanut. There's nothing on CASPA I want. These are all features that are non events to me, but that shouldn't hold people back, as they are nice to haves but the core product is solid too. TIVO's nothing too amazing to me, and I think it's popularity, simplicity and appeal to many users says more about the general sad state of affairs of competing PVR devices in NZ more than anything.

So, it's not like TIVO offers too much more over say a Magic TV box, but look at the price. TIVO comes in professional packaging, and offers a rock solid product

crackrdbycracku

1168 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 68

#649478 2-Jul-2012 12:09

I agree, the question isn't so much: Why is TiVo great, but why is it good and cheap when so many other alternatives expensive or rubbish or both?

Supplementary question: Why the hell was Caspa never developed into what it could have been?

Solid set-top-box plus over the net content delivery service plus one of NZs biggest (if not the biggest) ISP in Telcom. Gee does anybody else see that as an opportunity gone begging?

Sorry just answered my own question by remembering who the Telecom CEO is.

Cracked By Cracku

Didn't anybody tell you I was a hacker?

Handle9

11927 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 9683

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#649488 2-Jul-2012 12:25

The reason why Tivo is so cheap compared to other PVRs is that Tivos are being dumped to recover something from the investment in stock which was made in 2009. If you compare the retail on them compared to Australia(AU$449) we are getting an excellent deal, just bear in mind that it is in all likelihood at or below Hybrids cost.

http://dicksmith.com.au/product/GH5712/tivo-320-high-definition-dvr

Jaxson

8172 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 1332

Trusted

#649495 2-Jul-2012 12:30

crackrdbycracku: Solid set-top-box plus over the net content delivery service

Someone should look into that market, just ask IGLOO... (Though not the PVR bit

)

and yeah, I agree the clearance is below cost, which means comments like don't buy it, there's another model coming sort of thing are not really apples vs apples as such.

I guess my comment would be that I personally wouldn't necessarily opt for TIVO at full price. I think there are probably better units out there, with what I would call 'newer looking' interfaces etc, but at $300 vs $800 it's a no brainer right now.

Plus this PVR is pre commissioned, meaning it's well tested and works out of the box, without me needing to do testing, report faults back to an NZ distributor in the hope that they release prompt fix firmwares etc. TIVO works, right now.

Handle9

11927 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 9683

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#649511 2-Jul-2012 12:48

Jaxson:
crackrdbycracku: Solid set-top-box plus over the net content delivery service

Someone should look into that market, just ask IGLOO... (Though not the PVR bit )

and yeah, I agree the clearance is below cost, which means comments like don't buy it, there's another model coming sort of thing are not really apples vs apples as such.

I guess my comment would be that I personally wouldn't necessarily opt for TIVO at full price. I think there are probably better units out there, with what I would call 'newer looking' interfaces etc, but at $300 vs $800 it's a no brainer right now.

Plus this PVR is pre commissioned, meaning it's well tested and works out of the box, without me needing to do testing, report faults back to an NZ distributor in the hope that they release prompt fix firmwares etc. TIVO works, right now.

The GUI on TiVo is a bit dated but compared to the other PVRs out there it's the most cohesive experience because it doesn't use the ugly slow crappy Freeview EPG. I really can't overstate how much I hate that piece of junk.

Geekzone

Want to support Geekzone and browse the site without the ads? Subscribe to Geekzone now (monthly, annual and lifetime options).

Jaxson

8172 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 1332

Trusted

#649518 2-Jul-2012 13:00

Handle9: it doesn't use the ugly slow crappy Freeview EPG. I really can't overstate how much I hate that piece of junk.

Getting off topic here but I agree with you. I do think the MHEG5 EPG has it's place, namely for elderly etc as it's fairly clean/un cluttered and obviously as it provides for the series link option. However, their (freeviews) insistence on not simultaneously broadcasting EIT data so companies can do what they want to do with their guide really annoys me. Think all the effort to get Windows 7 Media Centre to work, Sony's PlayTV, how cool Magic TV's native/un-butchered guide looks etc etc.

I just don't get the insistence on a 'universally standard' interface when so much else of the various approved units can be different. And not to mention when it plain doesn't work, as in that other recent thread of a new Samsung TV that cut the end off recordings when using the MHEG5 guide to book them, and my JC Matthews mission where it would record up to Lotto but not resume afterwards etc etc.

For the record, and to bring this back on topic..., TIVO has none of these problems and is far more flexible

jonb

1796 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 545

Trusted

#649525 2-Jul-2012 13:06

DonGould:
CONSUMER WARNING

TiVo's are so bloody wonderful that you risk just spending all your day watching tv and playing with the cool features.

Humans need exercise and TiVo's are a health risk in that regard as running and programing your TiVo from your phone can be very hazard-is in built up areas with traffic on the roads.

Potential buyers should also consider how many units they will need before purchasing and this can impact cost and family budget.

The assumption that your house only needs 1 unit is just wrong and the manufactures are misleading to even suggest this and the issue has, or will be raised with ComCom shortly.

Wifes and children seem to assume some kind of entitlement to Dad's TiVo once they've mastered its operation.

Consumers should also be warned that local distributor, Hybrid, have a clear policy to shame competitors by provider levels of service that other STB owners can only dream about. This kind of service could lead to new expectations being established in the New Zealand market. Such public shaming can not be tolerated.

In summary - TiVos are a clear danger to the heath industry which profits greatly from illness caused by consumer devices that stress consumers. They also provide a level of enjoyment beyond expectation and can cause family disruption as everyone wants a bloody TiVo!

;)

Appendum - dont' have a 2nd TiVo unit in your marital bedroom. For obvious reasons.

BlueShift

1692 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 969

#649547 2-Jul-2012 13:21

crackrdbycracku: Sorry just answered my own question by remembering who the Telecom CEO is.

Correction - not 'is', 'was', as of last Friday.

crackrdbycracku

1168 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 68

#649555 2-Jul-2012 13:29

BlueShift:
crackrdbycracku: Sorry just answered my own question by remembering who the Telecom CEO is.

Correction - not 'is', 'was', as of last Friday.

Good point.

Telcom's support of the TiVo was a farce, wonder how much he had to do with that.

Didn't anybody tell you I was a hacker?

DonGould

3892 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 164

#649756 2-Jul-2012 20:08

jonb:
Appendum - dont' have a 2nd TiVo unit in your marital bedroom. For obvious reasons.

ya not this is a really interesting one... the noise it makes, and it does make noise, never bothered me, but it did bother her.

I honestly thought the TiVo would be out, but the benefits clearly out weighted the annoyance of any noise it makes.

I did get busy and put a pad under it to reduce vibration.

It's amazing how much tolerance people will give to feature set isn't it? ;)

D

Promote New Zealand - Get yourself a .kiwi.nz domain name!!!

Check out mine - i.am.a.can.do.kiwi.nz - don@i.am.a.can.do.kiwi.nz

1 | 2 | 3