Well I decided to give VDSL another go - as suspected it doesn't seem to have improved at all. After having a bit of fun getting the Edgerouter to authenticate (turns out I had to first create a virtual interface over the correct Eth interface with VLAN10, then setup the pppoe interface over that.
Screenshots here of line stats on ADSL
and VDSL
I think that answers my original question anyway, haha.