Rushmere:
WyleECoyoteNZ: Well done Sky, you've taken over a product and made it worse.
2 main issues:
1) Requires a satellite dish, why? If they are able to provide Vodafone TV over the internet, why can't the new box do this? Seems to be a backward step to me.
2) Why can the Pod Watch Live or From the Start, but the Box can't. And the box can't scroll back, but the Pod can Another backward step
I suspect the Sky Pod was a bit of an afterthought when the Vodafone TV issue emerged, and has been put together hastily to fill a gap. The Sky Box has probably been in development longer, and scrolling back wasn't part of the specification at that point.
It does seem a bit weird to not allow the Sky Box to operate without a satellite dish.
I wonder if they'll add these missing capabilities to the Sky Box at a later date?
You almost need to be able to plug both devices into each other for the ideal solution.