geekIT:
So I skimmed the 55 thread pages and now agree with the many who've concluded that the money would be better spent on beer or chocolate.
Horses for courses. It depends on what your needs are.
For us - we want to record stuff on some channels that aren't available to us outside the Sky environment.
We don't watch live stuff.
We have the couch in front of the TV with the box directly connected to the TV.
We stream stuff that is available via apps on the box.
So for US, it's a perfectly fine one-stop shop.
I have no idea if we are in the minority amongst Sky customers, or if we're in the majority.
I have 40 years as an engineer under my belt (half of which was working in TV) and I find the box's UI to be acceptable. Not perfect, but acceptable. Ours isn't laggy like some folk are reporting.
As always - YMMV.