The Pirate Bay: Winning>?

Forums › Off topic › The Pirate Bay: Winning>?

rossmnz

507 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 31

Topic # 30703 18-Feb-2009 14:26

Day 2 of the trial of TPB in Sweden.

Avast, ye scurvy sea dogs!! half of the charges have been dropped. Harr Harr, me hearties!

In a spectacular fail, the prosecuting team doesnt understand bit torrent protocol, and TPB leadership poke fun at them in a series of hilarious posts.

See: http://i.gizmodo.com/5154950/pirate-bay-trial-watch-day-2-half-of-the-charges-have-been-dropped

I find myself supporting TPB hard. Not least 'cos of the fact that the bit torrent protocol will fall over completely if they get shut down.

The force is strong with this one!

honem

194 posts

Master Geek

Trusted

Reply # 196591 18-Feb-2009 20:04

I find myself supporting TPB hard. Not least 'cos of the fact that the bit torrent protocol will fall over completely if they get shut down.

I fail to see how TPB going down would effect the bit torrent protocol.

Just like if one server shuts down does not shut down the FTP procol.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BitTorrent_(protocol)

Basically the way bit torrent works , as long as you have a tracker server and sufficient people with near complete copy of the file it will still work. TPB is only 1 of many torrent servers. There are also many businesses that distribute their stuff using bit torrent technology.

If the TPB does get shut down some of us will cry. But it will not stop the bit torrent protocol completely

==================================
- Hone , Often accused of Excess Verbosity
==================================

rossmnz

507 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 31

Reply # 196612 18-Feb-2009 22:15

http://www.gizmodo.com.au/2009/02/if_pirate_bay_is_shut_down_it_could_take_all_of_bittorrent_with_it-2.html

Maybe it wont fall over completely (ok ok i got carried away)but it will still be chaos for a while. Tracking over 50% of all torrents according to the above.

Could be setting up for a spectacular fail-all our eggs in one basket so to speak.

Makes you wonder if the RIAA tards would stoop to terrorism and blow up TPBs servers it would work just as well lol

The force is strong with this one!

old3eyes

7887 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 792

Subscriber

Reply # 196636 19-Feb-2009 08:27

After the fantastic success of sect 92 here in NZ next week the RIAA with then try and bribe all other Govs around the world to introduce the same legislation except this time it will the death penalty and not having your internet cut off.. That's how they will close TPB.

Regards,

Old3eyes

sbiddle

27126 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 6567

Moderator

Trusted

Biddle Corp

Lifetime subscriber

Reply # 196645 19-Feb-2009 08:53

Day 3 summary in a nutshell.

TPB claims they are nothing more than a search engine and that no copyrighted material ever passes through it's servers. They claim they are no different to using Google and adding filetype:torrent

honem

194 posts

Master Geek

Trusted

Reply # 196689 19-Feb-2009 12:59

rossmnz: http://www.gizmodo.com.au/2009/02/if_pirate_bay_is_shut_down_it_could_take_all_of_bittorrent_with_it-2.html

Maybe it wont fall over completely (ok ok i got carried away)but it will still be chaos for a while. Tracking over 50% of all torrents according to the above.

From the url you posted :

It is unlikely, of course, that BitTorrent as a protocol will fail. Someone will rise up to take the place of the Pirate Bay, and trackerless torrents are also in the works. But right now, the entire ecosystem depends on a single site, whose operators are about to go on trial for copyright violations. Nevertheless, all eyes should be on Stockholm next week if you're a torrenter. You can watch the Pirate Bay trial live thanks to Swedish public TV.

Sounds like sensationalist talk to me quite frankly. Yes if TPB goes down torrent traffic world wide might be affected. But it won't mean a thing to the protocol it uses. The concept and methodology of the Bittorrent protocol is already out there in both commercial and residential applications. You can't really put that genie back in the bottle.

If TPB goes down I have no doubt in my mind that something else somewhere else would raise up in it's place. I still very much doubt a huge "chain reaction" will results in taking ALL Bit torrent trackers off line. What they going to do require all ISPs in the world suddenly start refusing bit torrent packets ????

==================================
- Hone , Often accused of Excess Verbosity
==================================

CYaBro

2974 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 290

Reply # 196707 19-Feb-2009 14:17

I thought TPB servers had been moved out of Sweden after they got raided last time?
So even if TPB do lose how are they going to force them to shutdown the servers that aren't even in the country??

Computer Repairs Whangarei
Apple Authorised Reseller
Apple Authorised Service Provider

honem

194 posts

Master Geek

Trusted

Reply # 196805 19-Feb-2009 22:22

rossmnz: http://www.gizmodo.com.au/2009/02/if_pirate_bay_is_shut_down_it_could_take_all_of_bittorrent_with_it-2.html

I had a look at their graph for "top 20 bit torrent trackers" , their so called proof that 50% of Bittorrent tracker goes through TPB.

Except for pirate bay none of them were trackers I have ever used. None of them are trackers that have every come up from a random torrent search.None of the popular ones I use are on their. None of them are ones that come up from a google search for torrents.

Me thinks their so called "scientific study by a panel of experts" has skewed results that show what they want people to see (ie lying with statistics by omitting stuff)

==================================
- Hone , Often accused of Excess Verbosity
==================================

boby55

1539 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 39

Trusted

Reply # 196808 19-Feb-2009 22:31

CYaBro: I thought TPB servers had been moved out of Sweden after they got raided last time?
So even if TPB do lose how are they going to force them to shutdown the servers that aren't even in the country??

they have servers around the world now, so if one country goes down the next will be up in minutes

www.stealthisfilm.com is a really good film about the freedom of speech when it comes to bit torrent and so on from both sides of the game MPAA / Piratebay admins