Changing Broadband

Forums › New Zealand Broadband › Changing Broadband

Kelburn

25 posts

Geek

# 41841 23-Sep-2009 21:38

Hi,
I'm currently with Slingshot. Currently got 25GB data per month but speed is capped at 256k.
I was thinking of moving up to full speed (downloading - uploading doesn't concern me) and changing providers.

I finalised it to:

Actrix@$49.95 - 10GB
Inspire@$52.50 - 5GB
Maxnet@$44.95 - 5GB
Xnet@$44.19 - 10GB
ICONZ@$49.95 - 10GB
Orcon@$47.95 - 6GB
Snap@$49.95 - 20GB

What are the recommendations or opinions? I'm really keen on details to do with speed - most downloading is youtube/web surfing as well as FTP servers...
Cheers,
Kelburn

1 | 2

1539 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

# 257941 23-Sep-2009 22:10

Telecom 10gb $49.95 , 20gb $59.95 or Unlimited (BigTime) $59.95

Kelburn

25 posts

Geek

# 257942 23-Sep-2009 22:13

thanks for your reply but I'd prefer not to use Telecom/Slingshot etc. (the biggies). Bad reviews/publicity.
A lot of what 'm basing it on is the consumer report as well.

Ragnor

8033 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

# 257956 23-Sep-2009 23:49

Maxnet or Snap probably have the best real world peak time performance out of that list. I would avoid Xnet and Orcon and I haven't heard anything good or bad about Iconz recently.

Upload sync speed should concern you as 128Kbit upload will constrain your download speed for anything using tcp/ip (eg: http, ftp etc).

rscole86

4352 posts

Uber Geek

Moderator

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

# 257967 24-Sep-2009 08:02

I have not heard anything bad about Telecoms services for a wee while now, and have been really happy with them myself.

cyril7

6902 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

Subscriber

# 257968 24-Sep-2009 08:07

I also agree with Ross, you would be crazy not to concider Telecom or TCL.

Cyril

JoeRandom

43 posts

Geek

# 258032 24-Sep-2009 11:12

I never had any peak time slowdowns with orcon(8months ago), at leat nowhare near as bad as i do with x-net. I would try Orcon and if you dont like it change after a month as it will cost you nothing as long as you have you own modem

Kelburn

25 posts

Geek

# 258185 24-Sep-2009 22:12

Sorry but am ruling out Xtra.

But what are peoples perspectives of Xnet and Actrix or Orcon mainly. Those are the ones I'm steering towards. Xnet seems to get a good rap around here...

matt45

307 posts

Ultimate Geek

# 258186 24-Sep-2009 22:20

you do realise that no matter what isp you go to you will still be connected to telecoms equipment and (effectivly) still paying them to a certain degree. The only real difference between isp's is the the traffic routing, i am with telecom and have never got anything but fullspeed 24/7.

(this post assumes that you cannot get ucll)

Disclaimer: Comments I make are NOT on behalf of my employer, these comments are mine and mine alone.

vexxxboy

2884 posts

Uber Geek

# 258187 24-Sep-2009 22:22

xnet ?, a good rap, what forums are you reading lol

Common sense is not as common as you think.

Kelburn

25 posts

Geek

# 258189 24-Sep-2009 22:27

Well these forums...
Anyway apart from the majors, who would you recommend - I want good speed. Using the consumer report, most internet majors such as Telecom or Slingshot, performed really badly which is why I'm avoiding them.

nzbnw

2366 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

Spark

# 258191 24-Sep-2009 22:32

Kelburn: Well these forums...
Anyway apart from the majors, who would you recommend - I want good speed. Using the consumer report, most internet majors such as Telecom or Slingshot, performed really badly which is why I'm avoiding them.

I think you should look again. Check out the forums of the ISP's here on Geekzone and you'll quickly notice those who are not preforming and those that are.

A number of Geekzone members have left ISP's such as Xnet, which use to be almost the ISP of choice around here, and a number of these have moved to larger ISP's such as Telecom.

Don't be so quick to rule out the majors.

nzbnw

matt45

307 posts

Ultimate Geek

# 258192 24-Sep-2009 22:34

no offence but the consumer report IMO is a load of c*** they dont measure the right things and allow far too many variables.

Disclaimer: Comments I make are NOT on behalf of my employer, these comments are mine and mine alone.

Ragnor

8033 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

# 258197 24-Sep-2009 22:55

Telstra and Telecom (normal plans not BigTime) have the least flexible pricing models which is a valid reason for ruling them out, however they typically have the most international capacity and the best peak time performance.

I also think the consumers report is next to useless.

Kelburn

25 posts

Geek

# 258202 24-Sep-2009 23:07

right then. What I want is a plan that's not too expensive but has really good speed. NZ internet always seems to have this complication.

insane

2380 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

Subscriber

# 258214 24-Sep-2009 23:31

Kelburn: right then. What I want is a plan that's not too expensive but has really good speed. NZ internet always seems to have this complication.

have a look at these graphs for an idea on performance
http://bgrade.bage.net.nz/results_summary.php

In my mind the results are better than those of a report like Epitiro, but again perhaps not as good as real-world multithreaded downloads.

1 | 2