First time poster here

My story is very common, moved a house and need to decide on ISP. I've been reading these forums for about a week now and can't make my mind up as all seem to be hated by some of their users and unfortunately I can't seem to distinguish between an occasional problem and ongoing failure to deliver service.
Usage: Pretty lite - no gaming, no torrents, occasional downloads (audio), and 2-3 youtube clips a day + general browsing - I'm thinking I need about 5Gb. So speed is more important than capacity.
Location: Eden Terrace, Auckland
Overall: I'm looking for some knowledgeable performance-based comparison between these plans.
Several plans which appeal to me, but feel free to suggest any others:
Plan
Cost / Type / Allowance / Up/Down / Phone
Slingshot big thing
$70 / ADSL / 5Gb / FS/FS / Fixed Line
Compass
$73 / Wireless / 5Gb / 5Mb/1Mb / Voip
Xnet fusion unlimited
$75 / Naked / 5Gb / FS/FS / VoIP
Slingshot just broadband
$80 / Naked / 25Gb / FS/FS / VoIP
Orcon silver
$80 / ADSl / 5Gb / FS/FS / Fixed Line
Vodafone Ideal
$80 / ADSL / 5Gb / FS/128kbp / Fixed Line
Telecom Total home lite
$80 / ADSL / 5GB / FS/FS / Fixed Line
Thanks
