Hello213: Dynalink RTA1025W:
Linksys WAG200G:
Netcomm NB6Plus4W:
other(please say):

garvani: 3com Officeconnect 3CRWDR101A-75

tonyhughes:

Hello213: Dynalink RTA1025W:
Linksys WAG200G:
Netcomm NB6Plus4W:
other(please say):

What exactly is your poll?

Are you asking who owns one of those? Or whether we think they are good? Or which is most unreliable?

xpd:

garvani: 3com Officeconnect 3CRWDR101A-75

+1

Been a great little unit overall, even with the cat chewing the antenna's to bits.

garvani:

xpd:

garvani: 3com Officeconnect 3CRWDR101A-75

+1

Been a great little unit overall, even with the cat chewing the antenna's to bits.

We have sold well over 200 of them and only had problems with 2 in 3 years! (both were d.o.a power adapters). We were selling linksys, dlinks, etc but had too much problems. Just waiting on the 3CRWDR300A-73 wireless N version to come down in price and we will standardise on that..

Ragnor: Depends on your definition of best..

Best under a certain price?  I could list a "best" router that costs $1000 if you like.  What's your budget?  What's your geek level, do you want to be able to install custom community developed firmware with cool features that default firmware doesn't come with?  Do you just want an all in one device that does the job without much tweaking?

In my personal opinion (for a geek or enthusiast) an all in one device will never be best.  What you want is a solid modem device that acts as a dumb bridge to a server doing firewall/QoS/caching/traffic measurement.  Add traditional switches or wireless ap's as required after that.

Dynalink and Netcomm are basically the same company so it's probably pointless comparing those two since internally they are likely to be similar if not identical.

So out of those you listed I would rate them like this: Dynalink RTA1025W > WAG200G because my experience with the WAG200G is bad on ADSL2+ and LLU lines.

Depending on your budget you might want to consider Belkin and Netgear routers.

garvani: 3com Officeconnect 3CRWDR101A-75