Audioengine A2+. Are these the best option for PC audio for music?

Forums › Gadgets, robotics, home automation, electronics (including wearables) › Audioengine A2+. Are these the best option for PC audio for music?

dafman

3791 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

#306269 9-Jul-2023 17:58

I’m looking for a pair of active desktop PC speakers, primarily for music.

I currently use a single Sonos One, but want something I can connect to my PC, and stereo

I really like the look/size of the Audioengine A2+

But …

While the A2+ get rave reviews on ‘commercial’ review sites, there are some pretty disparaging comments on Reddit and the Noaudophile review was far from glowing:

“This is a computer speaker that sounds pretty good, but it's not great. I'm a picky bastard, so I would classify the stock sound as hideous. With the over enthusiastic "look at me" midbass being a deal breaker. Outside of the bass response the treble is pretty clean, but hides information with a dip in the response. I've heard plenty worse, but only a few for this much money.”

So hoping for some real world NZ feedback from owners. I read some of the older GZ forum threads on these, but any 2023 thoughts would be appreciated.

And … if not the A2+, what else do you recommend. I don’t want large speakers for my desk, which is the main appeal of the A2s

Thanks.

Goosey

2337 posts

Uber Geek

Subscriber

#3101732 9-Jul-2023 18:24

What sort of audio quality are you looking for?

surley the Sonos has better audio quality than the look of these?

Search for “bookshelf speakers”

what’s your budget?

why do you have a need to connect to your stereo?

GoodSync

GoodSync. Easily back up and sync your files with GoodSync. Simple and secure file backup and synchronisation software will ensure that your files are never lost (affiliate link).

dafman

3791 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

#3101734 9-Jul-2023 18:40

Goosey:

What sort of audio quality are you looking for?

surley the Sonos has better audio quality than the look of these?

Search for “bookshelf speakers”

what’s your budget?

why do you have a need to connect to your stereo?

I am a fan of Sonos - we use these throughout the house - but I want these speakers to be an extension of my PC when I am working from home at my desk. The Sonos cannot be connected to the PC and is restricted to the Sonos app.

My poor wording, I want stereo speakers (x2), not connect to my stereo.

My budget is $500 - $800, but would prefer to stay towards lower end if possible.

Goosey

2337 posts

Uber Geek

Subscriber

#3101739 9-Jul-2023 19:51

I see,

would a cheap wifi card or dongle allow you to stream to the Sonus from the PC?
(im not sure if that’s able to be done whilst plugged into Ethernet but as I type…I’m now realising maybe not).

Bluetooth from Sonos to PC? (Bluetooth dongle)?

anyway, good luck searching for a reasonable sounding set….book shelfs will be your way to go….or speakers with sub? E.g. altec Lansing? Kilpch etc etc.

would a tv sound bar with sub sort you out?

Sideface

8436 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#3101742 9-Jul-2023 20:15

I am an audiophile and computer geek.

I have used Audioengine A2+ speakers on two desktop computers for several years - they are excellent near-field speakers for music and voice.

Plus an Audioengine D1 headphone amplifier. Superb!

Also a pair of (larger) Audioengine A5+ speakers for my TV. These fill a large room with good sound.

Very highly recommended!

Sideface

Poll

340 posts

Ultimate Geek

#3101750 9-Jul-2023 21:53

The other path you can go down is to look at some studio monitors, for example I've got KRK Rokit 5's with a Focusrite Scarlett 2i2 usb soundcard, they're pretty flat sounding as they're designed around music creation more than listening but I use them primarily for listening and find music sounds great through them.

phrozenpenguin

763 posts

Ultimate Geek

#3101753 9-Jul-2023 22:20

I use the Audioengine A2+ on my desktop setup and think they are great. I wouldn't class myself as any kind of "audiophile" but I've had "decent" speakers for a while and these don't disappoint. Also very nice and compact, bluetooth comes in handy sometimes, do what they were designed for.

If you are considering bookshelff speakers and a sub like some other suggestions these are a very different option in terms of physical size - if you haven't seen them run the measurements. They are tiny - a fraction of the size of the monitor speakers we ran before.

I've had no need to explore what else is on the market so can't help with any newer/2023 options. But I would buy these again easily.

dafman

3791 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

#3106774 21-Jul-2023 18:09

Still researching, thanks for comments so far.

Just wondering how the PreSonus Eris 3.5 would stack up against the Audioengine A2+?

The Eris are a little bigger, plus and have the bass port at back rather than front - both of which appeal to me.

Reviews for the Eris are generally positive - although these are studio monitors so may not be the best for streaming music?

Sideface

8436 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#3106782 21-Jul-2023 19:00

dafman: Reviews for the Eris are generally positive - although these are studio monitors so may not be the best for streaming music?

Audioengine A2+ are designed as compact near-field speakers for use with a desktop system - they are not meant to fill a room.

Studio monitors are designed to fill a room, and listened to from a distance - they tend to be larger and louder.

Horses for courses. Go with the Audioengine. 🙂

Sideface

Handle9

9633 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#3106791 21-Jul-2023 19:45

dafman:

Still researching, thanks for comments so far.

Just wondering how the PreSonus Eris 3.5 would stack up against the Audioengine A2+?

The Eris are a little bigger, plus and have the bass port at back rather than front - both of which appeal to me.

Reviews for the Eris are generally positive - although these are studio monitors so may not be the best for streaming music?

I run Eris 4.5s on my desk. They are excellent but for best results you need a good quality DAC. Putting a Schiit Modi into my setup made a big difference.

Edit: I have 4.5s. My senility is advancing as expected.

Handle9

9633 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#3106793 21-Jul-2023 19:49

Sideface:

dafman: Reviews for the Eris are generally positive - although these are studio monitors so may not be the best for streaming music?

Audioengine A2+ are designed as compact near-field speakers for use with a desktop system - they are not meant to fill a room.

Studio monitors are designed to fill a room, and listened to from a distance - they tend to be larger and louder.

Horses for courses. Go with the Audioengine. 🙂

3.5 inch drivers filling a room?

Eris 3.5s are near field studio monitors.

Handle9

9633 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#3106796 21-Jul-2023 19:56

@dafman these threads may also be useful

https://www.geekzone.co.nz/forums.asp?forumid=34&topicid=275752

https://www.geekzone.co.nz/forums.asp?forumid=34&topicid=289654

networkn

Networkn
30188 posts

Uber Geek

ID Verified

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#3106861 22-Jul-2023 10:43

Also worth considering edifier which consistently rate well, and are often on great discounts at a variety of places.

A few years ago I had a Klipsch 5.1 PC system I loved.

dafman

3791 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

#3107039 22-Jul-2023 19:09

After much online research, procrastination, and taking into account GZ feedback …

I’ve ordered the A2+ with stands. I want near field PC speakers, not looking to fill a room, so the A2+ compact sizing was a key deciding factor over competing slightly larger options.

I’ll report back in due course once received and broken in.

dafman

3791 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

#3121255 28-Aug-2023 15:47

Ok, I've now had the A2s for several weeks.

I was a little disappointed initially - the speakers were very detailed (which was great) but I found them a little fatiguing to listen to over several hours at my desk. I was aware of their bass limitations before purchase, but after set up I needed more fuller sound.

So I hooked up an Energy 8" sub and was immediately much happier. The Energy sub blends beautifully with the A2s.

Also, several weeks in, now that the speakers have broken in, they have a slightly more warmer sound, but still very detailed. So, I am very happy with my purchase.

Build quality is excellent and they look great on the desk. I have connected to PC via USB (using the internal DAC), but on occasions I want bluetooth via iPhone they flawlessly connect every time. In fact, almost too good, I can be elsewhere in the house connecting to a portable speaker and I hear sound from the other end of the house as the A2's beat the portable speaker to connect!

Will add an external DAC in due course to try and eek out a little more quality from these.

Thanks all for your comments pre purchase.