Looking for new phone. LG G4/LG G5/One Plus 3

Forums › Android › Looking for new phone. LG G4/LG G5/One Plus 3

olivernz

158 posts

Master Geek
+1 received by user: 34

Topic # 199016 1-Aug-2016 10:44

Hey,

My wife's Nexus 5 is slowly giving up (frequent restarts, oversensitive off button). She needs something new. Main use is reading (kindle) and photos aside from the usual stuff. I have a LG G4 and am VERY happy with it. Now the question is what to get her. Id get her an LG G4 but since tech has moved on was looking at the LG G5 but I read a LOT about bad quality. Only other handset that comes to mind is the One Plus 3 but is a little hard to come by.

So anyone out there that can make a call on the LG G5? Is it really that bad? Any other ideas? Oh and I won't buy Samsung.

Cheers & Thanks for any help!

Oliver

1 | 2

14142 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 2546

Trusted

Subscriber

Reply # 1602083 1-Aug-2016 10:49

2 people support this post

I just got my Mum an LG G4, it's still a good phone and it's pretty good value, so maybe it is a good option.

Consider a kindle paperwhite for reading if it's a key use. They're smallish, slim, light, and MUCH better for reading both in the sun and in bed. Phones emit lots of blue light which inhibits sleep, the kindle doesn't emit so much and it's not quite as blue. If kindle is the main use then get one of them ($200) and a basic phone. The phone app and hardware kindle sync reading position between them.

AWS Certified Solution Architect Professional, Sysop Administrator Associate, and Developer Associate
TOGAF certified enterprise architect
Professional photographer

olivernz

158 posts

Master Geek
+1 received by user: 34

Reply # 1602104 1-Aug-2016 11:21

Actually leaning towards the LG G4. I already know it's a good phone and don't have to take a gamble. As for the kindle, been there done that. She doesn't really use it. It's just another device. She is German and that means she reads everywhere and anywhere. Yes, fully aware of the blue tint (SAD suffere here ;-) )

olivernz

158 posts

Master Geek
+1 received by user: 34

Reply # 1604860 5-Aug-2016 10:25

Ok, so just as an update, my LG G4 just died yesterday. Aparently a known boot-loop issue (hardware). So that went off to get fixed. In the meantime I now ordered a One Plus 3. See how that goes...

jonathan18

3045 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 746

Reply # 1604872 5-Aug-2016 10:42

So between Monday and today you've purchased a G4 that's already developed that @#$@# fault? That's really bad luck...

I had planned on getting the G4 for my wife but then found out about this boot loop problem so looked elsewhere (we got her a Huawei P8 when NL's had them for $349 the other day). I had planned on replacing my G3 with a newer version of the same series when the time came, but given the problems with both G4 and apparently G5 I may have to go back to square one! Not sure if I'm yet ready for a Chinese-sourced phone, given the irritations caused with my wife's previous phone (Xiaomi Redmi Note 2).

timmmay

14142 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 2546

Trusted

Subscriber

Reply # 1604876 5-Aug-2016 10:47

jonathan18:

So between Monday and today you've purchased a G4 that's already developed that @#$@# fault? That's really bad luck...

Already owns it, read p1.

AWS Certified Solution Architect Professional, Sysop Administrator Associate, and Developer Associate
TOGAF certified enterprise architect
Professional photographer

jonathan18

3045 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 746

Reply # 1604886 5-Aug-2016 10:53

timmmay:

jonathan18:

So between Monday and today you've purchased a G4 that's already developed that @#$@# fault? That's really bad luck...

Already owns it, read p1.

Ah! My bad... Still, a p!sser his phone's developed this fault; long may your mother's phone remain free of it!

It really does seem the G3 was the last decently reliable LG flagship phone. Mine's still going fine, touch wood, and fast enough for me.

timmmay

14142 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 2546

Trusted

Subscriber

Reply # 1604896 5-Aug-2016 11:05

How do they get fixed in NZ? I got Mum's from a store in Auckland, suspect it's parallel imported. Probably just ask the store.

AWS Certified Solution Architect Professional, Sysop Administrator Associate, and Developer Associate
TOGAF certified enterprise architect
Professional photographer

sxz

645 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 148

Reply # 1604924 5-Aug-2016 11:16

I took a risk with the G5 and I love it. Best phone I've ever used. Camera is great, and additional wide angle camera is AWESOME.

Better than my wife's G4.

Consumer guarantees act man - take a risk on it. It's dropped to about $650 retail, I'd buy this phone again in a heartbeat

olivernz

158 posts

Master Geek
+1 received by user: 34

Reply # 1604968 5-Aug-2016 12:28

One person supports this post

Hi,

The original question was to replace my wife's phone an aging Nexus 5 (which has had a LOT of use and is OK to break down). I've found out that it's a known issue with the on/off button sticking. So I ordered some from china and will have a soldering job when they get here. But I still intended to replace it. Anyway then my LG G4 broke yesterday. Bought from Harvey Norman (ex 2degrees stock) in December. They took it back on warranty with absolutely minimal red tape! Kudos! They said LG had a great service so should be back in about a week (instead of two like most other manufacturers). So hoping that all works out. But I realised yesterday I can't work withouta phone for a week. I grabbed back our ex phone (iPhone 4S) from the kids for the next days and then decided to go ahead and order the One Plus 3 which should be here tomorrow. Once the LG is back from service we can then decide, who gets what phone.

Although the LG giving up is annoying I would have bought it again. HN has it on again for $799. The One Plus 3 is next gen though with a Snapdragon 820 and set me back $769. So I thought I'd give it a shot. The OP3 has three drawbacks for me. No QHD screen (which I can survive), no microSD slot (but has 64GB which is enough but really??? No microSD) and no FM radio (the surprising bonus feature on the LG G4 which I found great). Not so sure I can do without the latter but I think there are these things called single-use devices... ;-)

Anyway The OP3 has great reviews as opposed to the LG G5. Both are about the same price atm and both are only available as parallel imports. Most of the tech is the same too. I just thought I'd try Chinese after dining Korean. The only other device that was in the race was the Nexus 5X. The big advantage being fast Android releases and compatibility. But it soon fell out of competition as same gen as LG G4 at lesser specs.

Oliver

olivernz

158 posts

Master Geek
+1 received by user: 34

Reply # 1606345 8-Aug-2016 14:15

2 people support this post

Ok. Feedback time. Got theOne Plus 3 on Saturday (thanks PBtech for putting in the effort there!!). Nice phone! Design is impecable. Yes, the camerahump is a nuisance but physically inevitable. And on that note the camera is definitely better than the one on the LG G4. And I thought that one was stellar. The camera app though is definitely not as good.

The screen is weird. It is OLED so it has these poppy colours and deep blacks. Actually makes movie vieweing worse imho. You can switch to sRGB though. We'll see. I also note the step down from QHD to FHD. I can see pixels. But maybe it's a figment of my mind.

Love the fingerprint sensor, the speed, The fact that it doesn't heat up at all. Battery looks long lasting at least compared to the LG. Microphones are a bit meh. Struggling a bit on skype. But that might just be noise cancellation being overzealous. Did I mention the GREAT feel and design? It's not inspirational but they just got it all right. I also like that it feels a lot like the Nexus 5. Basically stock Android and not much else.

Still downsides are a missing FM radio, no microSD, no QHD, no wireless charging.

But for the price ($769) it's a great buy and I'd be torn between the LG G4 and this. I'd probably go with the One Plus 3 eventually.

Also amazing, since it's a parallel import it comes with a US plug. PBtech put in a surge protected adapter to AU AND they put a dual USB AU 2A charger into the packet too. That IS thoughtful. Oh and the OP3 doesn't come with earbuds. So need to buy those extra if you need some.

Cheers Oliver

jaypeegee

26 posts

Geek
+1 received by user: 3

Reply # 1607015 9-Aug-2016 15:05

+1 for the One plus

Dual SIM is great and running the resurrection ROM is at least as good as the original OS

PBTech were fantastic also, Ordered Thursday evening. Arrived at WGTN Friday early afternoon

Son is jealous AF though.....

olivernz

158 posts

Master Geek
+1 received by user: 34

Reply # 1607429 10-Aug-2016 09:50

I am talking OP3 though not OP1. Resurrection ROM I only see for OP1. Also am quite happy with standard OS.

olivernz

158 posts

Master Geek
+1 received by user: 34

Reply # 1610070 11-Aug-2016 12:30

Kudos to LG New Zealand! Managed to turn around the repair of my LG G4 in 4 workdays. Mainboard was exchanged. That is excellent service.

jaypeegee

26 posts

Geek
+1 received by user: 3

Reply # 1610154 11-Aug-2016 15:05

olivernz:

I am talking OP3 though not OP1. Resurrection ROM I only see for OP1. Also am quite happy with standard OS.

If that was a reply to me I have the 1+3 also

The RR is great although I had to reflash it when I got a second SIM

The standard OS was also very good but I missed a couple of extra things like ad blocking and some of the cosmetic flourishes

If that wasn't a reply to me then I apologise

olivernz

158 posts

Master Geek
+1 received by user: 34

Reply # 1610186 11-Aug-2016 16:05

It was. Thanks. Just wasn't clear in your post which phone you meant. :)

1 | 2