POTS to ADSL phone changes ring pattern & confuses PABX

Forums › One New Zealand (including Vodafone, WxC, Farmside) › POTS to ADSL phone changes ring pattern & confuses PABX

1 | 2

nztim

3819 posts

Uber Geek

ID Verified

Trusted

TEAMnetwork

Subscriber

#3186648 26-Jan-2024 09:19

decibel:

All very good talking about VoIP etc but the root cause is that Vodafone has botched the ring cadence on the new system.

There is no requirement for the RSPs to make sure customers CPE is compatible when moving from the NEAX to VOIP

This includes but not limited to Alarms, EFTPOS, PBXs, Medical Equipment

If it works after the move, great, if not the customer needs to upgrade their CPE

Any views expressed on these forums are my own and don't necessarily reflect those of my employer.

Linux

11429 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#3186650 26-Jan-2024 09:21

decibel:

All very good talking about VoIP etc but the root cause is that Vodafone has botched the ring cadence on the new system.

It is Vodafone (or ONE) who you need to refer this too.

@decibel Incorrect VodafoneNZ / OneNZ did not provide them with the PBX

old3eyes

9120 posts

Uber Geek

Subscriber

#3186704 26-Jan-2024 09:31

decibel:

All very good talking about VoIP etc but the root cause is that Vodafone has botched the ring cadence on the new system.

It is Vodafone (or ONE) who you need to refer this too.

The two second on and four second off is not new on Vodafone analog trunks. I first struck this on NEC PBX systems about 10 years ago on their Centrex offerings. From memory they weren't the only ones . I seem to remember Spark did the same.

Posters here suggesting that SIP trunks should have been installed are correct unless there is a hardware issue in that they can't be provisioned.

Regards,

Old3eyes

richms

28191 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#3186739 26-Jan-2024 10:32

decibel:

All very good talking about VoIP etc but the root cause is that Vodafone has botched the ring cadence on the new system.

It is Vodafone (or ONE) who you need to refer this too.

There is no botch, because its working fine with analog handsets which is what they sell the service to work with. If you choose to put a PABX on it which is not a supported configuration from One, then that is on you or the integrator to make sure that these changes will work for you.

Richard rich.ms

slaw54

10 posts

Wannabe Geek

#3186833 26-Jan-2024 13:37

richms

They wanted to push the changeover through and assured that everything would be the same as on the old system other that that our lines would appear on two sockets rather than a piece of copper, as you say if a standard analog phone works (albeit with a different cadence) then end of story.

nztim

3819 posts

Uber Geek

ID Verified

Trusted

TEAMnetwork

Subscriber

#3186838 26-Jan-2024 13:50

slaw54:

They wanted to push the changeover through

They Had not Choice Spark which owns the NEAX switches (and sells to other providers) are progressively shutting these down.

slaw54:

and assured that everything would be the same as on the old system other that that our lines would appear on two sockets rather than a piece of copper

Understand this is frustrating, and it should have been explained up front that various PBXs, EFTPOS Terminals, and Alarms may not work post changeover, that aside it will still not stop this process from happening, once the NEAXs are removed VOIP is your only option.

Any views expressed on these forums are my own and don't necessarily reflect those of my employer.

richms

28191 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#3186912 26-Jan-2024 15:06

nztim:

once the NEAXs are removed VOIP is your only option.

Or cellular. 2degrees will let you take a landline number to a sim card and then that can go into a gateway. They say its not supported but it works fine for the people I know doing it because their copper is dire and voip never worked over their wireless broadband properly. OP is remote so there is a good chance that since they are still on ADSL they will have issues with crap copper that noone will ever want to fix.

Richard rich.ms

Sharesies

Trade NZ and US shares and funds with Sharesies (affiliate link).

decibel

316 posts

Ultimate Geek

#3187278 27-Jan-2024 13:51

You are in a tricky situation here.

I suspect that the problem with the "...This is causing the PABX to drop and then pickup the line.. " is actually caused by the modem not maintaining polarity reversal during the silent period of the ring and not the ring cadence itself. (this is/was a known issue back in the day.)

This should all be configurable in the modem settings. For many years I used a Linksys ATA off 2talk and that was the case there.

I have just looked up the specifications at ComCom and although there is quite a bit about ring cadence, I cannot see anything about the DC polarity

If you get no joy from ONE, you can follow the suggestion of @old3eyes and set the ring validation timer to 3 seconds.

Or, better still, take the advice of a lot of people here and change to SIP trunking.

1 | 2