Geekzone: technology news, blogs, forums
Guest
Welcome Guest.
You haven't logged in yet. If you don't have an account you can register now.




40 posts

Geek


# 182433 15-Oct-2015 16:03
Send private message

Alternator in our car failed about six months ago and we got it repaired by local dealer.
Dealer organised a replacement part from some company in AKL that sells refurbished alternators.
Alternator came with 12 month warranty.

Now replacement alternator packed up too and we took the car back to same garage.
I just got a call saying that alternator is free but we have to pay for labor cost which in this case is about $250 because "alternator warranty was provided by other company"

This doesn't sound quite right to me?? I do not have any contract with this 3rd party who provided refurbished alternator.
Is dealer just trying to pick my pockets or do they actually have rights to charge the labor from me under CGA?

View this topic in a long page with up to 500 replies per page Create new topic
 1 | 2 | 3
2650 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted
Subscriber

  # 1407330 15-Oct-2015 16:12
2 people support this post
Send private message

He is trying it on. You are correct that as your dealer supplied the alternator he is responsible for replacing it if it failed.

8952 posts

Uber Geek


  # 1407342 15-Oct-2015 16:30
Send private message

$250 sounds like a very steep labour cost to replace an alternator. I'd have expected perhaps 1 hour labour maximum, unless it's extraordinarily complicated to get access to it (possible but unlikely).
But anyway, you shouldn't be paying anything at all.

 
 
 
 




40 posts

Geek


  # 1407344 15-Oct-2015 16:36
Send private message

Fred99: $250 sounds like a very steep labour cost to replace an alternator. I'd have expected perhaps 1 hour labour maximum, unless it's extraordinarily complicated to get access to it (possible but unlikely).


It actually is extraordinary complicated and requires removing bumper, one headlamp housing, power steering pump bolts etc. and wiggling alternator out from underneath the car :)


1859 posts

Uber Geek

Subscriber

  # 1407345 15-Oct-2015 16:37
Send private message

When my VW alternator packed up, it was replaced and a 12 month warranty for part only and I was informed this at the time. All labour cost was to be mine if it did packed up within 12 months, which was fair sounding to me.  Depending on the car, an alternator can be tricky to get out and in again (i.e. radiators, hoses, belts, other things crammed in the way of access). 

Was there any small print on the invoice pointing out that warranty was for parts only?


14459 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted
Subscriber

  # 1407347 15-Oct-2015 16:41
One person supports this post
Send private message

MagicSquirrel:
Fred99: $250 sounds like a very steep labour cost to replace an alternator. I'd have expected perhaps 1 hour labour maximum, unless it's extraordinarily complicated to get access to it (possible but unlikely).


It actually is extraordinary complicated and requires removing bumper, one headlamp housing, power steering pump bolts etc. and wiggling alternator out from underneath the car :)



That is a lot of work, $250 does not sound unreasonable




Mike
Retired IT Manager. 
The views stated in my posts are my personal views and not that of any other organisation.

 

There is no planet B

 

 


3344 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted
Vocus

  # 1407349 15-Oct-2015 16:50
Send private message

MagicSquirrel:
Fred99: $250 sounds like a very steep labour cost to replace an alternator. I'd have expected perhaps 1 hour labour maximum, unless it's extraordinarily complicated to get access to it (possible but unlikely).


It actually is extraordinary complicated and requires removing bumper, one headlamp housing, power steering pump bolts etc. and wiggling alternator out from underneath the car :)



I thought mine was difficult and I only had to undo one engine mount and jack the engine a bit to get clearance



40 posts

Geek


  # 1407350 15-Oct-2015 16:50
Send private message

MikeB4: 
That is a lot of work, $250 does not sound unreasonable


Yep, I agree with that, and the amount in this case is irrelevant.
I'm interested in the legal side of charging labor fees.

 

Is repair considered as service or combination of goods & service?

 
 
 
 


4196 posts

Uber Geek


  # 1407351 15-Oct-2015 16:57
Send private message

MagicSquirrel:
MikeB4: 
That is a lot of work, $250 does not sound unreasonable


Yep, I agree with that, and the amount in this case is irrelevant.
I'm interested in the legal side of charging labor fees. Is repair considered as service or combination of goods & service?


A warranty can be "parts only" but I think it needs to be specified, best check the fine print...

2650 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted
Subscriber

  # 1407352 15-Oct-2015 16:57
Send private message

MagicSquirrel:
MikeB4: 
That is a lot of work, $250 does not sound unreasonable


Yep, I agree with that, and the amount in this case is irrelevant.
I'm interested in the legal side of charging labor fees. Is repair considered as service or combination of goods & service?


The labour cost is a consequential loss caused by the defective alternator, therefore is considered part of the supplied solution. The only exceptions would be if you free issued them the alternator to fit, or if the alternator was replaced under warranty and the original 12 month warranty had expired. Below has some good detail.

https://www.consumer.org.nz/articles/consumer-guarantees-act

3344 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted
Vocus

  # 1407354 15-Oct-2015 17:03
2 people support this post
Send private message

wellygary:
MagicSquirrel:
MikeB4: 
That is a lot of work, $250 does not sound unreasonable


Yep, I agree with that, and the amount in this case is irrelevant.
I'm interested in the legal side of charging labor fees. Is repair considered as service or combination of goods & service?


A warranty can be "parts only" but I think it needs to be specified, best check the fine print...


What's written in the warranty does not matter one jot.  One cannot contract out of one's obligations under the CGA.

8952 posts

Uber Geek


  # 1407365 15-Oct-2015 17:36
One person supports this post
Send private message

MagicSquirrel:
Fred99: $250 sounds like a very steep labour cost to replace an alternator. I'd have expected perhaps 1 hour labour maximum, unless it's extraordinarily complicated to get access to it (possible but unlikely).


It actually is extraordinary complicated and requires removing bumper, one headlamp housing, power steering pump bolts etc. and wiggling alternator out from underneath the car :)



What kind of car?
<for future reference as something to avoid>


4440 posts

Uber Geek


  # 1407390 15-Oct-2015 18:22
Send private message

Fred99: 
What kind of car?
<for future reference as something to avoid>



Given that every model of car in the world will have suffered a mechanical issue from time to time I'm guessing your cars-to-avoid list will be rather lengthy. 

Regardless, the dealer must pay for repairs... outrageous yet common what they are trying to do to you. 

You can either pay up and make life easy...

Or, argue and fight (and inevitably win as the dealer is in the wrong) which might end up in the disputes tribunal though.  








40 posts

Geek


  # 1407393 15-Oct-2015 18:29
One person supports this post
Send private message

Fred99:

What kind of car?
<for future reference as something to avoid>



Ford Ka. Not sure if that even classifies as 'a car' :)

4440 posts

Uber Geek


  # 1407395 15-Oct-2015 18:29
Send private message

Handle9:
The labour cost is a consequential loss caused by the defective alternator

The CGA does not really define the term 'repairs',  but most normal people would assume that repairs includes both parts and labour. 

The labour is not really a consequential loss. Consequential loss is the damage or loss done to other things due to the failure in question. eg, if i bought a new car tire which burst prematurely causing me to destroy a fence then the fence repairs would be considered consequential loss. 

4440 posts

Uber Geek


  # 1407396 15-Oct-2015 18:30
Send private message

MagicSquirrel:
Fred99:

What kind of car?
<for future reference as something to avoid>



Ford Ka. Not sure if that even classifies as 'a car' :)


Beats a smart car ha ha. 


 1 | 2 | 3
View this topic in a long page with up to 500 replies per page Create new topic



Twitter and LinkedIn »



Follow us to receive Twitter updates when new discussions are posted in our forums:



Follow us to receive Twitter updates when news items and blogs are posted in our frontpage:



Follow us to receive Twitter updates when tech item prices are listed in our price comparison site:





News »

Intel introduces cryogenic control chip to enable quantum computers
Posted 10-Dec-2019 21:32


Vodafone 5G service live in four cities
Posted 10-Dec-2019 08:30


Samsung Galaxy Fold now available in New Zealand
Posted 6-Dec-2019 00:01


NZ company oDocs awarded US$ 100,000 Dubai World Expo grant
Posted 5-Dec-2019 16:00


New Zealand Rugby Selects AWS-Powered Analytics for Deeper Game Insights
Posted 5-Dec-2019 11:33


IMAGR and Farro bring checkout-less supermarket shopping to New Zealand
Posted 5-Dec-2019 09:07


Wellington Airport becomes first 5G connected airport in the country
Posted 3-Dec-2019 08:42


MetService secures Al Jazeera as a new weather client
Posted 28-Nov-2019 09:40


NZ a top 10 connected nation with stage one of ultra-fast broadband roll-out completed
Posted 24-Nov-2019 14:15


Microsoft Translator understands te reo Māori
Posted 22-Nov-2019 08:46


Chorus to launch Hyperfibre service
Posted 18-Nov-2019 15:00


Microsoft launches first Experience Center worldwide for Asia Pacific in Singapore
Posted 13-Nov-2019 13:08


Disney+ comes to LG Smart TVs
Posted 13-Nov-2019 12:55


Spark launches new wireless broadband "Unplan Metro"
Posted 11-Nov-2019 08:19


Malwarebytes overhauls flagship product with new UI, faster engine and lighter footprint
Posted 6-Nov-2019 11:48



Geekzone Live »

Try automatic live updates from Geekzone directly in your browser, without refreshing the page, with Geekzone Live now.


Support Geekzone »

Our community of supporters help make Geekzone possible. Click the button below to join them.

Support Geezone on PressPatron



Are you subscribed to our RSS feed? You can download the latest headlines and summaries from our stories directly to your computer or smartphone by using a feed reader.

Alternatively, you can receive a daily email with Geekzone updates.