Xbox One S vs PS4

Forums › Gaming › Xbox One S vs PS4 - help

howdystranger

105 posts

Master Geek
+1 received by user: 14

Subscriber

Topic # 202028 14-Sep-2016 13:17

Does anyone have any advice on which of these consoles is better? I'm leaning towards a PS4 as I've heard it has better exclusives, but I am attracted to the backwards compatibly of the Xbox and some of the upcoming exclusives.

For context, I used to be a PC gamer but I no longer have room for my comp in my new tiny apartment...

1 | 2

1394 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 80

Reply # 1630231 14-Sep-2016 13:40

Completely depends on what games you like to play. And in the end, it does come down for exclusives. Personally, i am a huge fan of the Uncharted series so I went with PS4. But the XBONE has better media capabilities.

Lias

3440 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 1907

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

Reply # 1630241 14-Sep-2016 13:48

Just buy a mini gaming PC, plenty of gaming systems now come in ultra small / "Steam Machine" formats.

Information wants to be free. The Net interprets censorship as damage and routes around it.

richms

21530 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 4384

Trusted

Subscriber

Reply # 1630249 14-Sep-2016 13:59

Richard rich.ms

billgates

3832 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 234

Trusted

Reply # 1630263 14-Sep-2016 14:14

Xbox One S has better media capabilities, online multi player service and arguably the best controller. Games is a personal one. You pick which exclusives you like better.

Do whatever you want to do man.

reven

3390 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 677

Trusted

Reply # 1630280 14-Sep-2016 14:40

comes down to games really. PS4 has some pretty great exclusives. but they are few and far between. xbox one s has better media capabilities and backwards compatibility, plus the whole buy once use on both windows 10/xbox is cool, but limited to a very few games ATM.

personally I rate them this order

1. steam machine, big picture mode, controller == perfect console, more expensive than ps4/xbox, but games are waaaaaayyyyy cheaper (most consoles games come to steam)

2. xbox one s, finally no power brick, nice system, way better OS than PS4

3. ps4, terrible OS (IMO), but has some pretty great exclusives, the last of us is my personal favourite.

jfanning

344 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 45

Reply # 1630315 14-Sep-2016 15:50

reven:

comes down to games really. PS4 has some pretty great exclusives. but they are few and far between. xbox one s has better media capabilities and backwards compatibility, plus the whole buy once use on both windows 10/xbox is cool, but limited to a very few games ATM.

personally I rate them this order

1. steam machine, big picture mode, controller == perfect console, more expensive than ps4/xbox, but games are waaaaaayyyyy cheaper (most consoles games come to steam)

2. xbox one s, finally no power brick, nice system, way better OS than PS4

3. ps4, terrible OS (IMO), but has some pretty great exclusives, the last of us is my personal favourite.

Are you referring to the actual OS, or just the GUI?

richms

21530 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 4384

Trusted

Subscriber

Reply # 1630318 14-Sep-2016 15:53

xbox seems to take longer to update if you have not used it for a while and then want to play on it. Much longer downloads and more of them I find.

Richard rich.ms

reven

3390 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 677

Trusted

Reply # 1630320 14-Sep-2016 15:54

jfanning:

reven:

comes down to games really. PS4 has some pretty great exclusives. but they are few and far between. xbox one s has better media capabilities and backwards compatibility, plus the whole buy once use on both windows 10/xbox is cool, but limited to a very few games ATM.

personally I rate them this order

1. steam machine, big picture mode, controller == perfect console, more expensive than ps4/xbox, but games are waaaaaayyyyy cheaper (most consoles games come to steam)

2. xbox one s, finally no power brick, nice system, way better OS than PS4

3. ps4, terrible OS (IMO), but has some pretty great exclusives, the last of us is my personal favourite.

Are you referring to the actual OS, or just the GUI?

I guess mostly the UI for the OS. its not like the PS4 OS crashes constantly.

nzkiwiman

2074 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 165

Reply # 1630409 14-Sep-2016 17:48

I went Playstation (original) to Xbox 360 and have now just gone Xbox One S

Sometimes I wish I could have both PS4 and Xbox for the exclusives on both systems, but space and money is an issue

Lastman

190 posts

Master Geek
+1 received by user: 52

Reply # 1630433 14-Sep-2016 18:43

The 4K Ultra-HD Blu-ray on the Xbox One S at least rates a mention.

stocksp

402 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 165

Reply # 1630447 14-Sep-2016 19:12

I have both and much prefer the Xbox. It's OS is much more stable as noted above ( the PS4 is constantly crashing), and operates far better as an around media machine as well as games machine. We use it every day, whereas the PS4 might get turned on once a week.

Backwards compatibility is nice on Xbox, but what is really nice is the ability to Attach external hard drives ( I have 2 1 TB currently attached). It's true that you can upgrade the PS4 hard drive, but you can't attach externals.

There are a couple of exclusives that are good for PS4 - uncharted, singstar :) but really, the Xbox is the one to go for in my view ( and if you are buying one now I would go for the S which also has UHD bluray playback ( the PS4 and the PS4 pro don't)

stocksp

402 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 165

Reply # 1630449 14-Sep-2016 19:15

And the Xbox is being continuously upgraded with new capabilities, whereas the PS4 does not seem to be evolving much at all

toejam316

666 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 188

Reply # 1630456 14-Sep-2016 19:24

stocksp: And the Xbox is being continuously upgraded with new capabilities, whereas the PS4 does not seem to be evolving much at all

I'd say otherwise - they're both developing quite nicely, the PS4 4.0 update just added a much more responsive in game menu, and I believe HDR support is coming to ALL PS4s, whereas my Xbox One will never support HDR. Pick the one with the games that you want, and if you don't want it for games, buy an Intel NUC.

howdystranger

105 posts

Master Geek
+1 received by user: 14

Subscriber

Reply # 1630542 14-Sep-2016 22:21

Thanks all for your help. I went with an Xbox One S 2TB and hopefully I don't live to regret my decision :-)

travlockhart

19 posts

Geek
+1 received by user: 2

Reply # 1631119 15-Sep-2016 16:53

HDR is useless if you don't have HDR TV, but still surprising PS4 will be getting it at 1080p. But I highly doubt this is real HDR, iirc PS4 has hdmi 1.4 and as I understand this only supports wider color gamut which I suspect what they mean by bringing HDR on PS4.

But back on thread, like everyone else said it's all about the games. I personally could have both consoles but I prefer to use Xbox as I have most of my friends to play with on that platform. Also I stopped using PSN after the 2011 attack, they handled that poorly. Also want to point out PSN has planned outages, and you rarely get these on XBL.

1 | 2