Zigbee vs BLE temperature sensors for Home Assistant

Forums › Gadgets, robotics, home automation, electronics (including wearables) › Zigbee vs BLE temperature sensors for Home Assistant - which is most reliable?

timmmay

20900 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 5381

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#299210 21-Aug-2022 08:24

I'm adding Zigbee to my Raspberry Pi 4 Home Assistant install using the SONOFF Zigbee 3.0 USB Dongle Plus Gateway. I'm looking for temperature sensors, and I might need a range extender at some point. What have people found reliable?

The Sonoff SNZB-02 only gets 3.5 stars at Amazon and has a lot of recent bad reviews. The advantage of these is they come from Amazon where I'm getting other things, shipping is fast and reliable.
Tuya sensors are meant to be HA compatible, I've read they can be more hassle.
I read that Aquara sensors aren't standard Zigbee, but that may have been an older review.

I'm also interested if there's a decent Zigbee mains (NZ plug) or USB powered repeater, in case I decide to put a sensor in the greenhouse. I don't have smart light bulbs or similar and don't really want any either, I know they can act as repeaters.

Let's tag a few people who seem to be Zigbee users... @mdf @Chippo @davidcole @peejayw @phrozenpenguin @PANiCnz

Update: based on the feedback here I decided to go with Bluetooth Low Energy, with Xiaomi sensors and a USB long range BLE adapter with an external antenna. I'll report back once everything is set up.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5

129 posts

Master Geek
+1 received by user: 52

Trusted

#2957206 21-Aug-2022 09:26

I've never heard of the Aqara Temperature and Humidity Sensor not being standards compliant - but I do know that they are incredibly popular in the Home Assistant community.

I have 5 of them and they are very reliable day-to-day. I use them for both Temperature and Humidity, in my case with a Conbee II USB stick + Home Assistant. Most bought from Ali Express - but it's a particular bonus that my local PB Tech also stocks them.

They do tend to agree in temperature with the much more expensive and much less reliable Netatmo sensors I have as well.

Only complaint is that the replaceable CR2032 battery they use only lasts about a year. So make sure you stick them places you can reach.

I work for a global Data Protection Software company - But my opinions are my own.

timmmay

20900 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 5381

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#2957210 21-Aug-2022 09:39

Thanks Chippo, sounds good. Unfortunately there are none available at PBTech anywhere in NZ unfortunately, Au looks expensive to buy them, so they would probably have to come from AliExpress which has incredibly unreliable shipping.

mdf

3567 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 1524

Trusted

#2957219 21-Aug-2022 09:58

I've got Aqara sensors (all ebay sourced) and never had any issue with Home Assistant + Zigbee2MQTT. I do need to get around to proper data logging and graphing, which has been on the to do list for far too long, but that has nothing to do with the sensors. As Chippo said, battery lasts about a year but they're well designed so you can change the battery easily and trademe batteries are cheap as chips.

Zigbee terminology is weird. A zigbee range extender is a "router", and the bit controlling everything (what I think of as a router) is a "coordinator". In theory, most hard wired zigbee devices can be a router/range extender too (e.g., bulb, switch, smart plug). I've had limited success with this, so you would need to do your research on the specific device.

After an extended period of d!cking around, I finally did it properly and wired up a couple of CC2530 routers. I used a 5V --> 3.3V buck converter and run it off any old USB charger. Range and stability are superb. Took about half an hour (excluding shipping time) and cost next to nothing. But definitely in the project category rather than plug and play. There are various suppliers of pre-made open source routers, but I've never bought from any so buyer discretion is advised. See e.g. https://www.tubeszb.com. Full list: https://www.zigbee2mqtt.io/guide/adapters/#recommended

In general, the Zigbee2MQTT list of supported devices is a superb resource. Clearly a lot will be hard to source here but it gives you a pretty firm starting place for things that are known to play nicely with each other.

openmedia

3471 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 888

Trusted

#2957221 21-Aug-2022 10:09

I went down the BLE path for temp sensors and use the basic Xiaomi ones with a modded firmware.

These are regularly on offer.

Generally known online as OpenMedia, now working for Red Hat APAC as a Technology Evangelist and Portfolio Architect. Still playing with MythTV and digital media on the side.

TommySharp

135 posts

Master Geek
+1 received by user: 14

ID Verified

#2957226 21-Aug-2022 10:24

I have 12 of the xiaomi sensors for a few years now…. I find that there are some that keep going offline every now and then and need me to press the button on them to connect them up again. My 8 door sensors seem to be rock solid though!

I’ve bought some of the BLE ones with the small LCD screen to see if those are better.

timmmay

20900 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 5381

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#2957228 21-Aug-2022 10:38

Thanks all for the ideas, I will read them all and look at the links when I'm at home.

I figured the range of zigbee would be better than Bluetooth low energy. Places I would like to monitor the temperature of are through four or five walls inside the house, which is why I thought a zigbee router would be useful. Any thoughts on that?

Geekzone support

Support Geekzone with one-off or recurring donations Donate via PressPatron.

peejayw

1913 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 123

#2957235 21-Aug-2022 11:22

+1 for the Aqara sensors. I have three, all work fine in HA and closely correlate. I bought mine from Aliexpress and printed some stands from Thingiverse, there are lots of different types there.

I'm supposed to respect my elders, but it's getting harder and harder for me to find one now.

Klathman

302 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 78

#2957236 21-Aug-2022 11:37

Due to already having Hue lights I've found a totally different method. The Hue motion sensors have temperature sensors which HA can access. I don't know how accurate they are but they seem good enough for my purposes.

rscole86

5001 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 463

Moderator

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#2957242 21-Aug-2022 12:07

timmmay: Thanks all for the ideas, I will read them all and look at the links when I'm at home.

I figured the range of zigbee would be better than Bluetooth low energy. Places I would like to monitor the temperature of are through four or five walls inside the house, which is why I thought a zigbee router would be useful. Any thoughts on that?

I use an esp32 wifi/ble module as the hub, allowing my Xiaomi ble devices to connect via esp to home assistant. So long as you have wifi to your hubs, then you've got greater range for your ble devices.

Batwing

692 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 224

Trusted

Subscriber

#2957275 21-Aug-2022 14:15

Naked esp32 boards off cellphone chargers around the house really brings the place together.

timmmay

20900 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 5381

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#2957276 21-Aug-2022 14:26

I think I'll stick with Zigbee products I can buy off the shelf. I could probably work out the whole ESP32 thing but they have a low WAF.

Aqara sounds like a good option, unfortunately not available in NZ or on Amazon. I'll see if I can get some in a reasonable time.

Has anyone used the Sonoff SNZB-02? Main advantage there is they come from Amazon which is reliable and has good shipping. I would like like a display on the sensors, which the Sonoff don't do.

Apple TV

Stream your favourite shows now on Apple TV (affiliate link).

fearandloathing

539 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 208

ID Verified

Lifetime subscriber

#2957280 21-Aug-2022 15:07

timmmay:

Aqara sounds like a good option, unfortunately not available in NZ or on Amazon. I'll see if I can get some in a reasonable time

https://www.thetechnologystore.co.nz/products/aqara-temperature-and-humidity-sensor

eluSiveNZ

192 posts

Master Geek
+1 received by user: 42

#2957290 21-Aug-2022 15:40

timmmay:

I think I'll stick with Zigbee products I can buy off the shelf. I could probably work out the whole ESP32 thing but they have a low WAF.

Aqara sounds like a good option, unfortunately not available in NZ or on Amazon. I'll see if I can get some in a reasonable time.

Has anyone used the Sonoff SNZB-02? Main advantage there is they come from Amazon which is reliable and has good shipping. I would like like a display on the sensors, which the Sonoff don't do.

I have also been moving over to the Xiaomi BLE sensors with an ESP32. I have a couple of Aqara zigbee sensors spare now, so if you want to grab one let me know.

Another thing to note, the Aqara sensors also have a pressure sensor along with temp and humidity.

timmmay

20900 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 5381

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#2957296 21-Aug-2022 16:17

fearandloathing:
https://www.thetechnologystore.co.nz/products/aqara-temperature-and-humidity-sensor

Thanks, I meant at a decent price. You can get 2.5 from AliExpress for the price of one in NZ, but obviously takes a lot longer.

eluSiveNZ:

I have also been moving over to the Xiaomi BLE sensors with an ESP32. I have a couple of Aqara zigbee sensors spare now, so if you want to grab one let me know.

Another thing to note, the Aqara sensors also have a pressure sensor along with temp and humidity.

@eluSiveNZ Why have you moved to BLE / ESP32? If that's a more popular route maybe I should skip Zigbee. I have ethernet to parts of the house, but not the whole house, and I wouldn't be able to reach the greenhouse - which isn't a huge problem. If I go Zigbee I'll give you a yell - how old are they / what would you want for them? PM if you like.

What do you find the range of the BLE sensors is indoors, particularly through walls? Approx is fine.

eluSiveNZ

192 posts

Master Geek
+1 received by user: 42

#2957355 21-Aug-2022 17:24

timmmay:

@eluSiveNZ Why have you moved to BLE / ESP32? If that's a more popular route maybe I should skip Zigbee. I have ethernet to parts of the house, but not the whole house, and I wouldn't be able to reach the greenhouse - which isn't a huge problem. If I go Zigbee I'll give you a yell - how old are they / what would you want for them? PM if you like.

What do you find the range of the BLE sensors is indoors, particularly through walls? Approx is fine.

I still use some Zigbee ones, but have the BLE ones for the display. Just nice to have a display that is visible in lounge and bedrooms, plus they are $19 (sometimes cheaper on special) and readily available locally.

The furthest one I have is about 7-8meters from the ESP32 and goes through 2 walls.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5