![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
|
frankv: Put the kettle in a bell jar and evacuate. Not only is it quiet, but it boils faster too.Depends on how loud your vacuum pump is. And also if you desire a pot of room temperature boiling water.
Staying in Wellington. Check out my AirBnB in the Wellington CBD. https://www.airbnb.co.nz/h/wellycbd PM me and mention GZ to get a 15% discount and no AirBnB charges.
Handsomedan:andrewNZ:
If anyone suggests a Russell Hobbs Whisper Kettle, I'll have the geekzone secret service deal to you
We've had one of those for a few years now.
It was incredibly quiet for about three weeks.
Now, it's the loudest kettle we've ever owned, but it boils quickly, so we make do.
Hammerer:JamesL: I don't think there's such a thing as a quiet kettle tbh, I've been through many and any that claim to be quiet is BS.. Quiet vs a jet engine maybe?
Apparently, Consumer and other researchers are wasting their time measuring noise levels. I guess that you'll wonder how these academics got their paper, Why does heating water in a kettle produce sound?, accepted for publication with the fanciful idea that it is possible to have a kettle that can effectively boil water silently.
Quietness is relative to the listener so it is no surprise that people have different viewpoints. The quietness of a kettle is affected by the acoustic characteristics of the location, the water level, the water quality, and residues remaining in the kettle. So it is not entirely the fault of the kettle manufacturer when they are not as quiet as expected.
In summary, Aljishi & Tatarkiewicz found that the following stages in heating fresh tap water:
They discuss that the frequency of the sound waves is affected by the shape of the container and the amount of water. They also mention resonance which can occur in a fixed container (like in an organ pipe). It appears that the drop off in intensity of the sound when the kettle boils is due to water roiling and so the water level is not constant thereby disrupting resonance effects.
- silent convection
- nucleate boiling where most of the noise comes from the explosive creation and collapse of vapour bubbles
- nearly silent ~40C bubbles form from dissolved air
- noisy ~70C vapour bubbles nucleate on the heated bottom of the kettle and collapse
- noisier ~90C vapour bubbles coalesce from the heated surface to create larger bubbles that can rise to the top surface to explode
- noisiest ~90C large vapour bubbles form throughout most of the water
Two of the methods for reducing sound independent of the kettle used are:
[Edited to fix grammar and clarity]
- using deionised or distilled water moves nucleate bubble formation until just before 100C
- stirring the water (they used a Teflon rod) to reduce non-uniform heating and bubble formation is equivalent to using deionised/distilled water
khull:DS248: We have a Breville BKE590 "Quite Boil Technology" kettle (photo below).
Much quieter than a 'normal' electric kettle
Stainless steel.
This one exactly - it is so quiet it has a bell that goes ding when it is done boiling.
Reality is you just need to clean the kettle. All of them will become loud eventually because of hard water deposits. Invest in a $6 kettle cleaner or use vinegar (lots of it) first before you go out and find a new one
Hammerer:
Apparently, Consumer and other researchers are wasting their time measuring noise levels. I guess that you'll wonder how these academics got their paper, Why does heating water in a kettle produce sound?, accepted for publication with the fanciful idea that it is possible to have a kettle that can effectively boil water silently.
Quietness is relative to the listener so it is no surprise that people have different viewpoints. The quietness of a kettle is affected by the acoustic characteristics of the location, the water level, the water quality, and residues remaining in the kettle. So it is not entirely the fault of the kettle manufacturer when they are not as quiet as expected.
In summary, Aljishi & Tatarkiewicz found that the following stages in heating fresh tap water:
They discuss that the frequency of the sound waves is affected by the shape of the container and the amount of water. They also mention resonance which can occur in a fixed container (like in an organ pipe). It appears that the drop off in intensity of the sound when the kettle boils is due to water roiling and so the water level is not constant thereby disrupting resonance effects.
- silent convection
- nucleate boiling where most of the noise comes from the explosive creation and collapse of vapour bubbles
- nearly silent ~40C bubbles form from dissolved air
- noisy ~70C vapour bubbles nucleate on the heated bottom of the kettle and collapse
- noisier ~90C vapour bubbles coalesce from the heated surface to create larger bubbles that can rise to the top surface to explode
- noisiest ~90C large vapour bubbles form throughout most of the water
Two of the methods for reducing sound independent of the kettle used are:
[Edited to fix grammar and clarity]
- using deionised or distilled water moves nucleate bubble formation until just before 100C
- stirring the water (they used a Teflon rod) to reduce non-uniform heating and bubble formation is equivalent to using deionised/distilled water
mdf: ...
That must be the most awesomely comprehensive answer to a water boiling forum post ever.
Hammerer: [PS found mistake which should have said "noisiest ~90-100C large vapour bubbles form throughout most of the water"]
Keep calm, and carry on posting.
Referral Links: Sharesies - Backblaze -
Are you happy with what you get from Geekzone? If so, please consider supporting us by subscribing.
No matter where you go, there you are.
lchiu7:
It started off quiet but I have now had two fail on my and the third takes a long time to stop boiling once the correct temperature is reached.
Since the kitchen is open plan when the kettle is boiling the noise can be annoying over the TV.
If anyone suggests a Russell Hobbs Whisper Kettle, I'll have the geekzone secret service deal to you
Hammerer:mdf: ...
That must be the most awesomely comprehensive answer to a water boiling forum post ever.
That made me smile.Even if it were sarcastic, that would make me laugh.
![]()
Then it reminded me that one of my nicknames used to be "Technical". That's why I really enjoyed reading the technical paper and found it hard to leave out a couple of the best bits because they weren't really germane to the original question.
[PS found mistake which should have said "noisiest ~90-100C large vapour bubbles form throughout most of the water"]
|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |