David321:
Very well explained thank you, I understand you put extra money on you floating which makes perfect sense if you are that way inclined and if your savings is likely to sit idle at $50,000 that would certainly be the best thing to do in my (and i guess your) opinion.
My situation is similar, but the key detail which I believe could change everything is the fact I contribute to my savings on a regular basis, therefore its always (well mostly) growing, plus the offset balance is always coming down with repayments. Then obviously what you get almost instantly after the first repayment and savings contribution is a gap between the offset balance and total credit (savings), which is money sitting there not earning interest or offsetting interest.
Yes to be fair my savings are definitely more idle. I have an upcoming job change so prefer the certainty about costs etc. That's good that you are increasing savings. It really comes down to a goal I guess.
If you are saving for a particular goal that you will need it for, then it makes sense to keep it separate. When I bought the home, I wanted to get back to six months pay saved as quickly as possible, once I reached that, I started putting my "unspent" income towards my floating loan. I work in finance and get paid monthly so prefer to keep things simple nonetheless. I still track my kiwisaver and mortgage balance each month as I like to see what I owe coming down in real terms.
As I'm sure you're aware the mortgage balance drops depressingly slowly compared to the repayments. NB to be fair I've been attacking the floating loan more aggressively recentl, as I bought when the rates were low, so set my fixed repayments as much above the minimum as I could. But as the rates went up, I've had less of buffer between what I could afford and what the minimum repayment was. So the fixed are all set just above the minimum, and the surplus I now use towards the floating loan as it's dollar for dollar.