Help: New to the HTPC scene

Forums › Home Theatre (incl HTPC) › Help: New to the HTPC scene

Brendan

703 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 67

Trusted

Topic # 96523 30-Jan-2012 00:36

New to the HTPC scene.

What i would like to know (preferably without wading through too many threads) is:

1. What USB solutions are there in NZ for NZ Freeview (satellite) viewing/recording on a PC. (Is USB just a bad idea? Why?) URL's?

2. What software supports those (MythTV, MediaPortal, WMC, or others?)

3. Support for NAS, etc.

4. What should a noob look out for? Budget is a concern.

Obviously many here are doing that? But I am trying to get the best price/performance ratio and avoid any pitfalls/driver issues with some models.

As yet it is just a vague idea, but with the correct info and links it might become a good idea lol.

Thanks.

Brendan

703 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 67

Trusted

Reply # 575144 31-Jan-2012 01:28

So, no one here can name a good USB freeview decoder for windows ????????? Really?

timbosan

1484 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 147

Subscriber

Reply # 575153 31-Jan-2012 07:30

I have two USB tuners in my HTPC system, however they are DVB-T, not satellite. They work fine except every so often the system will 'loose' them. More specifically they appear with "No Signal" in Windows Media Centre, but after a reboot work fine.

I also have a PCI satellite tuner which has been 100% stable.

In regards to your other questions, I use Windows Media Centre and I have a Windows Home Server as my 'NAS'. These two work together to move recordings off the Media Centre and onto the server automatically, where they can be accessed by anyone on the network, but still appear under "Recorded TV"

I haven't used any other software but I know several others on geekzone have.

Noob 'gotchas'
- recording TV can take up a LOT of space.
- If you want to get Ausi satellite channels (now limited to SBS after Go, Gen and Nine disappeared) you will want a DVB-S2 card to receive the HD signal
- Windows is known for its plug and play approach, but is slightly more limited compared to the other options if you like to tweak
- Satellite WILL give you a full EPG, unlike DVB-T
- Satellite will NOT give you HD from NZ channels
- Make sure to use an HDMI cable from the PC to the TV, it saves having two or more cables

Do you have any specs or ideas on the hardware you will be using?

sbiddle

27420 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 6866

Moderator

Trusted

Biddle Corp

Lifetime subscriber

Reply # 575159 31-Jan-2012 08:26

Brendan: So, no one here can name a good USB freeview decoder for windows ????????? Really?

There is technically no such thing as a "USB Freeview decoder". In a DVB-T/DVB-S world the tuner card merely passes the DVB stream to the PC where the audio and video is decoded by the audio and video codecs on your PC.

As for USB tuners I've known plenty of people with issues, a PCI card or Ethernet tuner is a far better option.

reven

3409 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 691

Trusted

Reply # 575181 31-Jan-2012 09:42

a hauppauge novat is a good usb tuner. but you can get some cheap ones off trademe with dual tuner capabilities, i might go for those in your shoes.

how many tvs do you want to serve? bedroom + lounge? if so, i would recommend xbmc as a front end, for the record or mediaportal for backend/tv server if you want windows or tvheadend or mythtv for linux.

then i would buy a couple of raspberry pis for the front end (not for sale yet, but weeks away, and 35 pound each).

im planning on getting a couple raspberry pis and selling off my mac minis

timbosan

1484 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 147

Subscriber

Reply # 575182 31-Jan-2012 09:44

I forgot to ask in my reply, why USB? Is it a Mac Mini or similar? Otherwise can you not fit in half-height PCI or PCIe cards?

Brendan

703 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 67

Trusted

Reply # 575325 31-Jan-2012 14:16

timbosan: I have two USB tuners in my HTPC system, however they are DVB-T, not satellite. They work fine except every so often the system will 'loose' them. More specifically they appear with "No Signal" in Windows Media Centre, but after a reboot work fine.

I also have a PCI satellite tuner which has been 100% stable.

Interesting - possibly the USB tuners are problematic... Might have to have a re-think.

In regards to your other questions, I use Windows Media Centre and I have a Windows Home Server as my 'NAS'. These two work together to move recordings off the Media Centre and onto the server automatically, where they can be accessed by anyone on the network, but still appear under "Recorded TV"

Noted, thanks.

I haven't used any other software but I know several others on geekzone have.

Noob 'gotchas'
- recording TV can take up a LOT of space.
- If you want to get Ausi satellite channels (now limited to SBS after Go, Gen and Nine disappeared) you will want a DVB-S2 card to receive the HD signal
- Windows is known for its plug and play approach, but is slightly more limited compared to the other options if you like to tweak

I do... But more importantly I want it to work lol.

- Satellite WILL give you a full EPG, unlike DVB-T

No dvb-t here in Oamaru anyway AFAIK.

- Satellite will NOT give you HD from NZ channels
- Make sure to use an HDMI cable from the PC to the TV, it saves having two or more cables

Thanks.

Do you have any specs or ideas on the hardware you will be using?

Still in the planning stage, but i had thought of using a spare laptop as a media center maybe running XBMC first, then add recording with mediaportal or ???... Good idea or bad?

Am i just asking for lots of trouble and should I go to something with PCI slots? Budget is a concern...

Brendan

703 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 67

Trusted

Reply # 575326 31-Jan-2012 14:16

sbiddle:
Brendan: So, no one here can name a good USB freeview decoder for windows ????????? Really?

There is technically no such thing as a "USB Freeview decoder". In a DVB-T/DVB-S world the tuner card merely passes the DVB stream to the PC where the audio and video is decoded by the audio and video codecs on your PC.

As for USB tuners I've known plenty of people with issues, a PCI card or Ethernet tuner is a far better option.

Thanks. Starting to look that way for me too.

Brendan

703 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 67

Trusted

Reply # 575331 31-Jan-2012 14:22

reven: a hauppauge novat is a good usb tuner. but you can get some cheap ones off trademe with dual tuner capabilities, i might go for those in your shoes.

Thanks. What should I be looking for exactly as far as compatibility with NZ Freeview goes? I can only get the satellite freeview here...

how many tvs do you want to serve? bedroom + lounge? if so, i would recommend xbmc as a front end, for the record or mediaportal for backend/tv server if you want windows or tvheadend or mythtv for linux.

Initially, just one TV.

So, I can have a server doing all the grunt work (inc NAS I guess? for PC backups etc) recording, hosting the tuners etc. hidden away somewhere, and then just have a weak front end computer running xbmc, that runs nice and quiet in the lounge?

then i would buy a couple of raspberry pis for the front end (not for sale yet, but weeks away, and 35 pound each).

im planning on getting a couple raspberry pis and selling off my mac minis

I was watching that too...

Thanks.

Brendan

703 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 67

Trusted

Reply # 575334 31-Jan-2012 14:22

timbosan: I forgot to ask in my reply, why USB? Is it a Mac Mini or similar? Otherwise can you not fit in half-height PCI or PCIe cards?

I had the idea of using a laptop.

reven

3409 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 691

Trusted

Reply # 575755 1-Feb-2012 10:42

if you only can receive DVB-S, i would suggest a PCIe card. the USB DVB-S tuners are few and far between and I couldnt find any that were dual or more tuners.

I would buy a Tevii PCIe from trademe or a TBS from buydvb.net (I got a TBS6984, quad tuner PCIe from there) and have used it with: For The Record (Windows), MediaPortal (Windows), NextPVR(Windows), and currently using it with Tvheadend (linux) (i was getting BSOD with my setup in windows so switched to linux to test that out (only did that last weekend)).

for the record is quite nice, nice interface, love the fact its a service and can run on a server type setup and has support for XBMC PVR frontend and a very good mediaportal frontend (hard to tell the difference from the mediaportal standard frontend).

Brendan

703 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 67

Trusted

Reply # 576135 2-Feb-2012 00:09

reven: if you only can receive DVB-S, i would suggest a PCIe card. the USB DVB-S tuners are few and far between and I couldnt find any that were dual or more tuners.

I would buy a Tevii PCIe from trademe or a TBS from buydvb.net (I got a TBS6984, quad tuner PCIe from there) and have used it with: For The Record (Windows), MediaPortal (Windows), NextPVR(Windows), and currently using it with Tvheadend (linux) (i was getting BSOD with my setup in windows so switched to linux to test that out (only did that last weekend)).

for the record is quite nice, nice interface, love the fact its a service and can run on a server type setup and has support for XBMC PVR frontend and a very good mediaportal frontend (hard to tell the difference from the mediaportal standard frontend).

Thanks, this is the sort of information I was hoping to get!

Thanks again.

Brendan

703 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 67

Trusted

Reply # 576140 2-Feb-2012 01:21

reven: if you only can receive DVB-S, i would suggest a PCIe card. the USB DVB-S tuners are few and far between and I couldnt find any that were dual or more tuners.

I would buy a Tevii PCIe from trademe or a TBS from buydvb.net (I got a TBS6984, quad tuner PCIe from there) and have used it with: For The Record (Windows), MediaPortal (Windows), NextPVR(Windows), and currently using it with Tvheadend (linux) (i was getting BSOD with my setup in windows so switched to linux to test that out (only did that last weekend)).

for the record is quite nice, nice interface, love the fact its a service and can run on a server type setup and has support for XBMC PVR frontend and a very good mediaportal frontend (hard to tell the difference from the mediaportal standard frontend).

Do you happen to know if the TeVii cards are compatible with mediaportal, myth, etc?

Thanks.

kiwijunglist

2738 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 98

Reply # 576143 2-Feb-2012 01:46

DVB-T (Terrestial freeview/TV Antenna) requires a faster/newer PC than DVB-S (Satellitefreeview/ Satellite Dish). Make sure your PC is fast enough if you require DVB-T.

HTPC: Intel i3-2100 / 12GB RAM / AMD HD7750 / 480 GB SSD / 58TB Storage / MediaPortal / MadVR / Win10
AVR: Pioneer Elite SC-LX87 220W 9.2 Ch AVR
Speakers: Wharfedale Jade 7 Fronts / Jade 2c Center / Jade 5 Rears
Subs: iNuke 3000dsp 3000W proamp with 4x 15" JBL Sealed Subs
Display: Samsung 60" UA60H6400 LCD TV
Accessories: Gefen HDMI Detective with splitter

reven

3409 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 691

Trusted

Reply # 576159 2-Feb-2012 07:37

Brendan:
reven: if you only can receive DVB-S, i would suggest a PCIe card. the USB DVB-S tuners are few and far between and I couldnt find any that were dual or more tuners.

I would buy a Tevii PCIe from trademe or a TBS from buydvb.net (I got a TBS6984, quad tuner PCIe from there) and have used it with: For The Record (Windows), MediaPortal (Windows), NextPVR(Windows), and currently using it with Tvheadend (linux) (i was getting BSOD with my setup in windows so switched to linux to test that out (only did that last weekend)).

for the record is quite nice, nice interface, love the fact its a service and can run on a server type setup and has support for XBMC PVR frontend and a very good mediaportal frontend (hard to tell the difference from the mediaportal standard frontend).

Do you happen to know if the TeVii cards are compatible with mediaportal, myth, etc?

Thanks.

yeah the Tevii cards are well supported. Theres not a lot of brands for DVB-S type cards, compared to DVB-T, the hauppauge ones seem small on features and i dont think they have a multi tuner DVB-S card (they have a multi dvb-t, dvb-s, analog card but thats about it).

also make sure you get a DVB-S2 card, as all the 1080 stuff is delivered over DVB-S2, you'll need a card reader and sky subscription to get that content atm, but that could change in the future so you dont want to have to replace the card to get HD stuff.

if you are going the XBMC route for a frontend, i would suggest using linux and tvheadend, that is the "offically" supported backend and what the pvr devs test against. but if you're not comfortable with linux, i would go for fortherecord as its pretty easy to setup and works well (i had lots of issues with mediaportal), for the record also has a mediaportal frontend.