GCSB

Forums › Off topic › GCSB

Linuxluver

5828 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

Subscriber

#109907 28-Sep-2012 17:39

If the GCSB was working under a misunderstanding from late 2009 until a week or two ago about who they could legally spy on, shouldn't PM John Key be investigating who else may have been illegally spied on?

I'd certainly like to know what crimes may have been committed in the two year period during which they didn't know what a NZ resident was.

The PM was just on the radio saying it was a brain fade by one person.

For two years? In all cases?

Reeeeally?

_____________________________________________________________________

I've been on Geekzone over 16 years..... Time flies....

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6

2802 posts

Uber Geek

#693063 28-Sep-2012 17:50

TorrentFreak have been following it closely if you want a view unpolluted by the NZ media.

I suspect that they knew full well he was a resident and thought they could get away with it. I also suspect that John Key will "forget" to do much further investigating.

http://torrentfreak.com/new-zealand-prime-minister-apologizes-to-kim-dotcom-120927/

@KnightNZ

chevrolux

4962 posts

Uber Geek
Inactive user

#693092 28-Sep-2012 18:48

I think it is bizarre they aren't allowed to spy on NZ residents. There are plenty of people on NZ that are far far more dangerous than Mr.com and they aren't allowed to keep tabs on them. Ridiculous.

...
And know people will say we shouldn't have to 'live in fear' that people could be spying on us it but it truly is a case of be good and it wont happen.

mattRSK

822 posts

Ultimate Geek

Trusted

#693099 28-Sep-2012 18:55

The guy is a criminal anyway, no idea how he got residency in the first place. Now he has brought all this baggage with him. Public seems to love him though.

old3eyes

9120 posts

Uber Geek

Subscriber

#693100 28-Sep-2012 18:58

Linuxluver: If the GCSB was working under a misunderstanding from late 2009 until a week or two ago about who they could legally spy on, shouldn't PM John Key be investigating who else may have been illegally spied on?

I'd certainly like to know what crimes may have been committed in the two year period during which they didn't know what a NZ resident was.

The PM was just on the radio saying it was a brain fade by one person.

For two years? In all cases?

Reeeeally?

Are you now worried that they spied on you??

Regards,

Old3eyes

nzkc

1572 posts

Uber Geek

#693113 28-Sep-2012 19:27

Its pretty simple to me. I'm not allowed to use ignorance as an excuse for breaking the law. Neither should a government organisation. Someone should be held to account for this.

freitasm

BDFL - Memuneh
79288 posts

Uber Geek

Administrator

ID Verified

Trusted

Geekzone

Lifetime subscriber

#693114 28-Sep-2012 19:32

chevrolux: I think it is bizarre they aren't allowed to spy on NZ residents. There are plenty of people on NZ that are far far more dangerous than Mr.com and they aren't allowed to keep tabs on them. Ridiculous.

It's not bizarre. Is a safeguard that guarantees that a rogue administration will not come up with "bad intel" on good citizens that dissent.

Remember, not all governments are good. A government is not the same as country. Dissent is not bad.

chevrolux: And know people will say we shouldn't have to 'live in fear' that people could be spying on us it but it truly is a case of be good and it wont happen.

This argument is so wrong. People should always be vigilant and do not allow government to have more power than needed - and power to covertly monitor its citizens is something that should be monitored by independent entities, to avoid exactly what I said before - rogue governments that decide by themselves no longer to follow the will of the people to keep their own interests above all.

Brendan

716 posts

Ultimate Geek

Trusted

#693226 29-Sep-2012 00:28

Linuxluver: If the GCSB was working under a misunderstanding from late 2009 until a week or two ago about who they could legally spy on, shouldn't PM John Key be investigating who else may have been illegally spied on?

I'd certainly like to know what crimes may have been committed in the two year period during which they didn't know what a NZ resident was.

The PM was just on the radio saying it was a brain fade by one person.

For two years? In all cases?

Reeeeally?

Exactly. I think that it goes deeper than many realize though.

This government is shaping up to be one of the most callous, corrupt governments New Zealand has ever known. This GCSB is simply the last in a long list of shonky dealings or callous attitudes. Off the top of my head:

Passing a Copyright law change at mid night as part of the amendments for helping Christchurch, after a previous attempt was protested by the voters and dropped. Later it was revealed that the US had paid several hundred thousand dollars to get it en-acted.
Mining of environmentally protected land, a policy hidden during the election and revealed only afterward.
Nasty 'private' comments between Shonky JohnKey and Dirty Bird Banks (tea pot tapes), showing their uncensored true feelings about normal people.
The head of a long-voted for system set up to provide for the poor and vulnerable publicly declaring she 'doesn't need to read' any statistics about child poverty.
NZ Government agencies are increasingly attempting to exempt themselves from the Official Information Act - e.g. keeping what they do secret from the voter.
Grand claims from National - quietly backpedaled and watered down when the media spotlight - and the voters - attention is elsewhere. (e.g. jobs, childcare demands on beneficiaries, etc).
Asset sales policy that has been universally panned - even buy Governments own Treasury Dept - yet, curiously, is still being rammed through... It's almost like John Key is got a personal stake in it....
The Megadownload debacle. Really, where do I start? A corrupt foreign government is told by one of it's owners to 'make an example of' a competitor, and so talks to a few of it's lapdogs in NZ. What then results is a comedy of inept key-stone cops capers, forgetful politicians, missing evidence, cowboy tactics, illegal spying and influence pedaling. I do not know if I should laugh at the incompetence and be thankful, or cry that they cannot even run a good conspiracy let alone a country!
And finally (although I am certain I have missed many other good examples): the total, total inability to actually FIX anything significant! Did they think we wouldn't notice? For all the big claims - nothing is actually better, and not ever likely to BE better. WTF? Is it the 1990's again???

Quic Broadband

Move to New Zealand's best fibre broadband service (affiliate link). Free setup code: R587125ERQ6VE. Note that to use Quic Broadband you must be comfortable with configuring your own router.

Jarno

270 posts

Ultimate Geek

#693230 29-Sep-2012 00:47

chevrolux: I think it is bizarre they aren't allowed to spy on NZ residents.

The GCSB is not allowed to spy on NZ residents because that is the job of the SIS. So don't worry, everyone can be legitimately spied on.

John2010

532 posts

Ultimate Geek

#693280 29-Sep-2012 08:23

Linuxluver: If the GCSB was working under a misunderstanding from late 2009 until a week or two ago about who they could legally spy on, shouldn't PM John Key be investigating who else may have been illegally spied on?

Probably quite a lot fewer than you yourself are hoping is the case, if only because the 2009 Act which has apparantly caused the confusion (it resulting in the demise of permits authorising stays and changing the use of the use of the term "visa" to describe the conditions of a permission to stay) did not come into effect until late 2010 (29 November) not "late 2009" as you have claimed.

John2010

532 posts

Ultimate Geek

#693287 29-Sep-2012 08:30

Jarno:
chevrolux: I think it is bizarre they aren't allowed to spy on NZ residents.

The GCSB is not allowed to spy on NZ residents because that is the job of the SIS. So don't worry, everyone can be legitimately spied on.

It would be my hope that they are keeping a watch of some sort on Brendan as he sounds like an extremely angry man beyond rational thought

D1023319

524 posts

Ultimate Geek

ID Verified

#693345 29-Sep-2012 11:09

freitasm:
chevrolux: I think it is bizarre they aren't allowed to spy on NZ residents. There are plenty of people on NZ that are far far more dangerous than Mr.com and they aren't allowed to keep tabs on them. Ridiculous.

It's not bizarre. Is a safeguard that guarantees that a rogue administration will not come up with "bad intel" on good citizens that dissent.

Remember, not all governments are good. A government is not the same as country. Dissent is not bad.

chevrolux: And know people will say we shouldn't have to 'live in fear' that people could be spying on us it but it truly is a case of be good and it wont happen.

This argument is so wrong. People should always be vigilant and do not allow government to have more power than needed - and power to covertly monitor its citizens is something that should be monitored by independent entities, to avoid exactly what I said before - rogue governments that decide by themselves no longer to follow the will of the people to keep their own interests above all.

mckenndk

911 posts

Ultimate Geek

#693363 29-Sep-2012 11:44

Brendan:
Linuxluver: If the GCSB was working under a misunderstanding from late 2009 until a week or two ago about who they could legally spy on, shouldn't PM John Key be investigating who else may have been illegally spied on?

I'd certainly like to know what crimes may have been committed in the two year period during which they didn't know what a NZ resident was.

The PM was just on the radio saying it was a brain fade by one person.

For two years? In all cases?

Reeeeally?

Exactly. I think that it goes deeper than many realize though.

This government is shaping up to be one of the most callous, corrupt governments New Zealand has ever known. This GCSB is simply the last in a long list of shonky dealings or callous attitudes. Off the top of my head:

Passing a Copyright law change at mid night as part of the amendments for helping Christchurch, after a previous attempt was protested by the voters and dropped. Later it was revealed that the US had paid several hundred thousand dollars to get it en-acted.
Mining of environmentally protected land, a policy hidden during the election and revealed only afterward.
Nasty 'private' comments between Shonky JohnKey and Dirty Bird Banks (tea pot tapes), showing their uncensored true feelings about normal people.
The head of a long-voted for system set up to provide for the poor and vulnerable publicly declaring she 'doesn't need to read' any statistics about child poverty.
NZ Government agencies are increasingly attempting to exempt themselves from the Official Information Act - e.g. keeping what they do secret from the voter.
Grand claims from National - quietly backpedaled and watered down when the media spotlight - and the voters - attention is elsewhere. (e.g. jobs, childcare demands on beneficiaries, etc).
Asset sales policy that has been universally panned - even buy Governments own Treasury Dept - yet, curiously, is still being rammed through... It's almost like John Key is got a personal stake in it....
The Megadownload debacle. Really, where do I start? A corrupt foreign government is told by one of it's owners to 'make an example of' a competitor, and so talks to a few of it's lapdogs in NZ. What then results is a comedy of inept key-stone cops capers, forgetful politicians, missing evidence, cowboy tactics, illegal spying and influence pedaling. I do not know if I should laugh at the incompetence and be thankful, or cry that they cannot even run a good conspiracy let alone a country!
And finally (although I am certain I have missed many other good examples): the total, total inability to actually FIX anything significant! Did they think we wouldn't notice? For all the big claims - nothing is actually better, and not ever likely to BE better. WTF? Is it the 1990's again???

Not to worry it will be forgotten about in a few weeks especially by the National Voters.

Dion

Kyanar

4089 posts

Uber Geek

ID Verified

Trusted

#693430 29-Sep-2012 18:02

Jarno:
chevrolux: I think it is bizarre they aren't allowed to spy on NZ residents.

The GCSB is not allowed to spy on NZ residents because that is the job of the SIS. So don't worry, everyone can be legitimately spied on.

The SIS is legally prohibited from intercepting communications to or from citizens or permanent residents. A lawful intercept of a citizen or resident can only be performed by the Police, with a warrant.

networkn

Networkn
32351 posts

Uber Geek

ID Verified

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#693439 29-Sep-2012 18:27

John2010:
Jarno:
chevrolux: I think it is bizarre they aren't allowed to spy on NZ residents.

The GCSB is not allowed to spy on NZ residents because that is the job of the SIS. So don't worry, everyone can be legitimately spied on.

It would be my hope that they are keeping a watch of some sort on Brendan as he sounds like an extremely angry man beyond rational thought .

This gave me my best LOL of the weekend thanks.

I would imagine plenty of investigating will be held into whom else was spied on, and someone will be held accountable.

gzt

17134 posts

Uber Geek

Lifetime subscriber

#693457 29-Sep-2012 19:03

Kyanar:The SIS is legally prohibited from intercepting communications to or from citizens or permanent residents. A lawful intercept of a citizen or resident can only be performed by the Police, with a warrant.

Wrong.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6