Geekzone: technology news, blogs, forums
Welcome Guest.
You haven't logged in yet. If you don't have an account you can register now.


272 posts

Ultimate Geek

#14602 11-Jul-2007 17:11
Send private message

A Wellington company has been ordered to pay $9000 compensation to a female employee it fired after she forwarded an email, from her father, containing pictures of naked people.


The Employment Relations Authority (ERA) ruled Jessica Wood was unjustifiably dismissed, despite her employer, electricity and water metering business Arthur D Riley & Co Ltd (ADR), having twice previously warned her about similar behaviour.

The authority was told that when she started work, the administrative assistant was given a copy of the policies and house rules, saying dismissal was likely if she breached the company's internet or email policy.

The policy stated employees were not to "access, download, save, request, transmit, store or purposely view sexual, pornographic, obscene, racist, profane or other offensive or inappropriate material".

The company retained the right to decide what was "offensive" or "inappropriate".

In December 2005, Ms Wood was given her first warning for her high numbers of forwards, joke emails and the questionable material she was sending using company computers.

Her professionalism in the workplace was also mentioned.

Though she remembered some of the circumstances at the time, Ms Wood said she could not remember the warning itself being given. She denied signing a written version of the warning, saying the copy brought before the authority could be fake.

In August 2006, Ms Wood was given another warning, also recorded in writing and signed by her, saying she had again breached the company policy with the amount of internet surfing and forwards she was sending. She was also cautioned about the high number of personal phone calls she was making.

On August 28, Ms Wood received an email from her father, a Wellington City Council employee, on the subject of "Eleven Most hot People!!!!!!!" (sic)

The email contained images of barely clothed or naked people, some obese, others with female heads edited on to the body of male bodybuilders.

"The images were clearly designed to shock and ridicule, as evidenced by the subject title and the phrase employed by Ms Wood when she forwarded it,. . . namely 'ewww'," Denis Asher, the ERA member ruling on the case, said.

She sent this email to her workmates and friends.

About two weeks later, on September 14, she was invited to a disciplinary meeting for "downloading objectionable/pornographic material or offensive material" and personal use of company email and internet.

The next day, company representatives, including general manager Garth Mickell, met with Ms Wood.

According to notes taken by the company at the time and Mr Mickell's recollection, the general manager went through each image and told her why he found it "objectionable/pornographic or offensive".

Ms Wood, however, denied she was shown the pictures.

On September 18, the company met with Ms Wood again. She gave no comment except to offer an apology.

The company then fired her.

Mr Asher said the company had "a significantly flawed and less than consistent approach to its email policy".

He also deemed the pictures were not as objectionable as Mr Mickell made them out to be and that his views were "unsustainable".

"Something more concrete is required than Mr Mickell and his colleagues' personal views," Mr Asher said.

As the other employees of the company who had received Ms Wood's email had not been disciplined, the company was not being fair, he ruled.

Also, the email had been sent to her by her father from his workplace (Wellington City Council), and computer filtering systems at both workplaces had not caught it.

Ms Wood wanted $12,000 for loss of wages and humiliation, but since she didn't adhere to the "broadly sensible guidelines" given to her, her payout was cut by 25 per cent.

Wellington City Council spokesman Richard Maclean said the woman's father had been reminded of the council's code of conduct around internet and email use, though no further action had been taken.

"On a scale of one to 10 (of obscenity), it was deemed this was not at the high end," he said.

The council was aware people circulated "joke" emails and had no plans to tighten up on personal use of its bandwidth by employees, he said.


Ok, sure people get sent junk mail but exactly how does one discipline someone for recieving an email? I think this lady deserves squat. She clearly violated her companies computer usage policy, which from the brief excert looks fairly standard, and yet manages to get a payout!?

Create new topic
Affiliate link

Affiliate link: Trade NZ and US shares and funds with Sharesies.
5 posts

Wannabe Geek

  #77949 13-Jul-2007 01:14
Send private message

Interesting story.


310 posts

Ultimate Geek


#77959 13-Jul-2007 09:15
Send private message

Would she have been sacked if she was contributing to Geekzone forums??!?



Now based in Perth WA.

BDFL - Memuneh
73991 posts

Uber Geek

ID Verified
Lifetime subscriber

#77960 13-Jul-2007 09:20
Send private message

Possible, if she was disclosing sensitive proprietary information.

We know it happened before - not sacking, but warnings. That's why we ask people to make sure when they post here there is no NDA or commercially sensitive information in their posts.

Are you happy with Geekzone? Consider subscribing or making a donation.




freitasm on Keybase | My technology disclosure 


These links are referral codes: Sharesies | Mighty Ape | Norton 360 | Lenovo laptops | GoodsyncGeekzone Blockchain Project

4556 posts

Uber Geek

  #77963 13-Jul-2007 09:48
Send private message

"Her professionalism in the workplace was also mentioned."

That was probably the real reason for seizing on a trumped up charge of "downloading objectionable/pornographic material or offensive material". She seems to have been there over a year with office management not showing much professionalism either.

29 posts


  #77993 13-Jul-2007 14:44
Send private message

People forget others will take offence. The key points to remember are

a. Keep personal stuff to a minimum if possible none at all

b. Somebody will be offended by something, this includes chain letters, religion, photos, jokes, inspirationals EVERYTHING. Unless you know they want them and they ask you for them - dont.

c. Unless there is a work related reason, use your own internet account to surf.

It is important to remember that she forwarded an email deemed objectionable. It is not because she received it, she was terminated because she forwarded it after repeated warnings over the same issue. Unfortunately the company did not follow the correct protocol, even though they quite rightly fired her.

If someone sent me an email such as the one described I would consider making a formal complaint if they were a work colleague.

Create new topic

News and reviews »

D-Link G415 4G Smart Router Review
Posted 27-Jun-2022 17:24

New Zealand Video Game Sales Reaches $540 Million
Posted 26-Jun-2022 14:49

Github Copilot Generally Available to All Developers
Posted 26-Jun-2022 14:37

Logitech G Introduces the New Astro A10 Headset
Posted 26-Jun-2022 14:20

Fitbit introduces Sleep Profiles
Posted 26-Jun-2022 14:11

Synology Introduces FlashStation FS3410
Posted 26-Jun-2022 14:04

Intel Arc A380 Graphics First Available in China
Posted 15-Jun-2022 17:08

JBL Introduces PartyBox Encore Essential Speaker
Posted 15-Jun-2022 17:05

New TVNZ+ streaming brand launches
Posted 13-Jun-2022 08:35

Chromecast With Google TV Review
Posted 10-Jun-2022 17:10

Xbox Gaming on Your Samsung Smart TV No Console Required
Posted 10-Jun-2022 00:01

Xbox Cloud Gaming Now Available in New Zealand
Posted 10-Jun-2022 00:01

HP Envy Inspire 7900e Review
Posted 9-Jun-2022 20:31

Philips Hue Starter Kit Review
Posted 4-Jun-2022 11:10

Sony Expands Its Wireless Speaker X-series Range
Posted 4-Jun-2022 10:25

Geekzone Live »

Try automatic live updates from Geekzone directly in your browser, without refreshing the page, with Geekzone Live now.

Are you subscribed to our RSS feed? You can download the latest headlines and summaries from our stories directly to your computer or smartphone by using a feed reader.