Geekzone: technology news, blogs, forums
Guest
Welcome Guest.
You haven't logged in yet. If you don't have an account you can register now.


godber

70 posts

Master Geek

ID Verified
Trusted
Lifetime subscriber

#290611 23-Nov-2021 07:05
Send private message

Can you get the Chorus NOA quote from multiple ISPs?

 

The margins (if any) that ISPs add may be different so the 'Chorus quote' received from different ISP may vary.

 

Happy to pay the ISP a fee for getting the quote as I there is work involved for the ISP but just want to shop around.

 

 

 

Many Thanks

 

 





 

Godfrey
Auckland/Coroglen, New Zealand
Quic Broadband - 4G Hyperfibre

 

Referral Link:
Quic (use R71004E9PVBJ on checkout for free setup)


Filter this topic showing only the reply marked as answer Create new topic
sbiddle
30853 posts

Uber Geek

Retired Mod
Trusted
Biddle Corp
Lifetime subscriber

  #2817402 23-Nov-2021 07:17
Send private message

Nothing stopping you but if your issue is with the fee why would you want to be paying it multiple times? All that'll happen is that Chorus do the same very same behind the scenes work multiple times.

 

 

 

 




godber

70 posts

Master Geek

ID Verified
Trusted
Lifetime subscriber

  #2817417 23-Nov-2021 08:03
Send private message

sbiddle:

 

Nothing stopping you but if your issue is with the fee why would you want to be paying it multiple times? All that'll happen is that Chorus do the same very same behind the scenes work multiple times.

 

 

I suspect the ISP I have chosen has added a significant dollar margin, based on a quote for software we are looking to buy for work.  I know the RRP and the price quoted is above RRP.  I also know from the distributor they are getting a margin off RRP.

 

A reasonable fee for a quote will be less than the margin I suspect.  It is unlikely Chorus will do the design again (the actual design has been done, so not a desktop estimate), surely they will just give the ISP the price.

 

In dollar terms if the quote from Chorus is $15k plus GST but the ISP adds 25% then it becomes $18750 plus GST.  So if the margin added by another ISPs is zero or less than 25% then the saving is significant (up to $3750 plus GST).

 

I have filled in the form at https://fullflavour.nz/rural-broadband/rural-fibre and I know from other people here they charge a $100 fee which seems reasonable.

 

I was originally going to get the quote from @myfullflavour I messaged him via geekzone but it was in lockdown and he may not have seen the message so did not receive a reply.  I was not aware at the time of the form fullflavour have otherwise I would have filled it in.

 

 

 

 





 

Godfrey
Auckland/Coroglen, New Zealand
Quic Broadband - 4G Hyperfibre

 

Referral Link:
Quic (use R71004E9PVBJ on checkout for free setup)


atomeara
324 posts

Ultimate Geek


  #2818093 23-Nov-2021 22:06
Send private message

The desktop estimate pricing can vary hugely from the formal quote.

 

 

 

I have had them 1/4 and 4x in price from the estimate.

 

 

 

I had one back from Napier for 450k recently and my cheapest has been $600 in Whangarei.




Wheelbarrow01
1723 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted
Chorus

  #2818114 23-Nov-2021 23:17
Send private message

It's not really feasible to get quotes from multiple RSPs for one simple reason - each RSP has to actually place an order to receive the firm quote from Chorus. This means you'd have to get RSP A to place an order, wait for the quote to come through, then instruct RSP A to decline the quote and cancel the order, before you can contact RSP B and ask them to place another order to receive the firm quote again - before comparing the two. And to be fair they could both have added a differing margin so you'd still not be 100% sure what the base price from Chorus is. Time consuming and frustrating for all really.

 

You are far better just to contact a few RSPs and ask them straight up if they add a margin on NOA orders, and then go with whichever one answers in the negative.

 

There are a few that I can think of who don't add a margin, but it's not my place to divulge that info given my position as 1) it's potentially commercially sensitive to those RSPs, and 2) it wouldn't be fair unless I was to state the policy of every RSP that offers NOA - and that sounds like a lot of work to collate....

 

I agree with @atomeara - sometimes the initial estimate can differ significantly from the firm quote amount. 

 

 





The views expressed by me are not necessarily those of my employer Chorus NZ Ltd


CYaBro
4582 posts

Uber Geek

ID Verified
Trusted

  #2818118 24-Nov-2021 00:15
Send private message

The ISP that got my quote from chorus didn’t add anything to the price.
In fact I was contacted by downer and chorus directly about it.
The money was however paid to the ISP who passed it on to chorus.
The initial fee I paid to the ISP for the quote was used as the first months payment for my connection.




Opinions are my own and not the views of my employer.


godber

70 posts

Master Geek

ID Verified
Trusted
Lifetime subscriber

  #2818886 24-Nov-2021 22:05
Send private message

Thank you all for your sage advice.  I will ask the ISP if they add a margin or a fee.

 

It might all be moot in any case. We have four neighbors interested.  

 

We rent the property on bookabach and randomly had people from a directional drilling company staying at the house.  We got the drillers to drill a pipe from the boundary to the house (about 100m) while they stayed. 

 

Two of neighbors asked what the pipe was for. When I told them they expressed interest in getting fibre installed. The minimum number of houses would be five, (three of the houses are owned by the same person).  I warned them they would likely be looking at a minimum of $4000-$5000 per house.

 

Even after I suggested this they are all still interested.

 

So now waiting on the Chorus subdivision or brownfields team to contact me.

 

I have to add the way Chorus join into a 12 core fibre cable is very smart.  Most people who replied will know how the fibre is split out but I was impressed with how much thought has gone into it.  I have detailed here in case anyone not in the know is interested.

 

 

There are 12 cores in the distribution fibre running along the road.  Labelled 12F in the diagram.

 

The 12F (in black on the diagram) runs from the Whenuakite Exchange to at least the Coroglen cabinet (WEN/R).   On the Whenuakite side of the Flex Closure (joiner) cores 1, 2 and 4-6 are live and feed WEN/R and core 11 feeds Coroglen School.  Cores 9 and 10 do not go all the way back to Whenuakite, they have been terminated at a previous Flash-9 (Seeka Packhouse).

 

When adding the join cores 7-12 of the 12F are cut and spliced to a new 24 core cable (24F), cores 1 to 6 at the Whenuakite side and cores 7 to 12 at the Coroglen side. Core 1 of the 24F (being core 7 of the 12F) is used for the new 12 way splitter in the new Flash-9 and cores 2-6 of the 24F cable are spliced to cores 8-12 of the 24F cable thus completing the circuit of cores 8 to 12 of the 12F cable.

 

This means that should the Flash-9 need an extra feed to they can just use core 8 or 12 as it is already in the Flash-9.  It would also be possible to install a flex closure nearer to Coroglen and connect any one of the unused cores in the 12F cable (7, 9 or 10) to the splitter in the Flash-9, either to directly feed a property or to feed through another splitter in a subsequent Flash-9.

 

And all this can be done without having to open the Flex closure again.

 

The older type join that appears to have been used at the Seeka Packhouse (installed mid 2020) seems to terminate the two fibres being feed into the Flash-9 (cores 9 and 10) in the joiner without looping the extra cores (7, 8, 11 and 12) through the Flash-9.

 

What appears to be the newer style split is really very nice engineering and while sad that I have to pay for the extra engineering (and I know someone has to, so not complaining) it really does provide for flexibility and potentially allows more rural properties to use the 12F cable.

 

Am sure if any of my description is wrong someone will correct me. 

 

Finally a 144 core cable goes from Whenuakite to AMGxxx. Can anyone enlighten me as to what or were AMG is?  (Assuming not secret.)

 

 





 

Godfrey
Auckland/Coroglen, New Zealand
Quic Broadband - 4G Hyperfibre

 

Referral Link:
Quic (use R71004E9PVBJ on checkout for free setup)


atomeara
324 posts

Ultimate Geek


  #2819226 25-Nov-2021 15:56
Send private message

I assume you mean WEN103/AMG879 Fibre Count: 144
It feeds Cooks Beach and Ferry landing for the UFB network there and also the 3 copper DSL cabinets they installed around 2019 running off it too.

 

 

 

There is also a 12F separate to that heading north to Whitianga (with a leg off to Hahei) and another 12F heading south Tairua.
These are old much older fibre running with a DWDM system running over them for transport/backhaul, it also provides north and south diversity for WEN Whenuakite for the UFB (FAN) network.
The copper network (REN) is only south facing due to the way it is designed and built.

 

 


 
 
 

Cloud spending continues to surge globally, but most organisations haven’t made the changes necessary to maximise the value and cost-efficiency benefits of their cloud investments. Download the whitepaper From Overspend to Advantage now.
CYaBro
4582 posts

Uber Geek

ID Verified
Trusted

  #2819232 25-Nov-2021 16:07
Send private message

godber:

 

Thank you all for your sage advice.  I will ask the ISP if they add a margin or a fee.

 

It might all be moot in any case. We have four neighbors interested.  

 

We rent the property on bookabach and randomly had people from a directional drilling company staying at the house.  We got the drillers to drill a pipe from the boundary to the house (about 100m) while they stayed. 

 

Two of neighbors asked what the pipe was for. When I told them they expressed interest in getting fibre installed. The minimum number of houses would be five, (three of the houses are owned by the same person).  I warned them they would likely be looking at a minimum of $4000-$5000 per house.

 

Even after I suggested this they are all still interested.

 

So now waiting on the Chorus subdivision or brownfields team to contact me.

 

I have to add the way Chorus join into a 12 core fibre cable is very smart.  Most people who replied will know how the fibre is split out but I was impressed with how much thought has gone into it.  I have detailed here in case anyone not in the know is interested.

 

 

There are 12 cores in the distribution fibre running along the road.  Labelled 12F in the diagram.

 

The 12F (in black on the diagram) runs from the Whenuakite Exchange to at least the Coroglen cabinet (WEN/R).   On the Whenuakite side of the Flex Closure (joiner) cores 1, 2 and 4-6 are live and feed WEN/R and core 11 feeds Coroglen School.  Cores 9 and 10 do not go all the way back to Whenuakite, they have been terminated at a previous Flash-9 (Seeka Packhouse).

 

When adding the join cores 7-12 of the 12F are cut and spliced to a new 24 core cable (24F), cores 1 to 6 at the Whenuakite side and cores 7 to 12 at the Coroglen side. Core 1 of the 24F (being core 7 of the 12F) is used for the new 12 way splitter in the new Flash-9 and cores 2-6 of the 24F cable are spliced to cores 8-12 of the 24F cable thus completing the circuit of cores 8 to 12 of the 12F cable.

 

This means that should the Flash-9 need an extra feed to they can just use core 8 or 12 as it is already in the Flash-9.  It would also be possible to install a flex closure nearer to Coroglen and connect any one of the unused cores in the 12F cable (7, 9 or 10) to the splitter in the Flash-9, either to directly feed a property or to feed through another splitter in a subsequent Flash-9.

 

And all this can be done without having to open the Flex closure again.

 

The older type join that appears to have been used at the Seeka Packhouse (installed mid 2020) seems to terminate the two fibres being feed into the Flash-9 (cores 9 and 10) in the joiner without looping the extra cores (7, 8, 11 and 12) through the Flash-9.

 

What appears to be the newer style split is really very nice engineering and while sad that I have to pay for the extra engineering (and I know someone has to, so not complaining) it really does provide for flexibility and potentially allows more rural properties to use the 12F cable.

 

Am sure if any of my description is wrong someone will correct me. 

 

Finally a 144 core cable goes from Whenuakite to AMGxxx. Can anyone enlighten me as to what or were AMG is?  (Assuming not secret.)

 

 

 

 

 

 

How did you find this info?





Opinions are my own and not the views of my employer.


godber

70 posts

Master Geek

ID Verified
Trusted
Lifetime subscriber

  #2819340 25-Nov-2021 19:23
Send private message

atomeara:

 

I assume you mean WEN103/AMG879 Fibre Count: 144
It feeds Cooks Beach and Ferry landing for the UFB network there and also the 3 copper DSL cabinets they installed around 2019 running off it too.

 

 

 

There is also a 12F separate to that heading north to Whitianga (with a leg off to Hahei) and another 12F heading south Tairua.
These are old much older fibre running with a DWDM system running over them for transport/backhaul, it also provides north and south diversity for WEN Whenuakite for the UFB (FAN) network.
The copper network (REN) is only south facing due to the way it is designed and built.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Thank you. I left the numbers off as I thought they may be confidential.





 

Godfrey
Auckland/Coroglen, New Zealand
Quic Broadband - 4G Hyperfibre

 

Referral Link:
Quic (use R71004E9PVBJ on checkout for free setup)


godber

70 posts

Master Geek

ID Verified
Trusted
Lifetime subscriber

  #2819357 25-Nov-2021 20:35
Send private message

CYaBro:

 

How did you find this info?

 

 

It is part of the install instructions for the Chorus tech that the ISP provided to me.

 

@CYaBro Thank you also for the answers you gave when I sent you a few questions by message, it helped us decide.

 

This has been a long process.

 

In 2014 @myfullflavour (who could not at that time provide the service) pointed me in the right direction and we got a desktop estimate of over $90k +GST from Spark, $90k +GST was not affordable. 

 

@atomeara got us a desktop estimate late 2019 in response to a VDSL question I asked, it was $20k +GST, unfortunately we did not have the money then.  I did message @atomeara when we wanted to convert the desktop estimate to a quote earlier this year, but did not receive a reply and so mistakenly assumed @atomeara had left geekzone.  The difference between the $90k desktop estimate and the $20k desktop estimate can be accounted for in the way the 12F cable can now be joined and the fact Whenuakite is now a UFB2 fibre enabled exchange, in 2014 it wasn't.

 

The current quote is $19K +GST

 

We will probably proceed with the install. For my wife and I, it will increase our overall 'happiness'.  It will allow us to work from our farm in the Coromandel at least 20 days a year, if we 'value' an extra day at the farm at $100 each per day then the $22k is paid off in just over 5 years.  Starlink might be an alternative, however we have some trees in the way and long term fibre will be better.

 

We actually ran a 12-way duct (12 x 5/3.5mm tubes) from the boundary.  It will allow us to have at least 12 ONTs installed (assuming Chorus allows that) even if there as only one fibre per tube (and multiple fibres can be blown down each tube). From the ONTs we could run private fibre to the neighbours.  It might turn out to be cheaper for the neighbours as there are plenty of tractors with mole plows available so we could easily plow fibre into our paddocks.

 

I actually thought of getting a Bitstream 4 P2P 1 Gbps down / 1 Gbps service installed, and sharing that, which would be legal to share provided an ISP agreed.  Ignoring the ISP costs, at the rates chorus charge ISPs you can get 8.5 standard Bitstream 2 1 Gbps services for the same price.  Using 8 individual ONTs would provide 2.5 Gbps down in aggregate vs 1 Gbps down on Bitstream 4 P2P and it would just be cleaner.  P2P is very expensive compared to GPON.

 

 





 

Godfrey
Auckland/Coroglen, New Zealand
Quic Broadband - 4G Hyperfibre

 

Referral Link:
Quic (use R71004E9PVBJ on checkout for free setup)


CYaBro
4582 posts

Uber Geek

ID Verified
Trusted

  #2819437 25-Nov-2021 22:14
Send private message

@godber It was a very long process for me too!
Originally contacted ISP not long after level 4 lockdown ended last year.
Fibre wasn’t live until mid December.
Original estimate was $10k but ended up being $14k.




Opinions are my own and not the views of my employer.


atomeara
324 posts

Ultimate Geek


  #2819683 26-Nov-2021 11:55
Send private message

godber:

 

CYaBro:

 

How did you find this info?

 

 

It is part of the install instructions for the Chorus tech that the ISP provided to me.

 

@CYaBro Thank you also for the answers you gave when I sent you a few questions by message, it helped us decide.

 

This has been a long process.

 

In 2014 @myfullflavour (who could not at that time provide the service) pointed me in the right direction and we got a desktop estimate of over $90k +GST from Spark, $90k +GST was not affordable. 

 

@atomeara got us a desktop estimate late 2019 in response to a VDSL question I asked, it was $20k +GST, unfortunately we did not have the money then.  I did message @atomeara when we wanted to convert the desktop estimate to a quote earlier this year, but did not receive a reply and so mistakenly assumed @atomeara had left geekzone.  The difference between the $90k desktop estimate and the $20k desktop estimate can be accounted for in the way the 12F cable can now be joined and the fact Whenuakite is now a UFB2 fibre enabled exchange, in 2014 it wasn't.

 

The current quote is $19K +GST

 

We will probably proceed with the install. For my wife and I, it will increase our overall 'happiness'.  It will allow us to work from our farm in the Coromandel at least 20 days a year, if we 'value' an extra day at the farm at $100 each per day then the $22k is paid off in just over 5 years.  Starlink might be an alternative, however we have some trees in the way and long term fibre will be better.

 

We actually ran a 12-way duct (12 x 5/3.5mm tubes) from the boundary.  It will allow us to have at least 12 ONTs installed (assuming Chorus allows that) even if there as only one fibre per tube (and multiple fibres can be blown down each tube). From the ONTs we could run private fibre to the neighbours.  It might turn out to be cheaper for the neighbours as there are plenty of tractors with mole plows available so we could easily plow fibre into our paddocks.

 

I actually thought of getting a Bitstream 4 P2P 1 Gbps down / 1 Gbps service installed, and sharing that, which would be legal to share provided an ISP agreed.  Ignoring the ISP costs, at the rates chorus charge ISPs you can get 8.5 standard Bitstream 2 1 Gbps services for the same price.  Using 8 individual ONTs would provide 2.5 Gbps down in aggregate vs 1 Gbps down on Bitstream 4 P2P and it would just be cleaner.  P2P is very expensive compared to GPON.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Sorry I come and go and miss messages sometimes.

 

I generally refer most NOA's to Full Flavor now, as the company I work for only does business broadband and most people get outraged at 4 figure prices, let alone 5.

 

I was recently estimated by Chorus 2k to upgrade the school to UFB.

 

When looking at you and your neighbors, the first connection will likely pay a lot more than the 2nd / 3rd / 4th (excluding the trenching which obviously varies depending on the terrain and distance)


DS248
1691 posts

Uber Geek

Lifetime subscriber

  #2921149 31-May-2022 23:01
Send private message

I see the Chorus BB checker is now reporting this for our house (interesting that VDSL may be available, given we are on VDSL!)

 

 

Where: ** Available on request - get connected to fibre with a customised, off-network installation with Chorus. Ask your provider for details.

 

 

 

I take it this is an NOA situation?

 

Asking our provider (VF) has not got very far.  Said because we are 'rural' (0.5km north of the Auckland urban boundary) we would have to follow up with Farmside.  I have now spoken with Farmside and they have sought an estimate from Chorus.  But from what the Farmside person said, it is not looking too positive; ie. likely prohibitively expensive (potentially in the 100k mark?!).  Will be interesting to see what comes back.   

 

Reason for enquiring is that we have now had four outages of our VDSL in the last 9 months (~22 hours yesterday-today, and in other cases 3 days to a week). In each case, ultimately get a txt saying problem now fixed, without a technician coming anywhere near our property (and with no info on what the problem is).

 

Not great for working from home!

 

 


Wheelbarrow01
1723 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted
Chorus

  #2921150 31-May-2022 23:13
Send private message

DS248:

 

Where: ** Available on request - get connected to fibre with a customised, off-network installation with Chorus. Ask your provider for details.

 

I take it this is an NOA situation?

 

 

Correct 👍





The views expressed by me are not necessarily those of my employer Chorus NZ Ltd


DS248
1691 posts

Uber Geek

Lifetime subscriber

  #2921360 1-Jun-2022 11:47
Send private message

Wheelbarrow01:

 

DS248:

 

Where: ** Available on request - get connected to fibre with a customised, off-network installation with Chorus. Ask your provider for details.

 

I take it this is an NOA situation?

 

 

Correct 👍

 

 

Thanks


Filter this topic showing only the reply marked as answer Create new topic





News and reviews »

Air New Zealand Starts AI adoption with OpenAI
Posted 24-Jul-2025 16:00


eero Pro 7 Review
Posted 23-Jul-2025 12:07


BeeStation Plus Review
Posted 21-Jul-2025 14:21


eero Unveils New Wi-Fi 7 Products in New Zealand
Posted 21-Jul-2025 00:01


WiZ Introduces HDMI Sync Box and other Light Devices
Posted 20-Jul-2025 17:32


RedShield Enhances DDoS and Bot Attack Protection
Posted 20-Jul-2025 17:26


Seagate Ships 30TB Drives
Posted 17-Jul-2025 11:24


Oclean AirPump A10 Water Flosser Review
Posted 13-Jul-2025 11:05


Samsung Galaxy Z Fold7: Raising the Bar for Smartphones
Posted 10-Jul-2025 02:01


Samsung Galaxy Z Flip7 Brings New Edge-To-Edge FlexWindow
Posted 10-Jul-2025 02:01


Epson Launches New AM-C550Z WorkForce Enterprise printer
Posted 9-Jul-2025 18:22


Samsung Releases Smart Monitor M9
Posted 9-Jul-2025 17:46


Nearly Half of Older Kiwis Still Write their Passwords on Paper
Posted 9-Jul-2025 08:42


D-Link 4G+ Cat6 Wi-Fi 6 DWR-933M Mobile Hotspot Review
Posted 1-Jul-2025 11:34


Oppo A5 Series Launches With New Levels of Durability
Posted 30-Jun-2025 10:15









Geekzone Live »

Try automatic live updates from Geekzone directly in your browser, without refreshing the page, with Geekzone Live now.



Are you subscribed to our RSS feed? You can download the latest headlines and summaries from our stories directly to your computer or smartphone by using a feed reader.