![]() ![]() |
Ragnor: Woosh is pretty well known in the community for below average performance and speed. It does not suprise me at all to hear they have applied a cheap and nasty solution for p2p traffic.
............
However applying a straight rate shape to p2p all the time smells of cost cutting at the expense at of the users performance. Basically it's a hack job to cover the fact they aren't paying for enough bandwidth for peak demand.
Please note: Any posts, comments, or contributions in this forum are posted by me as an individual acting in my own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of any company I work for, clients I've consulted for, or anyone else.
p2p can suck up all available international bandwidth in peak time and adversly affect regular usage. Bit Torrent actually exploits flaws in tcp/ip's congestion control mechanism to achieve such high download speeds (lots and lots of half open connections) at the expense of other users.
Many ISP's price data use to restrict usage and/or apply traffic management and shaping. Smart traffic managmenet is generally a good thing. Gaming, voip and other time sensitive traffic should be priority over downloads. Active users should generally get a fair share of the available bandwidth each. Lots of ISP's are doing smart stuff in this area like p2p caching servers..
However applying a straight rate shape to p2p all the time smells of cost cutting at the expense at of the users performance. Basically it's a hack job to cover the fact they aren't paying for enough bandwidth for peak demand.
lurkerbelow:
I dont know of one ISP in NZ that does this. I suspect certain legal issues arise when ISP's are holding possibly copyrightable material on there own servers.
Ray Taylor
There is no place like localhost
Spreadsheet for Comparing Electricity Plans Here
![]() ![]() |