Any idea why my New USB 3 Memory Stick is so slow?

Forums › Desktop computing › Any idea why my New USB 3 Memory Stick is so slow?

Hollow

29 posts

Geek

# 137885 12-Dec-2013 10:53

I just bought a new Apacer USB 3.0 memory stick over the weekend after putting up with (what I thought) were horribly slow USB 2.0 stick for the last few years, yet when I went to use it, there was really no improvement at all. After reading in the forums that some people were getting good results from Teracopy, I tried that also. I got a slight boost but still no where near what I was hoping for. I'm using Windows 8.1 and the stick is formatted to FAT32 (I copy between my PC and Macbook quite a bit).

Anyone got any idea what's going on or how I could improve it?

Here are the sort of results I'm getting:

1 | 2

BDFL - Memuneh
64691 posts

Uber Geek

Administrator

Trusted

Geekzone

Lifetime subscriber

# 950855 12-Dec-2013 10:58

It could be a lot of things, but I also noticed my Sony USB 3 is no faster on a USB 3 port than on a USB 2 port.

To compare, if I plug an external case with a 256GB SSD drive to my USB 3 port it just flies.

I guess that's why memory keys are cheap...

My technology disclosure | Digital Transformation | Enterprise Content Management | Customer Relationship Management | Data Insights, Business Intelligence and Advanced Analytics

Inphinity

2541 posts

Uber Geek

# 950895 12-Dec-2013 11:56

Just because it's USB3 doesn't mean the flash it uses is any faster. That said, Apacer tend to be pretty decent. What sort of read speeds do you get? Is whatever the copy source is on capable of speeds greater than ~5MB/sec? I just did a copy to/from my Apacer AH352 16GB and got a bit over 40MB/sec for write and jsut under 50MB/sec for read.

Do you have other USB3 devices that operate at full speed on those ports?

surfisup1000

4370 posts

Uber Geek

# 950927 12-Dec-2013 12:17

Check your usb3 drivers.

Generally on modern pc's they are included in the intel chipsets but in older mobo's usb3.0 was an add-on and you needed 3rd party drivers. Might be wrong, but i 'think' this was the situation.

I reckon your bottleneck is likely that the flash mem is just slow.

eg, i bought a cheap as chips sandisk 95MB/s SDHC card from amazon , and a good quality lexar usb3.0 card reader.... the real world write / read speed is 60/70MB/s.

kiwigeek1

622 posts

Ultimate Geek

# 950933 12-Dec-2013 12:38

on my HP probook I had heaps of trouble with USB 3 drivers doing what they meant to.
they always say usb 3 but worked at usb 2 speeds and if got usb 3 going it would drop
drive and reconnect randomly...

also took about 3-4 USB bubs to find one with better firmware that finally worked.

does it say using Renesas Electronics USB 3.0 Hub and have Host controller

ver 2.1.39.0

might not be latest.. latest I think had issues and rolled back.

if it doesnt detect right it seems to fall back to USB2 speeds.. like 11 to 16mb /s

USB 3.0 im NOW getting from 26mb/s to 85 mb/s .. however I have a a rated usb 3 key that says
can do that. costly at $45 for 32gb

usb 3 drives are constant

one thing i notice if you happen to loose power to a powered usb 3 hub.. and it turns back on

it drops to usb 2 speeds! even if unplug and plug in again

only way to fix is reboot win 7

not sure if affects usb 3 root hub.. the one connect to the laptop directly

CYaBro

3170 posts

Uber Geek

Subscriber

# 950944 12-Dec-2013 13:03

Just because it is USB3.0 doesn't mean it will be any faster.
There are different speeds of the actual flash memory chips inside the device and this is what matters.
Most, if not all, brands have different price levels for their USB sticks, the cheap ones will use slow flash memory while the more expensive models will be faster.
You should be able to find the specs of your flash drive on the Apacer website.

The speed can also depend on the size of the storage of the flash drive.

Hollow

29 posts

Geek

# 950978 12-Dec-2013 14:32

Inphinity: Just because it's USB3 doesn't mean the flash it uses is any faster. That said, Apacer tend to be pretty decent. What sort of read speeds do you get? Is whatever the copy source is on capable of speeds greater than ~5MB/sec? I just did a copy to/from my Apacer AH352 16GB and got a bit over 40MB/sec for write and jsut under 50MB/sec for read.

Do you have other USB3 devices that operate at full speed on those ports?

That's encouraging, my stick is also an Apacer AH352 16GB. I have a ASUS H87M-Pro Intel H87 MB which supposidly is Windows 8.1 compatable and has a USB 3.0 Boost that is supposed to enable 170% faster transfer speeds than traditional USB 3.0. I was copying from an internal SSD too so that shouldn't have provided any issues.

so looks like it could possibly be a usb 3.0 driver issue - I haven't yet been able find a USB driver on the ASUS site that is compatable with anything later than windows 7.

Thanks for all the comments!

Oblivian

3371 posts

Uber Geek

# 950986 12-Dec-2013 14:48

The southbridge controls the USB/SATA on the 87 range it seems.

Simple answer, DL the intel reference drivers :)

https://downloadcenter.intel.com/Detail_Desc.aspx?agr=Y&DwnldID=23061&ProdId=3603&lang=eng

Hammerer

2005 posts

Uber Geek

Lifetime subscriber

# 951007 12-Dec-2013 15:11

Do you have the manufacturers specs so you know what you are aiming for? To benchmark the drives against the manufacturers spec you should also use low level formatting software that is available from from the manufacturers.

Were you writing large or small files? Smaller files take have proportionately more overhead particularly if write amplification is involved where whole blocks are rewritten for smaller amounts of data.

Write speeds are typically slower than reads so have you also looked at read speeds for large files? That is more likely to indicate the actual speed. On my USB 2 flash drives average reads are six times faster than writes.

The memory might be faster but the memory controller might be more limited.

Regs

Cloud Guru
4060 posts

Uber Geek

Trusted

Snowflake

Subscriber

# 951067 12-Dec-2013 16:18

my 64gb apacer usb 3 sticks run at 80-100MB/s in a laptop with a usb3 port and when copying to an SSD disk. when copying to the sata disk its more like 50-80MB/sec.

4-5MB/sec is poor even for USB2. That's normally 25-30MB/sec

Sales Engineer
Snowflake
www.snowflake.com

about.me/nzregs
Twitter: @nzregs

alexx

635 posts

Ultimate Geek

# 951149 12-Dec-2013 18:08

Because when people go shopping for USB memory sticks, they tend to look at "how many GB for how many $$$$" and very little else (sometimes a nice colour helps). Flash memory makers know this.

For those that want more speed:
http://usbspeed.nirsoft.net/
http://usb-flash-drives.whoratesit.com/

#include <standard.disclaimer>

Hollow

29 posts

Geek

# 951154 12-Dec-2013 18:17

alexx: Because when people go shopping for USB memory sticks, they tend to look at "how many GB for how many $$$$" and very little else (sometimes a nice colour helps). Flash memory makers know this.

For those that want more speed:
http://usbspeed.nirsoft.net/
http://usb-flash-drives.whoratesit.com/

Yeah I kind of agree with that, but I still think I should still be getting much greater speeds than I am getting presently.

Will try some of the suggestions out when I get home later tonight.

Hollow

29 posts

Geek

# 951385 13-Dec-2013 08:20

Oblivian: The southbridge controls the USB/SATA on the 87 range it seems.

Simple answer, DL the intel reference drivers :)

https://downloadcenter.intel.com/Detail_Desc.aspx?agr=Y&DwnldID=23061&ProdId=3603&lang=eng

Just tried this but still getting the same sort of write speeds. Read speed is actually pretty good at around 53mb/s though not hugely faster than my USB 2.0 ports which are around around 40 mb/s

andrewNZ

2130 posts

Uber Geek

# 951409 13-Dec-2013 08:39

Please use the correct abbreviations so we know what speeds you're actually getting Mb (Mega bit), MB (Mega Byte), etc. mb (milli bits) isn't a real value :)

Is it actually connecting as USB3?
USB3 uses different connectors and if they're not making a connection because they're damaged or dirty, it'll be using the USB2 connections.

Location: Dunedin

Hollow

29 posts

Geek

# 951419 13-Dec-2013 08:58

My apologies, every value I gave should have been MB/s.

The stick is appearing as a USB3.0 FLASH DRIVE and both the memory stick and my PC are quite new and shouldn't be dirty or have any damage.

Cheers

Hollow

29 posts

Geek

# 951816 13-Dec-2013 18:24

I tried the stick on a 2013 Macbook with USB3 and i was still only getting a write speed of 5.3MB/s so looks like it's the stick that's the problem.

1 | 2