Geekzone: technology news, blogs, forums
Guest
Welcome Guest.
You haven't logged in yet. If you don't have an account you can register now.


1006 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 29


Topic # 27105 14-Oct-2008 17:04
Send private message

Right, I was wondering about the quality difference for the FTA channels over the currently 4 different methods you can receive them. Lets discuss the ones available on all 4 methods, C4 will do.

How would you rate the quality of SD transmissions over these 4. I know analogue would be the worst, then I assume sky. How does dvb-s and dvb-t compare when both are transmitting SD content? Is there much difference?

Is DVB-s freeview C4 much better than sky C4 (through component cables)? IS DVB-T C4 much better than DVB-s C4?

Is dvb-s freeview just as good as dvb-t if one excludes the certain programmes that are broadcast in HD?

Cheers




HTPC: Silverstone Crown CW02 case | Asus P5Q-L main board | Intel Dual core E8400 3.0GHz CPU | Thermalright Ultra120-Extreme Passive CPU Cooler | Blackgold BTG3540 TV Tuner & Hauppauge PVR-150 MCE Edition | Asus EN9600GT-Silent Passive GPU | 4GB Supertalent DDR2 800 RAM | 5+TB HDD space | LiteOn DH-401S BD/DVD/CD reader | Corsair HX-520w PSU | 1 single Noctua Silent Case fan | Logitech diNovo Bluetooth Media Desktop | Logitech Harmony 785 Universal Remote | Logitech Wireless Rumblepad 2 | Windows 7 Media Center, MediaBrowser & Arcsoft Total Media Theatre

Create new topic
4025 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 1076

Trusted

  Reply # 171110 14-Oct-2008 17:47
Send private message

DVB-S and DVB-T C4 are effectively the same because both transmissions are 576i, though the DVB-T feed might be a slighly higher bitrate. Can't comment on sky bitrate apart from that Freeview's version looks better.

1976 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 151

Trusted

  Reply # 171112 14-Oct-2008 17:50
Send private message

Now this is based on a number of factors, including the technology involved and typical conditions

From worst -> Best

Typical analogue NZ TV UHF
Typical analogue NZ TV VHG
Sky
freeview DVB-S
Very good analogue UHF/VHF
freeview|HD DVB-T

The surprise is that analogue can beat digital if you have a really really good picture.

For example my own TV2 and TV3 analogue reception is excellent and for a lot of content looks better than DVB-S. If the weather is bad I get a lot of ghosting and then DVB-S looks better.

Comparing an SD channel such as C4 my analogue isn't quite as good as freeview on DVB-S, but often looks better than Sky's signal. The DVB-T version of C4 does look a little bit better thanks to the higher bitrate H.264 encoder they use.

Another good example is TVNZ6. The DVB-T and DVB-S pictures are similar, but the DVB-T H.264 encoded one looks slightly better.

Now let the flames begin..




Generally known online as OpenMedia, now working for Red Hat New Zealand as a Solution Architect for all things Linux, Virtual and of course Cloud. Still playing with MythTV and digital media on the side.

Infrastructure Geek
4056 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 195

Trusted
Microsoft NZ
Subscriber

  Reply # 171180 14-Oct-2008 22:56
Send private message

openmedia: Now this is based on a number of factors, including the technology involved and typical conditions

From worst -> Best

Typical analogue NZ TV UHF
Typical analogue NZ TV VHG
Sky
freeview DVB-S
Very good analogue UHF/VHF
freeview|HD DVB-T

The surprise is that analogue can beat digital if you have a really really good picture.


isnt DVB-S broadcast with a higher resolution than the standard analog broadcasts? I cant recall the technical details but i'm certain i've never seen an analog broadcast look better than a freeview dvb-s broadcast on my 40" SD plasma screen.

I've definately seen some crappy SKY dvb-s broadcasts though - some of their channels were using such low bitrates they would have looked worse than an analog broadcast of the same content....




Technical Evangelist
Microsoft NZ
about.me/nzregs
Twitter: @nzregs


1976 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 151

Trusted

  Reply # 171218 15-Oct-2008 09:05
Send private message

Regs:
openmedia: Now this is based on a number of factors, including the technology involved and typical conditions

From worst -> Best

Typical analogue NZ TV UHF
Typical analogue NZ TV VHG
Sky
freeview DVB-S
Very good analogue UHF/VHF
freeview|HD DVB-T

The surprise is that analogue can beat digital if you have a really really good picture.




isnt DVB-S broadcast with a higher resolution than the standard analog broadcasts? I cant recall the technical details but i'm certain i've never seen an analog broadcast look better than a freeview dvb-s broadcast on my 40" SD plasma screen.



I've definately seen some crappy SKY dvb-s broadcasts though - some of their channels were using such low bitrates they would have looked worse than an analog broadcast of the same content....


Most DVB-S is broadcast in 720x576 and flagged as either 16:9 or 4:3, with the exception of some Sky channels which broadcast at a lower resolution.

In general this is an equivalent digital resolution to the analogue broadcast.

When considering picture quality you need to look at some high motion footage, or something using strobe lights. Often broadcast MPEG2 can't keep up with the picture changes which can look perfectly fine on old analogue TV.

Steve




Generally known online as OpenMedia, now working for Red Hat New Zealand as a Solution Architect for all things Linux, Virtual and of course Cloud. Still playing with MythTV and digital media on the side.

6640 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 551

Trusted

  Reply # 171219 15-Oct-2008 09:06
Send private message

C4 is broadcast at 576i on all formats, possibly not a good channel to compare but....

Analogue can be good, I agree with openmedia on that, because it has no compression applied to it.  If you've got a great signal, then the old analogue format can be good, but mostly it's not broadcast in widescreen in NZ.  The digital broadcasts are all in widescreen and I'd say that alone makes them the way to go for anyone with a new TV.

The freeview uhf compression format is mpeg4 vs mpeg2 for the satellite.  Also the tv1/tv2/tv3 freeview uhf channels have been upscaled using an expensive scaler, so they are more likely to appear better than their freeview satellite alternatives.  Freeview formats, be it sat or uhf, all have more bandwidth to give to their channels than sky does.  That's the tradeoff sky has to make to give you 50 channels of tv.

If you want TV for the standard channels only, then freeview will give you the best picture, and if you live in a freeview uhf area, then really that is the way to go.  If you want SKY pay for live sport/movies etc, then there is only one option, -SKY.  If you have an older TV ('square shape, not widescreen) and only want normal channels, and get good reception, then really it's easiest to stick with the analogue.

4853 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 91

Trusted

  Reply # 171227 15-Oct-2008 10:01
Send private message

I guess from my POV the quality is in this order

Analogue - I have terrible analogue reception even though I have a good external antenna because of hills etc
Analogue via TCL cable - basically receiving the analogue channels down the cable that TCL don't encrypt - okay
Digital (TCL) - on TV1, TV2, TV3 it's pretty good and has improved lately
DVB-S - despite being MPEG2 and SD I find on TV1, TV2 and TV3, the PQ is very good
DVB-T - excellent on the SD stuff that's upconverted and of course on true HD stuff, really nice

Don't have Sky but I would imaging it would be close to TCL - others may have different views on this





System One: Popcorn Hour A200,  PS3 SuperSlim, NPVR and Plex Server running on Gigabyte Brix (Windows 10 Pro), Sony BDP-S390 BD player, Pioneer AVR, Raspberry Pi running Kodi and Plex, Panasonic 60" 3D plasma, Google Chromecast

System Two: Popcorn Hour A200 ,  Oppo BDP-80 BluRay Player with hardware mode to be region free, Vivitek HD1080P 1080P DLP projector with 100" screen. Harman Kardon HK AVR 254 7.1 receiver, Samsung 4K player, Google Chromecast

 


My Google+ page 

 

 

 

https://plus.google.com/+laurencechiu

 

 


21121 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 4209

Trusted
Subscriber

  Reply # 171392 15-Oct-2008 23:45
Send private message

I would put analog ahead of sky for picture quality, sky is pretty bad.

I havent seen freeview dvb-s but I assume its better then the sky one,

dvb-t of course blows both away.

Lack of widescreen on C4 isnt really an issue since most of what they play is postagestamped anyway so you still get black on all 4 sides on digital, its just a bit smaler then when viewing analog.




Richard rich.ms

Create new topic

Twitter »

Follow us to receive Twitter updates when new discussions are posted in our forums:



Follow us to receive Twitter updates when news items and blogs are posted in our frontpage:



Follow us to receive Twitter updates when tech item prices are listed in our price comparison site:





News »

N4L helping TAKA Trust bridge the digital divide for Lower Hutt students
Posted 18-Jun-2018 13:08


Winners Announced for 2018 CIO Awards
Posted 18-Jun-2018 13:03


Logitech Rally sets new standard for USB-connected video conference cameras
Posted 18-Jun-2018 09:27


Russell Stanners steps down as Vodafone NZ CEO
Posted 12-Jun-2018 09:13


Intergen recognised as 2018 Microsoft Country Partner of the Year for New Zealand
Posted 12-Jun-2018 08:00


Finalists Announced For Microsoft NZ Partner Awards
Posted 6-Jun-2018 15:12


Vocus Group and Vodafone announce joint venture to accelerate fibre innovation
Posted 5-Jun-2018 10:52


Kogan.com to launch Kogan Mobile in New Zealand
Posted 4-Jun-2018 14:34


Enable doubles fibre broadband speeds for its most popular wholesale service in Christchurch
Posted 2-Jun-2018 20:07


All or Nothing: New Zealand All Blacks arrives on Amazon Prime Video
Posted 2-Jun-2018 16:21


Innovation Grant, High Tech Awards and new USA office for Kiwi tech company SwipedOn
Posted 1-Jun-2018 20:54


Commerce Commission warns Apple for misleading consumers about their rights
Posted 30-May-2018 13:15


IBM leads Call for Code to use cloud, data, AI, blockchain for natural disaster relief
Posted 25-May-2018 14:12


New FUJIFILM X-T100 aims to do better job than smartphones
Posted 24-May-2018 20:17


Stuff takes 100% ownership of Stuff Fibre
Posted 24-May-2018 19:41



Geekzone Live »

Try automatic live updates from Geekzone directly in your browser, without refreshing the page, with Geekzone Live now.



Are you subscribed to our RSS feed? You can download the latest headlines and summaries from our stories directly to your computer or smartphone by using a feed reader.

Alternatively, you can receive a daily email with Geekzone updates.