![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
|
nathan:GV27:
People are forgetting kids cannot be offloaded onto grandparents with this. Closing schools is massive, it would close down an enormous portion of the workforce.
Kids can’t socially distance themselves. All the countries with the start of run away infections have closed schools
Once the virus infects ~1% social distance mechanisms aren’t necessary as they become completely ineffective
I do hope you're not suggesting that if/when community infection rate reaches 1% (ie 50,000 "active" cases in NZ) that we "give up".
Social distance mechanisms will still continue to work - if not to halt the spread - then to slow it down.
All epidemic modeling has to take into account social behaviour. That's so variable and hard to measure that effectiveness of (social) controls can only be estimated in retrospect. If you could achieve 100% social isolation for a few weeks globally, then Covid 19 would cease to exist (unless it's still active in the intermediate host species from which it came to us).
So the 1% figure you quote - I don't know where you came up with it - it really isn't useful, accurate, I expect it was pulled out of a hat.
msukiwi:
Do Sky have any brains?
Given the circumstances, this is tonight's Premiere Movie!
HAPPY DEATH DAY 2U (M-CLV) TUESDAY 17 MARCH8:30 PM - 10:15 PMPREMIERE MOVIESCHANNEL 030
Its a movie, for entertainment purposes, if you don't want to watch it, then don't.
The really difficult issue is how will the shut-out be wound down ? If NZ measures are successful we will have no immunity but there will be some covid-19 in the wild most everywhere else. This side of effective treatment or a vaccine, infection could spread to NZ once restrictions are relaxed. If this happens mid-winter with seasonal flu as well it will be doubly stressing the health services.
I am assuming an extended period of restrictions might last to at least springtime. We are about to find out how self-sufficient NZ really is.
The controls being implemented to try to slow the spread of Covid 19 should be equally effective in slowing the spread of influenza. But everybody able to needs to get a flu shot anyway - we really do need a mild flu season.
Scotdownunder:
The really difficult issue is how will the shut-out be wound down ? If NZ measures are successful we will have no immunity but there will be some covid-19 in the wild most everywhere else. This side of effective treatment or a vaccine, infection could spread to NZ once restrictions are relaxed. If this happens mid-winter with seasonal flu as well it will be doubly stressing the health services.
I am assuming an extended period of restrictions might last to at least springtime. We are about to find out how self-sufficient NZ really is.
There are reports that say that getting Covid-19 does not give immunity to reinfection. This however has not been proven.
Scott3:Geektastic: We won’t be accused of xenophobia.
That’s a ludicrous suggestion that only the most woke of snowflakes would suggest as the reason the border is closed.
Border is only closed to those that have been in china or Iran in the last 14 days (plus diamond princess).
It is open to everybody else. (Subject to self isolation requirement).
Anyone thinking there are no idiots just "jumping bail" on the self-isolation is being naive.
Please support Geekzone by subscribing, or using one of our referral links: Samsung | AliExpress | Wise | Sharesies | Hatch | GoodSync | Backblaze backup
FRED99
(I do hope you're not suggesting that if/when community infection rate reaches 1% (ie 50,000 "active" cases in NZ) that we "give up".
Social distance mechanisms will still continue to work - if not to halt the spread - then to slow it down.
All epidemic modeling has to take into account social behaviour. That's so variable and hard to measure that effectiveness of (social) controls can only be estimated in retrospect. If you could achieve 100% social isolation for a few weeks globally, then Covid 19 would cease to exist (unless it's still active in the intermediate host species from which it came to us).
So the 1% figure you quote - I don't know where you came up with it - it really isn't useful, accurate, I expect it was pulled out of a hat.)
I disagree, I think at 50,000 we might as well at least partially give up. The best we can do at that point is ring fence the most venerable. Schools & Work places can't stay closed indefinitely,
These would have to be re-opened eventually. I understand not allowing mass gatherings, like sports events, church services etc. But you can't just shut up shop indefinitely.
How long you can lock up the elderly for anyway, it gets to a point where I am sure many of them would rather run the gauntlet & enjoy life. Play golf then have a beer, meet friends, go to yoga classes etc. Than
be prisoners in their own home.
Scotdownunder:
The really difficult issue is how will the shut-out be wound down ? If NZ measures are successful we will have no immunity but there will be some covid-19 in the wild most everywhere else. This side of effective treatment or a vaccine, infection could spread to NZ once restrictions are relaxed. If this happens mid-winter with seasonal flu as well it will be doubly stressing the health services.
I am assuming an extended period of restrictions might last to at least springtime. We are about to find out how self-sufficient NZ really is.
I guess it depends on how effective all the measures are, the more people have had it the quicker they will be lifted/relaxed. I can't see it happening but, what happens if the measures are really effective and only a small % of the population gets the virus? Do the measures stay in effect for a year until a vaccine is ready?
dogstar001:
How long you can lock up the elderly for anyway, it gets to a point where I am sure many of them would rather run the gauntlet & enjoy life. Play golf then have a beer, meet friends, go to yoga classes etc. Than
be prisoners in their own home.
That is not self isolation. Go for a walk, cycle, run. Alone. See someone else, just step aside 2+ metres and say hi. Words of Dr Bloomfield on one announcement. In your example, the elderly can play golf, have a beer, sit with friends, just keep clear of each other.
MikeB4:
Scotdownunder:
The really difficult issue is how will the shut-out be wound down ? If NZ measures are successful we will have no immunity but there will be some covid-19 in the wild most everywhere else. This side of effective treatment or a vaccine, infection could spread to NZ once restrictions are relaxed. If this happens mid-winter with seasonal flu as well it will be doubly stressing the health services.
I am assuming an extended period of restrictions might last to at least springtime. We are about to find out how self-sufficient NZ really is.
There are reports that say that getting Covid-19 does not give immunity to reinfection. This however has not been proven.
There's good evidence that resistance to coronaviruses doesn't last long term, but the reported cases of supposed reinfection are probably explained by the infection not having been eliminated. As we know, the rRT-PCR tests are far from perfect, false negatives are common, it takes a long time to recover.
There has already been one study carried out on Rhesus Monkeys using the SARS-CoV2 virus, they couldn't be reinfected after recovery. (yes I know - that's an animal trial - but it's a reasonably good indication)
MadEngineer: Courier post no longer taking signatures for deliveries.
"no longer" ? I haven't been asked to sign a 'signature required' delivery in a very long time. 😀
|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |