One more Cabinet

Forums › New Zealand Broadband › One more Cabinet

1 | 2

sbiddle

30853 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 9996

Retired Mod

Trusted

Biddle Corp

Lifetime subscriber

#1014433 28-Mar-2014 10:40

DSLAMs are cheap - but we really need to understand what the actual problem is first of all. If individual owners don't want to pay for a fixed monthly connection in each place (as it would seem they don't want do as that's the option they have right now), then a wireless hotspot solution for all apartments would seem to be the best option.

networkn

Networkn
32871 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 15464

ID Verified

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#1014554 28-Mar-2014 13:08

sbiddle: DSLAMs are cheap - but we really need to understand what the actual problem is first of all. If individual owners don't want to pay for a fixed monthly connection in each place (as it would seem they don't want do as that's the option they have right now), then a wireless hotspot solution for all apartments would seem to be the best option.

Which is what they have now, except it's on a ADSL2 connection getting about 12Mbps. I was hoping VDSL would improve performance to reasonable levels, for minimal cost.

plambrechtsen

1948 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 459
Inactive user

#1014555 28-Mar-2014 13:10

networkn:
sbiddle: DSLAMs are cheap - but we really need to understand what the actual problem is first of all. If individual owners don't want to pay for a fixed monthly connection in each place (as it would seem they don't want do as that's the option they have right now), then a wireless hotspot solution for all apartments would seem to be the best option.

Which is what they have now, except it's on a ADSL2 connection getting about 12Mbps. I was hoping VDSL would improve performance to reasonable levels, for minimal cost.

A VDSL ISAM fully loaded to support 600 folks or so costs about $150k to get in.... So it's not exactly minimal cost.

networkn

Networkn
32871 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 15464

ID Verified

Trusted

Lifetime subscriber

#1014556 28-Mar-2014 13:12

plambrechtsen:
networkn:
sbiddle: DSLAMs are cheap - but we really need to understand what the actual problem is first of all. If individual owners don't want to pay for a fixed monthly connection in each place (as it would seem they don't want do as that's the option they have right now), then a wireless hotspot solution for all apartments would seem to be the best option.

Which is what they have now, except it's on a ADSL2 connection getting about 12Mbps. I was hoping VDSL would improve performance to reasonable levels, for minimal cost.

A VDSL ISAM fully loaded to support 600 folks or so costs about $150k to get in.... So it's not exactly minimal cost.

Well it would be to the end user.

pjamieson

441 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 90

Trusted

Chorus

#1027969 19-Apr-2014 22:21

raytaylor:
plambrechtsen: I personally doubt Chorus would further cabinetise in that area, unless you and everyone else were interested in funding it. There are so many places that don't even have decent ADSL1 speeds, so with you getting ADSL2 and on the cusp of VDSL at around 900 meters from the exchange you are doing pretty well.

Was at a meeting with James (CEO of Inspire) a couple of weeks ago. He was complaining that he has been asking Chorus to build a cabinet that the residents were willing to pay for ($50k) and it was falling on deaf ears. Chorus dont appear to have any specific person you can talk to about such proposals. The buildout plans comes from government agreements and statisticians (monkeys with spreadsheets)

It won't be $50k, try at least 3 times that.

Zeon

3926 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 759

Trusted

#1027974 19-Apr-2014 22:45

plambrechtsen:
networkn:
sbiddle: DSLAMs are cheap - but we really need to understand what the actual problem is first of all. If individual owners don't want to pay for a fixed monthly connection in each place (as it would seem they don't want do as that's the option they have right now), then a wireless hotspot solution for all apartments would seem to be the best option.

Which is what they have now, except it's on a ADSL2 connection getting about 12Mbps. I was hoping VDSL would improve performance to reasonable levels, for minimal cost.

A VDSL ISAM fully loaded to support 600 folks or so costs about $150k to get in.... So it's not exactly minimal cost.

How much of that is "planning, resource consents, shining bureaucrat bald head costs..." etc.?

Speedtest 2019-10-14

Apple TV

Stream your favourite shows now on Apple TV (affiliate link).

NonprayingMantis

6434 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 1528

#1027978 19-Apr-2014 23:02

Zeon:
plambrechtsen:
networkn:
sbiddle: DSLAMs are cheap - but we really need to understand what the actual problem is first of all. If individual owners don't want to pay for a fixed monthly connection in each place (as it would seem they don't want do as that's the option they have right now), then a wireless hotspot solution for all apartments would seem to be the best option.

Which is what they have now, except it's on a ADSL2 connection getting about 12Mbps. I was hoping VDSL would improve performance to reasonable levels, for minimal cost.

A VDSL ISAM fully loaded to support 600 folks or so costs about $150k to get in.... So it's not exactly minimal cost.

How much of that is "planning, resource consents, shining bureaucrat bald head costs..." etc.?

are you suggesting they install cabinets without any planning and without acquiring resource consent??
(the 'bald head' costs i can do without I suppose)

pjamieson

441 posts

Ultimate Geek
+1 received by user: 90

Trusted

Chorus

#1027979 19-Apr-2014 23:04

Zeon:
plambrechtsen:
networkn:
sbiddle: DSLAMs are cheap - but we really need to understand what the actual problem is first of all. If individual owners don't want to pay for a fixed monthly connection in each place (as it would seem they don't want do as that's the option they have right now), then a wireless hotspot solution for all apartments would seem to be the best option.

Which is what they have now, except it's on a ADSL2 connection getting about 12Mbps. I was hoping VDSL would improve performance to reasonable levels, for minimal cost.

A VDSL ISAM fully loaded to support 600 folks or so costs about $150k to get in.... So it's not exactly minimal cost.

How much of that is "planning, resource consents, shining bureaucrat bald head costs..." etc.?

Or "Living in the real world, running a business, covering your costs and not expecting the commerce commission to see real sense".

plambrechtsen

1948 posts

Uber Geek
+1 received by user: 459
Inactive user

#1027980 19-Apr-2014 23:07

Zeon:
plambrechtsen:
networkn:
sbiddle: DSLAMs are cheap - but we really need to understand what the actual problem is first of all. If individual owners don't want to pay for a fixed monthly connection in each place (as it would seem they don't want do as that's the option they have right now), then a wireless hotspot solution for all apartments would seem to be the best option.

Which is what they have now, except it's on a ADSL2 connection getting about 12Mbps. I was hoping VDSL would improve performance to reasonable levels, for minimal cost.

A VDSL ISAM fully loaded to support 600 folks or so costs about $150k to get in.... So it's not exactly minimal cost.

How much of that is "planning, resource consents, shining bureaucrat bald head costs..." etc.?

I don't know any of the figures (and if I did I wouldn't be able to post them) so all of my views are gleemed from public information..

This is my understanding of the items that cost:

- The physical cabinet (made in NZ I believe, half of it is for the ISAM, and the other half is the MDF aka patch panel)
- The trenching in of fibre from wherever it is closest to the cabinet. I hear that runs in at around 10k per km.
- Resource consent
- Labour from one team to get the physical cabinet in there
- Labour from an engineering team to extend the copper pairs from both the exchange and out to the customers into the MDF in the cabinet.
- Then coordinating with each RSP to groom each customer in Chorus from the old cabinet to the new one, being that these folks are BUBA they will stay on BUBA but have a new calling station id so the RSP will need to have them setup to go otherwise they won't get service when they are cut-across.

I think to take all that into account, 150k is pretty cheap...

1 | 2